Sunday, July 24, 2011
CPSIA - Rachel Weintraub's Distortions Justify Dem Refusal to Amend the CPSIA
It is worth noting that a much more erudite explanation of the pending CPSIA Amendment (ECADA) was published side-by-side with Weintraub's smear campaign, namely "Fix bill would make products safer, not less so" by Eric Stone. For those who don't know Eric, his credentials include more than 33 years at the CPSC, including as Legal Director in the Office of Compliance and as Acting Director of the Recalls and Compliance Division. He faced the real questions of safety at the agency and made the judgments subject to the scrutiny of the public, Congress and the legal system.
As Eric Stone notes, "In crafting its new safety bill, Congress proved that moral outrage and good intentions do not necessarily result in good law." Amen.
My responses to Ms. Weintraub are in blue and red.
Don't set safety clock backwards for kids products
By Rachel Weintraub
Florida Sun-Sentinel
July 24, 2011
The House Energy and Commerce Committee will soon vote on HR 1939, the "Enhancing CPSC Authority and Discretion Act of 2011," or ECADA, a bill that guts the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, a vital law that keeps unsafe toys and other dangerous products off the shelves.
RW - It is a typical ploy of the Lefties opposing amendment of the CPSIA to frame everything in terms of toys. Toys are but one category affected by this awful law, but by using it as the CPSIA poster child, Weintraub puts you where she wants you - afraid of ECADA's potential effects on innocents by "evil toymakers". Aside from the fact that "evil toymakers" are no more or less prevalent in our society than any other category of "evil" something-or-anothers, Weintraub's characterization greatly distorts what CPSIA really is. CPSIA applies to ANYTHING that is intended to be sold to children. The list is well-known but, as a reminder, it includes t-shirts and shoes, carpets, pens, ATVs, bikes, books, science kits, DVDs and CDs, furniture, brass musical instruments, rhinestones and so on. Focusing on toys is just to get you going.
Congress passed CPSIA by an overwhelming, bipartisan vote in 2008, and President Bush signed the bill into law that year. After a year of careful deliberations, CPSIA's passage followed a record number of recalls of children's products that injured and killed children. The measure gave new life to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission, a weakened federal oversight agency that had failed in its meager efforts to protect the public's safety. The law represents a giant step forward in protecting America's children.
RW - Another defensive ploy of the CPSIA defenders is the "infallibility of Congress" argument, namely that everyone voted for it so why is anyone against it now. This argument only makes sense if you don't think about it too much. For one thing, the CPSIA was passed in anger. Have you ever said or done anything in anger that you later regretted? That point aside, it is important to consider that this law was devised by a Dem-controlled Congress dominated by the strong-willed Left Winger Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco. Pelosi takes no prisoners and tolerates no dissent among her Dem followers. The law was dictated by Dems to the Republicans, as insiders acknowledge, and was passed just ahead of the Obama wave in the Presidential election cycle. The votes of Republicans for such an extreme law cannot properly be deemed "voluntary" in any conventional sense. Everyone knew this law was a great chess move by the Dems, forcing Republicans to go along, and even President Bush got into the act by agreeing to sign to protect his party. Weintraub's distorted rewrite of history is a good illustration of the rule that history is written by the victors. Consider the source . . . .
CPSIA currently requires that children's products be tested for safety before they arrive on store shelves — something that many consumers already assumed was happening.
RW - Another oft-repeated consumer group assertion, never proven. It has always struck me that this argument is just transference. I have no doubt that folks like Weintraub always wanted this, and simply assume that everyone shares their "common sense" desires and fears.
It sets limits on lead in children's products, sets infant product and toy safety standards, and bans certain phthalates, which are chemicals linked to a variety of health risks. The law also creates a much-needed public database where consumers can easily report and research product safety problems.
We have already seen the successful results of CPSIA. Most recently, on June 28, 2011, new crib standards went into effect, which means that cribs sold in stores must meet the most protective safety standards in the world. This will give parents and caregivers the long-overdue peace of mind that when they purchase a new crib, it will be a truly safe place for their baby.
Some small toy manufacturers have raised concerns about the costs of testing their products to the new safety standards. These concerns, and narrowly tailored ways to reduce the costs for very small children's product manufacturers, are useful to discuss.
RW - The nauseating cynicism of this remark cannot go unaddressed. Ms. Weintraub argued for two years that the agency "needed time" to implement the law and to work out the kinks. At that time, she and the other Dems argued that there was "nothing wrong" with the CPSIA that the CPSC couldn't fix in its implementation and that consideration of legislative fixes was not merited until that process was complete. Three years later we are still subject to this on-going implementation . . . that is, those of us who haven't gone belly up. Weintraub expressed little interest in "discussing" these issues way back then.
Later, Ms. Weintraub tried to justify Henry Waxman's lame-o effort at a cursory amendment of the CPSIA that offers negligible relief. Here is an excerpt from her House testimony dated April 28, 2010 (15 months ago) on this topic:
"Special provisions for small businesses includes allowing certain businesses to be exempt from third party testing when the Commission finds that reasonable testing methods assure compliance with relevant consumer product safety standards. We believe, however, that the term "small batch manufacturer" is defined too broadly. We commend the fact that the language does not allow small batch manufacturers to obtain exceptions for durable infant or toddler products or lead paint, cribs, pacifiers, small parts, children’s metal jewelry, baby bouncers, walkers and jumpers. Because of the fatal nature of the defects in many of these types of products, as demonstrated by recalls in the past, all manufacturers should be required to meet the same safety and testing requirements. We could not accept a broadening of either the definition of small batch manufacturer or a limitation of those products not covered by this provision." [Emphasis added]
The CPSC never did identify any such "reasonable testing methods" even though the "hunt" has gone on for three years now. Even Ms. Weintraub must blush when she tells you that such issues deserve "discussion".
Unfortunately, instead of fixing concerns of the truly small manufacturers, HR 1939 goes too far and rolls back important consumer protections created by CPSIA in a number of ways.
HR 1939 reduces safety testing for children's products by undermining independent safety testing requirements for most children's products. This would place us in the same dangerous situation we were in 2007 and 2008, when millions of beloved toys were recalled because of excessive lead paint, strong magnets that when swallowed in multiples could rip apart a child's intestines and chemicals that turned into the date-rape drug when swallowed.
RW - The issue in 2007 and 2008 was NOT that the law did not protect consumers. In fact, if anything, the issue was that the agency did not (adequately) protect consumers. The bad behavior that prompted the CPSIA was clearly illegal, as the agency could act to enforce if it so chose. After all, they issued hundreds of recalls under prior law. Please pause and give that a little thought. Weintraub's argument is pure urban legend, but helpful urban legend for the tall tale she is trying to sell.
It is also worth noting that Gib Mullan, the then head of Compliance at the CPSC admitted during the second session question-and-answer session at the CPSC Tracking Labels hearing on May 12, 2009 that the agency had never seen the strong magnet hazard evidenced by Magnetix previously and at first mistook it as a "small parts" issue. No law can prevent the unknown and the not previously experienced from happening. That is a safety fantasy. In addition, the "date-rape drug" incident involved an unapproved change in materials by a factory which no testing regime would have caught (CPSIA or not). The safety issue was completely unprecedented and the product was immediately recalled without argument by a very safety conscious toymaker. Only in Weintraub's self-serving world is this incident useful . . . to terrorize. Under most circumstances, it should be held up as a great public-private partnership and a sign that there are good people in the industry.
Under this bill, virtually all toys would no longer have to be tested for safety before they come into our homes — these products would be safety-tested only if and when CPSC undertook a laborious and complicated series of steps, including a cost-benefit analysis that emphasizes testing costs over health and safety benefits.
RW - Weintraub here spurns the President's Executive Order which MANDATES cost-benefit analysis by the CPSC. This arch position conforms to the surprising world view of Bob "Over My Dead Body" Adler and Inez Tenenbaum and certainly suits their Dem agenda. It is, unfortunately, an affront to the President's order. It is also economic nonsense. The OPPOSITE is correct, at least according to the Nobel Prize committee which awarded the 1991 Economics Prize to Ronald Coase for his work proving the need for regulatory cost-benefit analysis. Mr. Coase proved that ignoring cost-benefit analysis exposes all of us to the risk of being impoverished by government regulation. Thanks, Rachel, for the great idea!
It is unclear if CPSC would ever have the resources, time or information to complete what this bill demands of them, and it is therefore unclear if toys would ever be subject to independent testing. Independent testing not only prevents unnecessary injuries to children, but it can also prevent costly recalls for the manufacturer — a benefit to consumers as well as manufacturers.
RW - Here Rachel spins an even bigger tall tale, that preserving mandatory testing is in manufacturers' best interests. Apparently she is the only one who knows this. The people who actually work for companies affected by this rule have been howling for three years-plus. Here Rachel sets us all straight - the problem is we're wrong and she's right. Oh, now I see it! Her reasoning relies on the urban legend that in the absence of mandated testing, testing will cease. That's nonsense and is not supported by data. We have been testing since I got to Learning Resources, more than 20 years ago. So, if mandated testing is necessary to force testing, why were we testing way back then? Simple - we wanted to know we were complying with the standards. Standards drive testing, and enforcement can make testing prevalent, even universal. Mandated testing just raises costs, unfortunately. I have previously addressed this issue in a blogpost.
HR 1939 increases the amount of lead that would be permitted in children's products. CPSIA currently requires that all parts of children's products comply with a single, unambiguous standard for lead content. The proposed legislation would replace that clarity with a variety of standards that will be different depending on when the product was manufactured, the age of the child for whom the product is designed, whether it contains small parts and other factors. As a result, parents and other consumers will no longer have the confidence that all parts of all children's products are safe for their children. Lead is a known toxin where even small amounts can be harmful by decreasing a child's IQ. There is no reason why there shouldn't be a single, strong standard that simply keeps lead out of children's products.
RW - No reason, huh? Space does not permit me to reduce this absurd statement to rubble. I have been writing about the many common sense reasons to modify standards for three years now. ECADA as a matter of fact does very little to change standards except to codify some sensible concessions already made by the CPSC in stays applying to metals. If you are terrorized by the prospect of bicycle licking or the horrors of playing brass instruments in the school band, ECADA's changes will no doubt keep you up at night. Your fears are nothing that our proposed National Xanax Fund can't address.
The idea that different standards for different products aimed at different ages of children are somehow "defective" flies in the face not only of common sense but also the regulatory tradition at the CPSC. Before whackjobs began to dominate the safety discussion, and before the agency had its brain removed by Congress, the regulators were able to see the sense of crafting different rules for two year olds, six year olds and twelve year olds. And nobody thought the same rules should apply to rhinestones, pens, ATVs and books. If you are an experienced parent, you might know something about the need to modify rules for different ages of children. I have tried to regulate teenagers with the same rules as toddlers and received some "pushback". And when I try to keep toddlers safe by applying sensible rules designed for teenagers, that doesn't seem to work either.
HR 1939 undermines the effectiveness of the new crib safety standard. The bill would carve out a large exception to the bipartisan standard for cribs in child-care facilities. Under the bill, some child-care facilities would not have to replace existing fixed-side cribs even if the cribs violate the most basic crib safety standards — slats too far apart, non-compliant corner posts and failing mattress supports. Parents should be assured that the cribs their babies sleep in meet the strongest crib standards — both at home and in child-care facilities. The new, robust crib standards just went into effect for new cribs consumers can buy in stores and will apply to hotels, motels and child-care facilities in 18 months. Carving out child-care center cribs from this important protection moves the safety bar backwards.
RW - I have tried to avoid biting on the bait of the consumer group attacks on ECADA for the innocuous and sensible crib rule changes. It is in Ms. Weintraub's interest to make you feel that there is some sort of evil cabal dominating the Republican Party which somehow induces them to play roulette with your babies' lives. Anyhow, it's all a fiction but a helpful fiction to Ms. Weintraub's purpose, namely to subvert efforts to amend the CPSIA. Here is the "deadly" language that Ms. Weintraub protests so intensely:
"(B) SPECIAL RULE FOR FIXED-SIDE CRIBS SUBJECT TO CERTAIN STATE OR LOCAL LAW REQUIREMENTS- Paragraph (1) shall not apply to a fixed-side crib that has not been recalled and that is offered or provided for use in a licensed child care facility (other than a family child care home) that is subject to the following requirements under the law of a State or a political subdivision of a State: (i) The facility may not allow a child to remain in a crib for any significant amount of time while the child is awake, (ii) The facility may not place in a crib a child over the age of 16 months, (iii) An adult must be present whenever a child is in a crib."
Ms. Weintraub fails to deliver evidence that this exceedingly modest change could harm children based on actual injury data. She just wants you to push the panic button. ECADA only permits certain legacy FIXED SIDE cribs to remain in service. I thought fixed side cribs were the "answer". Not if their inclusion in ECADA might help get it passed, apparently.
HR 1939 allows the use of dangerous phthalates, which are hormone-disrupting chemicals that have been added to child-care articles like teething rings. This proposed bill would undermine CPSIA's landmark protections against phthalates by allowing large, undefined exemptions to both the prohibition and interim bans on phthalates in toys and child-care articles.
RW - Rachel again ventures into Whopperville to scare you about phthalates. Let's start by deciding how "dangerous" phthalates are. Ms. Weintraub reasons that if (the infallible) Congress banned them, the chemicals are ergo dangerous. The law, in fact, only bans three chemicals permanently and has directed the agency to investigate another three. On two previous occasions the agency has done just that . . . and concluded that phthalates don't present a risk to children. Ms. Weintraub omits to let you know that this provision was added to CPSIA at the last moment, without hearings or investigation, by California Senator Diane Feinstein of San Francisco and mentor to Nancy Pelosi. Aha. The science on phthalates is hardly an open-and-shut case - just watch 60 Minutes for perspective.
Ultimately, the greatest disservice to truth performed by Ms. Weintraub here is to distort what measly relief is being offered. ECADA only allows us to stop testing components that cannot be touched or licked by kids. That's it. The actual words: "ACCESSIBLE COMPONENT PARTS- Effective on the date of enactment of this Act, subsections (a) and (b)(1) and any rule promulgated under subsection (b)(3) shall apply to any accessible, plasticized component part of a children’s toy or child care article."
HR 1939 undermines the new CSPC product safety database. This new database allows public access to consumer complaints about product safety problems while giving the industry ample opportunity to view and comment upon such safety-related reports before they are posted. The database, available at http://www.saferproducts.gov, just went live in March. It will help consumers research products, help CPSC identify emerging hazard trends and help prevent unnecessary deaths and injuries. HR 1939 would place onerous hurdles on those seeking to report a safety problem, thereby discouraging the sharing of potentially lifesaving information with other consumers, companies and the government.
RW - Oy vey. There has been so much written on this subject that I can't bear to write it again. Ms. Weintraub intentionally ignores any point inconsistent with her political agenda. I will leave it at that, but feel free to pour over my prior writings on the database (tagged on the side of the blog) for further details.
Consumers demanded and received strong product safety reform from Congress in 2008. Undermining these important product safety improvements puts all of our children at risk. HR 1939 will not protect our children from product safety hazards. Rather, HR 1939 rolls the safety clock backwards and creates huge and unnecessary loopholes in our nation's safety net.
RW - One last point, to quote Eric Stone: "ECADA gives CPSC broader subpoena and investigational authority. Not surprisingly, opponents do not mention such provisions since they do not fit the 'Republican-industry conspiracy' narrative." I love the "Republican-industry conspiracy narrative" part. You can see how that might work well for Rachel.
Rachel Weintraub is director of product safety and senior counsel at the Consumer Federation of America in Washington, D.C.
Thursday, July 21, 2011
CPSIA - The CPSC Finds a New Way to Scr*w You
Commissioner Nancy Nord points out that this decision was a compromise of a Hobson's Choice nature:
"I joined in the majority’s vote only because of a negotiated agreement that we would stay enforcement of the testing mandate through December 31, 2011. Had we not reached this compromise, the testing requirement would have landed in the market’s lap in mid-October, just as stores are making their final preparations for the holiday season and small toy manufacturers are at the peak of filling orders. While I am relieved that companies will now have some time to find their way through the maze we have created, I have major concerns about why we are rushing to impose testing requirements to a standard we know is about to change."
What was that last bit?
Ummm, well, the ASTM is actually updating the F963 standard right now. It will be done by year end. and as a result of the CPSC's wondrous action this week, it will be a mandatory rule to test to an obsolete standard on January 1, 2012 - and probably necessary to test to the new standard, too! Doesn't that sound great?! Now you can deliver TWO test reports when one might have sufficed. But think of how much safer kids will be if you produce two almost identical passing test reports rather than just one. Just think of it . . . .
Ms. Nord explains:
"When the stay of enforcement is lifted on January 1, 2012, most likely we will be requiring testing to an outdated standard. This puts manufacturers and retailers potentially in the situation of having to do redundant or perhaps irrelevant testing – testing mandated by the CPSC to the old standard and testing mandated by the marketplace to the new standard. Because we are taking the position that these testing requirements are rules and can only be changed (after August, 2011) by notice and comment rulemaking, there is virtually no way to get the new notice of requirements in place and labs accredited before the standard becomes effective. This puts toy manufacturers in an untenable position. Our response is that we will address these problems as they come up but, of course, in the real world, this is no response at all to the potential for confusion we are creating."
I no longer have a sense of humor, so you can rest assured that I am NOT making this up.
Why the heck was the Commission in such a big, hot hurry to get this done? Again, Ms. Nord explains:
"We are able to issue this NOR [notice of requirements] without following the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), with its notice and comment requirement, because the CPSIA allows avoiding the APA until August 14, 2011. After that, we must ask for and consider public input. Therefore, by putting out the NOR today, (1) we did not need to ask for and consider public comment, but (2) we did need to stay enforcement to prevent an unnecessary economic train wreck for the toy industry immediately prior to the holidays."
Does anyone remember that Bob Adler has said publicly at several Commission meetings and hearings that he hates stays and doesn't want to vote for any more stays? So this vote avoids a public hearing and public comment (takes time, increases scrutiny, can limited flexibility) and it also avoids another stay process to extend this misery. The Dems on the Commission almost always vote as a pack. Can you connect the dots?
Not surprisingly, Nancy Nord can connect dots:
"However, if we waited, as sound regulatory policy would direct, we would have had to seek comments from the public. Apparently this public input process is too much of a burden for the agency, so if we have the opportunity to skirt the requirement we are more than happy to do that. Like a teenager with dad’s car keys, we want to squeeze in as much joy-riding as we can before the curfew hits. Our hasty decision does not achieve a net safety benefit, but it unfortunately does make things much more difficult than they need to be for the companies that are trying to understand and follow the law. . . . With its vote today, the CPSC has once again opted for rash action over rational action, to the quick and easy over the thoughtful and transparent. We know how to do better rulemaking; unfortunately, the majority today decided to push the ‘quick’ button instead of the ‘pause and think’ button."
Another Commission decision, another shellacking of the poor fools left serving children's markets. After three years of this torture, I am just not surprised. When will our country wake up and notice this travesty?
Monday, March 7, 2011
CPSIA - Age Limits under the CPSIA
Perhaps you remember that last year the CPSC "in cooperation with" a company called Maxfield and Oberton LLC announced a recall of "Buckyballs", a magnetic ball toy for age grading issues. What age grading issues, in particular? To quote the CPSC: "The high powered magnets sets were labeled "Ages 13+" and do not meet the mandatory toy standard F963-08 (effective August 17, 2009) which requires that such powerful magnets are not sold for children under 14. Magnets found by young children can be swallowed or aspirated. If more than one magnet is swallowed, the magnets can attract each other and cause intestinal perforations or blockages, which can be fatal." [Emphasis added]
Woot.com sells this product and I love their spin on this safety "issue":
"Buckin’ Magnets, How Do They Work? If you’re 14 or older, Buckyballs promise hours of addictive magnetic fun! If you’re 13 or under, they promise fatal intestinal blockages!"
They continue to explain:
"When exactly does a child become an adult? Different societies have answered this question with different milestones . . . . Now the Consumer Product & Safety Commission has settled it once and for all: a child is an adult when they can be trusted not to accidentally swallow tiny but powerful magnets. This past spring, the CPSC told the Buckyballs people that they had to yank their compulsively play-withable little magnetic to- uh, 'desk decorations' to re-label them 'Keep Away From All Children'. It seems the previous label of 'Ages 13+' did not comply with consumer guidelines that 'such powerful magnets are not sold for children under 14', because even 13-year-olds were liable to swallow them and suffer perforated or blocked intestines. Yep, that year from your 13th birthday to your 14th makes all the difference. 'Consumers should take the Buckyballs® high powered magnets away from children under 14 immediately,' quoth the CPSC. Kids swallow the darnedest things!" [Emphasis added]
Indeed.
Of course, this illustrates the U.S. safety mania at its worst and its most damaging. Is this product actually dangerous? If it is, why does the CPSC allow it to remain on the market? Does labeling actually "solve" the problem? If there really is a difference developmentally between a 13-year-old and a 14-year-old on mouthing toys, I think it is incumbent on the CPSC to tell the public what it is. In the CPSC publication, "Which Toys for Which Child", the agency acknowledges what is generally accepted as true, namely that children over three don't put objects in their mouth: "Most children in [the 3, 4, 5 age group] can begin using toys with smaller components. If child is still mouthing objects, select toys with without small parts." Duh. But 13-year-olds? This is regulatory hypocrisy at its worst.
As long as the mania continues, and as long as Congress continues to try to meddle either legislatively or by applying political pressure to the agency, we will continue to see economic victims and economic losses. Jobs will be lost. And the safety zealots will never be able to prove that anyone is safer.
The only thing that will be beyond dispute is that there are fewer companies making fewer products for sale into a smaller market. In other words, the law and the CPSC will have engineered their very own mini-recession.
Nice!
Sunday, February 27, 2011
CPSIA - My Testimony at the CPSC Hearing on 100 ppm Lead Standard 2-16-11
I have already published the links from the morning session. Viewing those clips before watching these clips may help you understand the flow of the argument better.
My full testimony:
[Notably, Ms. Tenenbaum cut me a break and let me go over my 10 minute allotment. I appreciate that courtesy.]
Commissioner Bob Adler questions me on the future of small business under the CPSIA and the need for the Commission to "follow the law" and implement the new standard despite the known consequences. This may be the most interesting interchange on the troubling issues under the CPSIA that I have participated in over the past four years. Check it out!
Commissioner Anne Northup asks about the ability of small business to obtain exemptions from the lead standard:
Commissioner Nancy Nord questions me about recycled materials, the cost implications of the new standards and injuries:
My call for a Five Year Stay on the new lead standard to allow for development of real injury statistics:
CPSIA - Consumer Group Testimony at CPSC 100 ppm Lead Standard Hearing 2-16-11
There is a lot of interesting testimony not in my clips, in particular in the afternoon. Although I think I am giving you a lot of relevant information in the clips I prepared, you are always welcome to check my work. I was quite impressed by the other presenters in the afternoon session, and the vigorous and interesting discussion that followed, but anticipated that you would not likely spend 4-5 hours watching the entire thing. If that floats your boat, please enjoy the links above.
In this post, I am embedding several clips from the morning session where the consumer groups stated their "case". I hesitate to characterize the testimony as "tall tales" but watch for yourself and see what you think. I have come to believe that the consumer groups will say ANYTHING to prop up their beloved CPSIA. [Consider the laughable "consumer poll" prepared by the Consumers Union promoted by Henry Waxman on the eve of the House Hearings on February 17, 2011. CU shamed themselves with this pathetic effort to "win" the debate with garbage polling data.] This may include the remarkable hyperbole in the clips below. We can speculate among ourselves whether Don Mays really shakes with fear at the thought of his daughter playing a brass instrument (he says he would be "very concerned").
Likewise, does Dr. Dana Best believe the nonsense statistics she flung around last week, like the one about ingesting an object with 300 ppm lead costing a child four IQ points? Please, dear G-d, that statistic is absurd on its face. The assertion that children are losing four IQ points from swallowing objects with trace levels of lead is irresponsible and misleading at a minimum, and something much worse if done with understanding or intent. The spectacle of Ms. Best's testimony included calculations of the "cost" of 1 million injured children DESPITE the inability of any consumer group to produce the case history of a single child injured from lead-in-substrate in children's product EVER. [I replied to Dana Best in my testimony.]
We must hold Dana Best responsible for the words that came from her mouth. Interestingly, Dr. Best was the only nominal author of the seminal testimony on lead in the CPSIA debacle. According to her colleague Cindy Pelligrini, Dr. Best didn't write her 2007 Congressional testimony (Pelligrini told me in a phone interview in 2008 that she wrote it for Dr. Best to deliver). Did Dr. Best write last week's testimony or was it another Cindy Pelligrini job? One can't help but wonder, given the shocking assertions based on misleading and garbled data. The AAP should be ashamed.
Dr. Dana Best (AAP) on losing IQ points and "millions" of victims:
Dr. Dana Best worries about children licking their bicycles . . .
My 17 year old daughter came along on this adventure and at breakfast the next morning, asked me why a child would like their sibling's bike rather than their parent's? After all, the adult bike is not regulated. I thought that was a good point, and added that if we posit that the child was going to lick something inappropriately, why would they lick a bike - why not the family car, which is coated with lead paint? Of course, I got it wrong. I was later corrected by someone who, after listening to this story, reminded me that the two year old wouldn't lick either bike or even the car - they would play in the pool of oil under the car. You can take it from there . . . .
Don Mays (Consumers Union) and Dana Best (AAP) on the frightening prospect of children playing in brass bands:
Thursday, February 24, 2011
CPSIA - ICPHSO Keynote Speech by Inez Tenenbaum
Reviewed 2010 efforts and achievements.
- New crib standards ("vastly improved").
- Baby bath seats and walker rules
- Cadmium in jewelry and children's products (held off what might have been a repeat of the lead recall fiasco). Turned back some shipments at the port. Are now screening for cadmium when they find low lead levels in children's products. Looking at cadmium in substrate in toys and in children's products generally. Technical staff has made their position on these issues "abundantly clear".
- Toy safety improved. Recalls reduced from 172 in 2008 to 50 in 2009 to 44 in 2010. Lead recalls in 2010 were THREE. [RW: Obviously, lead is a huge issue.] This has helped to "restore" consumer confidence in toys.
- Drywall initiative with HUD. Warnings about sleep positioners and baby slings.
As for 2011,
- Looking forward to a "civil discussion" of the issues in 2011. The Commissioners go out to lunch together and aren't like the Sopranos. The Commission is not fractious. 85% of our votes are unanimous. We do disagree from time to time, but "hope to do so without personal or disparaging attacks".
- 2010 was the year of the Consumer and 2011 will be "the year to get connected with the CPSC". [RW: Last year she promised us that 2011 would be the year of enforcement. I guess that lays ahead . . . .]
- Will implement the Five Year Strategic Plan
- Wants to use Neal Cohen's office
- Launch the new database, assuming the government is "still open".
- Continuing new Section 104 rules, Pool Safely initiative, educating consumers about safe sleep.
"Knocking on the door" on being the global leader in consumer product safety. Looking for an "even more rigorous" identification process for product hazards. Will turn hazard identification into injury reduction. Want "safety built into the products intended for our store shelves."
Touts her agency's agreement with the Chinese government on toy safety. Sampling and testing in China will help assure safety.
Touts Neal Cohen's efforts, and the efforts of the CPSC Beijing office. Re Small Business Ombudsman, it is dedicated "touch point" for small business for education. Many manufacturers might not know where to turn for information or to fully implement the new rules. Not trying to take away business from outside counsel. [She really said this.] Wants to facilitate the transfer of knowledge across industries.
[No mention of SBO advocating for small business or playing an active role in RESOLVING rules disputes or problems. Hmmm. A shoulder to cry on?]
Looking at a shifting supply base, bringing other countries into play. We're looking to prevent a repeat of the China problems.
Re toxic metals, lead and cadmium requirements are intended to create safeguards for the future. Need to expand our vision beyond lead and cadmium. She's got a nice long list of new things to be scared of. We want to be "leaders" in preventing harm from these metals. Need to avoid exposure from the substrate of toys or other products.
[RW: I think a few more tests will do us ALL a lot of good! I am CRAZY to stick around in this industry.]
Back to new crib standards. Cribs must be replaced by end of 2012 to come into compliance with the new rules. [RW: Stimulus plan!] Cribs compliant with the new rules will be available by June, we hope. Lots new rules in "safe sleep" and other juvenile products.
Database ready to roll in two weeks. Don't forget to ask CF "more questions" today at 4 PM. ["More" questions?] She respectfully disagrees with objections to the database. Her pledge is that they will educate consumers that the report should be accurate and safety-based. Let's not let perfect be the enemy of the good. Data warehouse will promote greater efficiency. Consumers will be more "empowered". If consumers withdraw products while the CPSC is working behind the scenes to issue a recall, that's a good thing in her view.
[RW: Is it a "good thing" if they withdraw from using products that are safe or are not subject to recall? Hmmm. That question was unaddressed.]
Recounts her advice on how to amend the CPSIA (functional purpose exception, should get the lead out if it's "practical" to be removed, 100 ppm should be prospective only, and small businesses and small batch manufacturers deserve some relief). Will work with Congress on other changes.
She says, change it but don't end it. Hmmm. Certainly remains open to making old suggested changes to the law.
Finally, pleased to share that starting on March 1, will launch the Chairman's Commendation Circle Program. There will be more details about the nomination process. Wants to highlight innovators and those who are working to prevent injuries every day. [Hmmm.]
Have the right team in place, willing to take action against those who don't follow the law. Forging a new regulatory approach with predictability and consumer confidence. If all of us can be partners in this effort, can build on the progress made in recent years.
RW: This is BY FAR the least threatening speech by Ms. Tenenbaum since she ascended to her chairmanship. Let's hope this signals a significant shift in tone and direction.
Wednesday, January 5, 2011
CPSIA - CPSC Says "Ahhh, Don't Worry About It!"
In a TV piece called "Mom Outraged Over Lead in Baby's Toy" (watch the video here), a Georgia mother found "an ominous warning" on a toy drum she purchased for her 16 month old from Toys R Us (one of the toughest retailers on legal compliance and quality control, btw). The label read: "Warning: contains lead. May be harmful if eaten or chewed. May generate dust containing lead."
Uh-oh.
And I was wondering why anyone would buy a drum for a 16 month old . . . .
Mom was not happy: "Even if it's just a little bit of lead, I think lead in anything for a child is just insane."
When consulted, the CPSC assured her that it didn't mean anything. It's all about a California law that requires labels for lead levels that have nothing to do with safety. Scott Wolfson, who can really turn a phrase, intoned: "We respect California law, but parents should know that the safety of their children is not necessarily at risk if they see that label."
This is so rich on so many levels.
First, the CPSC is prohibited from assessing risk under the CPSIA. How is it that their spokesman is allowed to assess risk? I thought Congress decides what's risky now. The CPSC can't be trusted, right? As usual, particularly when Mr. Wolfson is involved, the CPSC's position is whatever is best for THEM. To heck with you. For purposes of this story, they magically regained the ability to assess risk.
Let's review - as a matter of law, the CPSC's job is to enforce the standards. They are literally prohibited from considering whether compliant products pose a risk. They are just measurers now, the "cop on the beat", determining whether products are inside the circle or outside the circle but never whether the circle is in the right place. So how can they fashion a judgment that lesser levels of lead aren't risky? The best they can say is that Congress didn't apparently think those lead levels deserved attention.
I am thinking of Sargeant Schultz from "Hogan's Heroes" . . . .
Second, the CPSIA is loaded with superfluous labels. The philosophy of warning consumers through labels pasted over labels is central to the precautionary principle that drove this law. How Mr. Wolfson can advise consumers to ignore a warning label without blushing is beyond me.
I believe the reason they try this stuff is because they think we're so stupid that we won't notice. Or that we're so docile we won't say anything. In any event, it hardly matters because they sure aren't going to listen to us.
Third, this situation proves beyond a shadow of a doubt what I have been saying for three years - that lead labels are a tacit ban. I have long resisted lead labels on any of our products. [Please NOTE - this is only happens under technical application of these stupid rules (gotcha's), such as labels for rocks, light bulbs, coated electrical cords, etc., and only on educational products.] If you put a label like the Georgia label on your product, it will die and you will have to drop it. Plain and simple - listen to the Georgia Mom. She's normal and has some common sense - if the company is warning you about lead, don't ask any questions, just don't use the product. Why else would they be warning you? Duh.
A tacit ban.
So the Illinois law and the California law that require these labels are not only violations of Constitutional protection of interstate commerce, but they are also preempted by federal law. The States are not allowed to ban products that are permitted to be sold by Federal law - they are preempted from taking that step. When you put a label on a product that causes consumers to not buy the product, you destroy the economic viability of the product, thereby killing it. This is a tacit ban, a ban in as many words. It is illegal.
Scott Wolfson apparently doesn't see the problem. Consumers should know that this label isn't serious, he says. I assume he thinks consumers should know that the other labels they should know are serious. If they have any questions, perhaps they should call him. He knows-it-all.
Or maybe Moms everywhere should get better at reading Scott's mind. That's the ticket. Fuggedaboutit.
Monday, October 25, 2010
CPSIA - Let's Keep Sucking Our Thumbs . . . .
Seven days to go! Go, baby, go!
I just found this article documenting the pain of some Illinois toy craftsmen owing to the CPSIA. Imagine, these guys are being held up by the noxious CPSIA and are essentially shut down. I have been reading these articles for almost three years now. Ho-hum.
Have any of you heard of Mattel or Hasbro going out of business because of this law? Me, neither.
Articles of this type are discouraging on several levels, not least of which is the lack of comprehension of almost everyone who gives a quote. The scale of the problem for small business, even the very nature of the problem presented by the law is unclear, apparently. No one asks the right questions like - why are we doing this? What are we achieving? Is it worth the cost? Can we even measure what we have accomplished?
Of course, the answers to these questions are all negative. No one knows why we're doing this, other than a general love of children. Don't know about you but a "general love of children" is a rather flimsy justification for killing off an entire industry (other than mass market companies like Mattel). Given that we have many fine universities here and train the occasional engineer in this country (I am one of them), I would think we could be a just a little more "science-y" in our analysis. So, if we can put our "general love of children" on the shelf for just a moment, why indeed are we doing this? To improve the health of children, right? That sounds good to me.
To assess whether we have had any impact on the health of children, presumably we would need to be able to describe what is WRONG with the health of children now. The zealots assure us that there is no safe level of lead. They also assure us that lead harms children "silently", in other words, the harm cannot be measured accurately, but trust us, it's there. In other words, there is no way to differentiate between lead "poisoning" in children not presenting symptoms - and a purely imaginary condition in those same children. The "real" problem and the imaginary problem present exactly the same way - no symptoms. Contrast banning pixie dust with banning lead-in-substrate - the issues are the same.
[Ed. Note: Apparently there ARE safe levels of lead in musical instruments made of brass if they are full-sized, but not if they are under-sized. This is part of the new interpretative rule on the definition of "Children's Products". Therefore, if you had a small trumpet (dangerous, subject to regulation) and you stretched it, making it into a full-sized trumpet with thinner walls of brass, it would become safe (no regulation)! Hmmm. This is not magic, this is the CPSIA!]
And if you want to measure your impact on this dreaded problem, how would you do it? The health statistics are purely made up, because there are no symptoms. The reasoning goes - since there is "no safe level" for lead, then we must consider anything that could possibly cause a blip in blood lead levels as a causative agent, therefore, we must ban everything that COULD POSSIBLY make blood lead levels rise.
Given that blood lead levels are declining these days and are not considered a health risk by the EPA, FDA, NIH or CDC except in connection with certain specific hazards (leaded house paint, residual pollution from leaded gasoline, or other environmental factors like air pollution), we cannot measure any improvement in health. It's literally impossible (remember, the "real" problem and the purely imaginary problem present exactly the same way). Thus, it will be impossible to measure how much we have achieved for our investment. We must cling to our assertion that there is "no safe level" for lead to assure ourselves that we have accomplished something. This is a logical argument, but there's no evidence to support it.
So the entire exercise is speculative? The benefits cannot be measured. The problem can't be measured or even described accurately. There weren't any victims before, there aren't any victims now. Seems like nothing has changed. Uh-oh.
Ah, thumb suckers, THAT isn't true. Something fundamental has changed, thank you Congress. Safety hasn't improved . . . but a few things have changed substantially:
- Our regulator is no longer capable of exercising a judgment about what is and what is not safe. Consider the musical instrument example above. The CPSC has also become quite aggressive, perhaps to justify its existence and its new jumbo budget. Not pretty.
- The cost of compliance has already skyrocketed. Those dollars are coming out of activities that would otherwise be used to grow our businesses.
- You ain't seen nothing yet on costs - wait for the CPSC to approve the 15 Month Rule on testing frequency and reasonable testing programs. Costs will rise by 10-100x for many companies if the rule is adopted as presently drafted. I'm not kidding.
- Complexity and risk have skyrocketed. What do people do when they can't figure out the rules or they get scared about the consequences of failure? They exit.
[Here's another pre-Xmas threat by the ever-lovable Inez Tenenbaum: "'We will continue to recall their products and it will damage the brand. There will be penalties, there will be lost customers,' she said in an interview." She's quite a charmer, isn't she? Does this sound good to you? Want to enter the Children's Product market? Want all your family's wealth dependent on the health of a business in this market, being regulated by Ms. Tenenbaum? Hmmm, the line's out the door, everyone wants in!!!] - Products and markets are being dropped, or aren't being entered in the first place. Profits are being lost (profit prevention) and jobs are being shredded. Lots of jobs . . . .
- It's not fun anymore to be in this business.
As for the Illinois wood toymakers, it's a shame for them. We read about this kind of thing all the time. Maybe it will go away on its own. Maybe it's all their imagination. Small businessmen are often so unsophisticated, they probably don't know what they're talking about. The U.S. government is just too smart to get something this wrong. If they really screwed up, they'll fix it - the government's not the enemy, you know. Something this big and stupid can't be true. Somebody big and important, like a trade association, will save us. No, no, 60 Minutes or John Stossel will do an embarrassing story and that will break the logjam. [Ed. Note: been there, done that.] I'm too busy running my business to address this. You can't fight City Hall. It will get fixed, don't worry! Nothing this ridiculous lasts very long.
Boy, that thumb must be yummy! But at your age, thumb-sucking seems so inappropriate.
Don't forget to vote on November 2nd. Even if this scourge won't go away and has become entrenched, you can still strike a note for capitalism and for sanity by voting against the idiots and the venal people who want to destroy your businesses and deprive you of valuable products that you prize. You can defend yourself - and you MUST.
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
CPSIA - Stories from the Front (My "Vivid" Imagination)
Have I ever mentioned how the CPSIA is strangling us to death slowly, death by a thousand cuts? I know the media and the "leaders" at the CPSC want me to put up bodies, my word and my reasoning are not enough. I also realize the body they want to see most of all is mine. Sorry, guys, I am working to prevent the delivery of that evidence to you. After all, anecdotes aren't evidence. Somebody said that once . . . .
How about some other evidence (anecdotes) from our business in recent days?
a. Good news for the U.S. economy? We just added our SIXTH person to our growing department of compliance and safety folks. Please NOTE that the volume of work is going to EXPLODE when the testing stay is lifted, so these hires are just a starter. For many years, it was one or two people doing this job (including me). No longer . . . .
I know what you're thinking, this obviously confirms how much we needed the extra safety people. In addition, it follows naturally that everyone is so, so, SOOOO much safer now that we have six pairs of eyes on the ball, not the one or two pairs we relied on for years. And those are jobs being created by Congress and the CPSIA - we must be so much better off . . . right?
Well, let's take a look at those points.
First, are we adding jobs? No. The department is clearly growing, BUT those jobs do not create revenue. They create COSTS. We are adding those jobs without increasing new economic activity (we're not growing) - in other words, our burden to conduct the same or less business is growing. That's simply a drain. Even WORSE, as a company, it turns out we shrunk our headcount in 2007, 2008, 2009 AND 2010. So much for a recovery . . . . If we are shrinking our headcount this year but have a growth department like Compliance, what does that mean? It means that we are reducing our investment in revenue-generating activities like Marketing and Sales, and shifting our personnel investment into managing bureaucracy. To pay the cost of paper pushing, we are shrinking overall headcount.
What-a-stimulus-plan!
As for safety, we achieved a remarkable 26-year track record with far less investment and far fewer people. I firmly believe that more cooks in the kitchen sharply raise the probability of poorer results. Yes, more is NOT better. Why? Because the focus on our efforts is now COMPLIANCE, not safety. [We still work on safety first but it has a lot more competition from paper pushing.] Compliance monitoring and "gotchas" have become a perverse parlor game. Consider Sean Oberle's recent meditation on Mood Rings. The subject of whether the rings are SAFE never comes up, it's all about whether they fall within the rules or not. Safety is secondary in the CPSIA scheme - and everyone is losing sight of what we're trying to accomplish. Paper stacked to the rafters won't make anyone safer but then again, it's comforting to have so many rules to follow.
Do I recall correctly that Mattel with its many CPSC-certified internal labs just recalled about 11 million units of toys? Hmmm.
b. Profit Prevention in Full Bloom at Learning Resources. We had two lessons in the joys of safety compliance money-burning in recent days. Consider these stories and their implications on incentive, motivation, ability to fund our operations, fairness and most importantly, safety.
First Case: We sold a longstanding product incorporating a motor to a mass market retailer with its own testing regime. Their testing regime includes CPSIA tests and is administered according to their specifications by a certified test lab of their choosing. The motor for that item was tested and failed for phthalates. We don't know why - it has been made reliably without the six verboten phthalates since 2007 (many passed tests in our files). So we pulled a second sample from the same batch, and bingo, it passes. This happens all the time.
Of course, certified labs are never wrong. We are the only ones who are ever wrong. After all, the certified labs are CERTIFIED. No doubt that's how Mattel keeps its shop so clean. Oops, they had some big recalls recently, didn't they? I am confused . . . .
Anyhow, back to my story. Motor fails for phthalates and then passes. [Let's not dither over whether phthalates on internal components could even THEORETICALLY harm anyone. It's all about compliance.] Unfortunately for us, this nonsense took two weeks. So the customer penalized us by making the sale a guaranteed sale. If they don't sell out, we lose.
Total cost - unknown. Was any of this cost budgeted for? Of course not. Is our customer happy? No. Could we control against this risk? Probably not, as the explanation of the "failed" test is not and never will be known. We are not making pharmaceuticals here, we make injection molded toys, but we are being held responsible for chemistry and testing results that have no real world significance.
And, it is worth mentioning, all this cost and disruption had NO impact on safety. It only reduced our profit and made us miserable.
Second Case: Another motor case. In the mania over safety and compliance, many formerly minor "gotcha's" have become elevated in signficance. This time, we were trying to mollify a customer over EMC approval of a motor. Electrical motors emit a frequency, apparently, which is regulated. You know, the government doesn't want our motor-powered toy to bring down a plane. We are required to test several of our products, sometimes even calculators. In this case, the motor failed . . . although we have no record of planes crashing after several years of sales of this toy and its motor. Our customer then hired a consultant at its expense to tell us how to "fix" our motor. The result - we were told to add two resistors to the motor, which we did, but then it was too weak to power our toy.
Then we had to find another motor. This took time and finally, we found another motor and had to have it retested. This entire process took two months. Once testing was complete, we were so late with this Xmas order that we were forced to bring in inventory by air freight to make it up to the customer. This cost about $15,000 in air freight and testing costs were an estimated $5-6,000 more. Think of how safe the planes are now!
This customer is a big customer of ours and if we didn't air in product for them, they told us they would have cut us off.
We had a great relationship with the customer before this interaction. How do you think they feel about us now? Do you think they respect us as much? Do you think they believe we "know what we're doing" because our motor failed an obscure and meaningless test? Does it matter that it is basically impossible for a terrestrial toy of this magnitude to influence the operation of a plane miles up in the air? No matter what, we look bad and we lost all of our profit and more on this ordeal, not to mention our good name.
And no one was made safer.
Thanks Congress! Thanks CPSC! Thanks Democrats! Can't wait to show my appreciation in the future. I'll find a way.
Thursday, August 26, 2010
CPSIA - Making It Up as We Go Along

The CPSC today whacked education company Lakeshore Learning Materials with a recall of Magnetic Maze products. This recall involved 18,500 units of a total of five products sold over a 18-month period. Was this recall justified? Well, anything goes these days but consider the facts:
There have been no reported injuries from this "hazard" - namely loose magnets. The company has received ten reports of loose magnets. The CPSC sums up the "hazard" this way:
"The magnetic maze board’s plastic wand can separate and expose a magnet that can be a choking hazard to children. Also, if a child has more than one of these toys and the magnets detach and are swallowed, the magnets can attract each other and cause intestinal perforations or blockages, which can be fatal." [Emphasis added]
Before we unpack this baloney, please consider for the umpteenth time where the CPSC's LEGAL BASIS for issuing a recall comes from. The authority to recall consumer products derives from the FHSA which restricts the agency's authority to "imminent hazards". Section 12(a) of the FHSA provides this definition: "As used in this section, and hereinafter in this Act, the term 'imminently hazardous consumer product' means a consumer product which presents imminent and unreasonable risk of death, serious illness, or severe personal injury." [Emphasis added]
So the CPSC must reach the legal conclusion that this product creates an IMMINENT AND UNREASONABLE RISK of death, serious injury or severe personal injury to order a recall. Did they meet that standard here?
The CPSC provides two explanations for this recall, namely small parts/choking hazards and intestinal perforations from ingestion of magnets. Of course, the latter hazard is derived from a fear of Magnetix, a notorious recall in the bad zone of 2007/8. There is no indication that these magnets were strong magnets as found in the Magnetix product.
A quick glance at this product confirms that the product is DESIGNED with small parts. These products were certainly tested for compliance with law (we know these folks well, and they are exemplary corporate citizens who are exceptionally careful about legal compliance and safety). Therefore, the assertion that the presence of small parts in this product somehow constitutes a violation of law or good practice just doesn't hold water. I could use stronger language, but I think this is a nonsense excuse.
And what about intestinal perforations? That's pretty icky, shouldn't we be intolerant of loose magnets? Well, the CPSC states the conditions under which these magnets could be a problem:
Step 1: The child must have more than one recalled product. [You need two products to have two magnets! There are 18,500 defective units in the world, let's not forget - a total universe of 18,500 magnets.]
Step 2: TWO magnets must fall out, one from each unit. [Ten loose magnets in the world are known. As noted above, there is no indication that these magnets are dangerously strong enough to perforate anything. A niggling detail?]
Step 3: An idiot child must choose to EAT these two yummy loose magnets in one sitting.
This has never happened, apparently. Could it happen?
This is well-beyond farfetched, but there you go. At today's CPSC, the agency is apparently no longer permitted by the politicians who run the place to reason or to assess any form of risk. If the risk can be put into words, that seems to make it real enough to punish any company severely. No doubt this recall exposes Lakeshore to grievous penalties, too. And for what? Can anyone make the case that this makes anyone ACTUALLY safer? And, call me picky, but is this a case of "imminent and unreasonable risk of death, serious illness, or severe personal injury"? I believe this speaks for itself - the answer is no.
Remember, these regulators work for us, the citizens of this country. As the regulators confuse and scramble the expectations of industry and consumers, as they disregard their enabling legislation to chart a path that makes sense only to them - something important is lost. Is that acceptable? Not to me. Remember this on November 2nd. Let's hope it's not too late by then.
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
CPSIA - Extinct Toys, Thanks Congress!
There are seemingly buckets of Endangered Toys (currently in stock but can't be reordered) and Extinct Toys (out of inventory and can't be reordered) on this website. Ooooh, they're so dangerous, like "Grandfather Lorenzo" from darkest Germany (endangered) or the "Post Express Van" also from the rogue state of Germany (extinct). Can't allow children to play with toys from Germany, that's for sure. . . .
Oddly, there's no sign that anyone anywhere was ever injured by these toys. They're just gone now because of the "unintended consequences" of the CPSIA. [Btw that expression, "unintended consequences", makes me want to throw up. Unintended, my ear. This is exactly what was intended, and Dem staffers have repeatedly admitted it.]
The zealots who brought this plague on you have practically grown callouses patting themselves on the back for making your businesses so darned safe. Niggling details like testing costs, loss of valued products, layoffs are all sloughed off as a "necessary" expense in making everyone safer. This flawed assertion is based on the self-evident conclusion that their law made us safer. Obvious, so obvious. I understand their point since I know they can't comprehend numbers or data. That's why they're politicians, after all. WERE they able to tote up a number or two, they might not be so quick to assert that we actually are safer, given that a few tedious hours of analysis would reveal that there are only THREE known (asserted) lead injuries in the last 11 years in this country, and only ONE documented death. That's it, barely a day's worth of death and maiming from pools. Hard to reduce injuries from nothing to less than nothing.
It hardly matters, because they cast the die for us, and have no intention to listen to our little problems. This explains why they blandly put out a rule for comment last week which states that our business will have to pay $15 million a year in testing costs. Gotta be safe, ergo if we don't test the way they say we should, our customers won't be safe.
In fact, if we DO test as they want us to, I GUARANTEE everyone will be safer than ever. That's because we will be out of business and they won't be able to buy any of our products.
Try not to forget to say "thank you" on November 2 to all those people who have stood between the CPSIA and its repair. You should have plenty of time to figure out how to thank the people who are committed to putting you out of business. You sure won't be selling toys.
Thursday, June 17, 2010
CPSIA - USA Today Highlights Damage Inflicted by CSPIA

European toys line shelves in Randy Hertzler's Lancaster, Pa., basement. The small, family-owned business has been directly affected by the crackdown on lead in toys as many of the European brands that he has sold have now left the U.S. market.
By Jayne O'Donnell, USA TODAY
When other toy retailers and manufacturers were feeling a backlash against their made-in-China products in late 2007, Randy Hertzler was riding high. He imports and sells only European-made toys, which, like those made in the U.S., were all the rage when recalls of toys with lead paint dominated the news.
Many small manufacturers say the testing is cost-prohibitive. But its proponents say the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 was long overdue, as the U.S. has been far behind Europe in addressing lead and has been slow to recognize the effects even very low levels can have on children's IQs.
Wednesday, June 9, 2010
CPSIA - More Details on Schylling Penalty Fiasco
1. First agreement was signed by the CPSC six weeks after Schylling on January 19.
2. The CPSC Commission met on February 3 to ratify the agreement. The vote is 4-1, with Anne Northup voting no. Northup apparently objected because she felt the penalty was out of line with other penalties set by the CPSC (too high).
[Ed. Note: I have been repeating myself of late when I assert that these penalties are PRECEDENT to be used against YOU. Ignore them at your peril - they are an evolving, common law measuring stick for penalties that may be assessed against you. Fact patterns are very difficult to compare but luckily big round numbers are easy to compare. Schylling may be . . . you next time.]
3. On February 5, in a remarkable and unexplained about-face, Tenenbaum, Adler and Northup voted 3-0-2 to rescind the agreement and send it back for to the staff "for further consideration of the financial condition of the company". Nord and Moore didn't vote.
5. On May 25th, the Commission again met to decide the fate of the beleaguered Schylling. By a vote of 5-0, the Commission approved the new, doubled penalty. Here is what the Record of Commission Action says: "The staff alleges that Schylling's importation, sale, or offering for sale, certain consumer products, tin pail toys and spinning tops, entrusted to or for use by children, violated the Lead Paint Ban, and that Schylling committed these prohibited acts "knowingly" as that term is defined in section 20(d) of the CPSA. The settlement agreement also resolves certain possible liabilities of Sections 19(a)(1) and 19(a)(4) of the CPSA for possible CPSA violations with other products. Section 20(a)(1) of the CPSA, 15 U.S.C. § 2069(a)(1), permits the imposition of civil penalties for the violations."
As noted in my prior post, there is a question of whether the Statute of Limitations on penalties permitted the assessment of this punishment. The focus of this document seems to be on lead-in-paint violations, which were probably beyond the reach of the CPSC's legal authority to assess penalties. Schylling paid anyhow.
So what happened? Only Ms. Northup provided a written statement. Her statement begs many questions but does provide fodder for conjecture. Here are some salient quotes:
"As an aside, I personally believe that it is inappropriate and risky for companies to ask political figures—including those who exercise control over the agency via budget or supervisory authority—to try to persuade the Commission to reduce a civil penalty. Our civil penalties are open for public comment for two weeks after publication in the Federal Register, and elected officials can comment upon them at that time. Intervention during the Commission’s quasi-judicial civil penalty decision-making process creates the possibility of conscious or subconscious influence on the fair resolution of cases. It also creates a perception that penalties vary according to the political influence of the violator rather than the severity of offenses. . . . The penalty will deter non-compliance and create the proper incentives to import safe products in the future without crippling the company. I believe Schylling has received a proportionately lower civil penalty than a similarly situated major corporation would receive if it engaged in similar conduct."
Hmmm. Seems to be a case of foot-in-mouth disease on someone's part. I admire that Ms. Northup was offended by the "insider baseball" approach apparently adopted by Schylling. The notion that the CPSC and the federal government is some kind of "good ole' boys" club is both outrageous and not even slightly surprising. Who doesn't imagine that there are people out there who have the ability to make your problems go away with a simple phone call? It's nice to see Ms. Northup to take a stand on this. Quite interesting that it is a Republican ex-Member of Congress who was apparently offended. Surprising only because of the press bias against Republicans these days. Good for you, Ms. Northup!
One can imagine an ill-advised or ham-handed conversation that set off this odd sequence of events. This may also be why a new law firm was appointed by Schylling.
I still get the feeling that anger determines the size of penalties by this CPSC. Think Daiso. Since Ms. Northup speaks in terms of deterrence, I presume she is addressing our company and companies similarly situated (like yours). We are supposed to be influenced by these penalties. I sure will be. I can't try any harder or spend any more time or money on safety. [Consumers, please note our almost unblemished safety record over 26 years - no more time is NEEDED, either.] Unfortunately, we have to spend a few moments every day tending to the OTHER needs of our business, like sales, marketing, product development, order fulfillment, accounting and so on. It's a shame we can't spend every waking moment on safety. What a world that might be.
In any event, I will be influenced by the mega-penalties that the angry CPSC is handing out. Given my conviction that there is no more time or money available for "more" safety, how will we be influenced? Well, we might hire fewer employees, develop fewer products, invest in fewer systems to operate our business better, pay lower bonuses, take money out of the business, enter new markets not subject to the prying eyes of the CPSC, and so on. We haven't decided how to be properly influenced by the incentives so generously provided by the CSPC . . . but it all sounds good, right?
Time will tell.
Tuesday, June 8, 2010
CPSIA - Schylling Penalty Update
Well well now, some of the more astute observers of the CPSC may have noticed that poor ole' Schylling did not actually end up paying the excessive $200,000 penalty. No, that agreement was apparently REJECTED in favor of a new agreement signed on May 18. The new agreement, which is virtually identical to the original agreement executed by the CPSC on January 19 (but for a non-substantive paragraph 30 and an order attached at the end) DOUBLES the penalty inflicted on Schylling to $400,000. The agreement was published for comment in the Federal Register on June 2.
Whoa.
So what happened?
It's not entirely clear. The original agreement was announced by press release on February 4 and notes: "The penalty settlement, which has been provisionally accepted by the Commission, resolves staff allegations that the company violated the federal lead paint ban regarding toys with surface paints containing lead above the 600 parts per million (ppm) legal limit applicable at the time, and failed to immediately report to CPSC information about the non-compliant toys."
The press release goes on to quote Ms. Tenenbaum sternly admonishing Schylling for violations that occurred between June 2001 and May 2003: “Manufacturers, importers, distributors and retailers have a legal obligation to ensure that no banned products are introduced into or distributed in the U.S. marketplace, and to inform CPSC as soon as they become aware of information that must be reported under our laws. We will continue to penalize companies that do not follow these basic requirements.”
The normal procedure is for the settlement agreement to be published for comment in the Federal Register, but that never happened. Although the February 4th press release states unambiguously that the settlement agreement had been provisionally accepted by the Commission, something derailed the agreement and back to drawing board it went. It's possible that the Office of Public Affairs somehow jumped the gun with the press release, too. Nevertheless, the time between signing and press release suggests it had to be something else. But what? I cannot find the Public Calendar for this time period but there were probably at least two closed Commission meetings that could have considered this case.
Somebody was NOT happy with the size of the penalty for these old violations. Schylling apparently changed law firms to deal with the revived crisis (two different firms signed the agreements) and four months later, a new agreement doubling the penalty was signed by the parties.
There is no public record of who was unhappy or why. It could have been a Commission member. It could also have been one of the self-appointed protectors of the public good, our good friends the consumer advocates. Who knows? I will be submitting a FOIA request to see what I can find out. Watch this space carefully over the next several years to see if I ever get an answer.
Everyone feeling safe and happy? How about you manufacturers? Happy about justice being served?
Here's another serious oddity: The statute of limitations for these violations had RUN by the time the agreement was signed. The CPSC should not have been able to assess penalties in this case. Hmmm. Let's unpack this a bit further. There are really TWO kinds of violations here - (a) lead-in-paint violations, and (b) failure to timely report the violation. On the former, the statute of limitations is apparently quite clear - it had run out. The CPSC had no legal ability to hammer Schylling for lead-in-paint violations that were so old. Bummer for the agency.
Just as the FBI uses the device of failure to report income to put away gangsters like Al Capone, the CPSC has another trick up its sleeve. The other violation, failure to timely report, is in a grey area as far as the statute of limitation goes. Does the statute start to run when the company should have reported . . . or does it run from the date the company finally files a report? This has never been tested in court. The CPSC seems to have seized on this ambiguity to assert penalties against Schylling. To judge by the outcome, the company did not relish litigation with the Federal Government. The old rule that you should never litigate with someone with a printing press holds doubly true in conflicts with the Obama Administration. They clearly know how to print money.
So the CSPC doubled an excessive penalty on a hapless toy company without the means or the will to push back, and set a terrible precedent that could be used . . . against you. The due process rights of corporations are trampled again. Who is protesting? No one.
All this brings to mind the March 3rd Commission hearing on the new civil penalty rule. Commissioner Bob Adler took a very hard position on penalties:
"I do think that the regulated community deserves to know that we are making a 'pivot' with respect to enforcing the law [referring to the size of penalties] [28:20] . . . . I certainly agree that we have to have gradations of civil penalties depending on the gravity of the offense. I personally wouldn't want to tie our hands by saying that the only time we can hit you with a big civil penalty is when there was a death or a serious injury. There may be an immense potential for death and serious injury which just through fortuity did not occur. So what I would like do is to retain the discretion on the Commission to say where you have done something REALLY BAD, and it could be a variety of factors, we are going to impose civil penalties. But there may be situations where what the company did was REALLY BAD but through fortuity, nobody was injured or nobody was killed. [32:00]" [Emphasis added]
Call it the "Adler Penalty Principle". Schylling's case did not involve any injuries, but perhaps under unforeseeable circumstances, a child or two could have been injured by the toys. They weren't but that doesn't seem to matter under the Adler Penalty Principle. The company also failed to report (see my original blogpost for details). another "crime" needing retribution. One cannot help wondering if Mr. Adler decided this was one of those "REALLY BAD" cases. It's not clear how such an assessment is to be made. Adler explicitly rejected outcome as a measure of the severity of infractions. In any event, a massive penalty like this is clearly intended to terrorize the regulated community. The niceties of whether the company's behavior merited this treatment seems to be a secondary consideration.
The penalty policy of this CPSC Commission is completely arbitrary, excessive and intended to be highly coercive. Practitioners in the CPSC Bar have regaled me with stories of the CPSC's use of the penalty free-for-all to coerce all sorts of unreasonable settlements.
Every outcome can be justified in a world without rules or due process protections. Maybe that's the pivot that Adler was referring to.
Tuesday, June 1, 2010
CPSIA - Phebe Phillips Leaves Toy Biz Over CPSIA
Life's lemons - that's a little harsh, isn't it, for something as wondrous as the CPSIA? I bet Mr. Waxman agrees with Ms. Phillips - if we would only relax, we would learn to really enjoy the CPSIA and its effect on our businesses and our lives. Look at all the benefits that Phebe Phillips experienced - it only drove her out of the business she started as a young graduate of Southern Methodist University in 1983 and out of the industry she loved so much. There is no sign that Ms. Phillips' products ever harmed a single child. Nonetheless, we can rejoice at how safe everyone is now . . . .
Monday, December 28, 2009
CPSIA - Are Toys Supposed To Be Fun Anymore?
Sadly, Mr. Mann observes that "toys are not something to play around with", noting the recent recall of toy darts because an 8-year-old almost choked on a dart that he was chewing. This is a real case. [This recall is eerily similar to a life-imitates-art spoof on The Onion entitled "Fun Toy Banned Because Of Three Stupid Dead Kids".]
Mr. Mann recounts in hilarious fashion various recent recalls illustrating the fact that we seem to have lost sight of what constitutes safety. [He even mentions the unfortunate Timberland ankle-high boots recalled for the lead-in-paint logo on their insoles.] To make his point, Mr. Mann notes the useful instructions provided by the CPSC in its "The Super Sitter" manual for babysitters. Here's some tips the government felt the need to give babysitters:
• "Keep the youngsters safe by preventing accidents."
• "Running or horseplay on [stairs] can lead to falls."
• "In the event of accidental choking, apply first aid measures to clear the child's airway."
He quips: "(In the event of intentional choking, do not apply first aid measures.)"
The fear of everything, railed at in this essay, is the philosophical underpinning of the misconceived CPSIA. There is no solution to this disease short of changing the law. In a world dominated by the fear of everything, nothing is safe and everything must be feared. Mr. Mann's strategy of not giving gifts seems to be an appropriate response in this environment.
It's a funny article, but it's not a funny problem for those of us stubborn enough to remain in the children's product market. I don't know how it comes as a surprise to anyone that misuse of products or the absence of individual responsibility may result in injuries, but that plague has descended on our industries. The issues inherent in this shift away from common sense are many:
- Fear of liability creates a perception of COST that deters investment in products and markets. Random costs feed the fear.
- Unjustified fear of injury by consumers translates into lower sales or higher costs in making sales. Markets shrink. Consumer needs become difficult to meet.
- An atmosphere of fear affects regulators, who tend to recall more often and to assess more penalties (even if non-monetary) because it's politically-expedient or follows the trend. In other words, it's "safer" for regulators to err on the side of caution - but that cost is borne by somebody . . . businesspeople.
- Rules tighten illogically, diverting attention from real issues, increasing the cost of participating in the market. All parties suffer from the consequences of complexity, including regulators.
- Misallocation of resources (expending too much energy on unimportant things) leads eventually to true crisis, fueling the fire of the original proponents of the legislation. The obvious solution - even MORE government.
And the joke will be on you and on us, if we don't do something about it. Mr. Mann takes a lighthearted swipe at the silliness of your Congress, but it's really no laughing matter.
