Showing posts with label FHSA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label FHSA. Show all posts

Monday, April 4, 2011

CPSIA - Analysis of Pending House CPSIA Amendment (Sections 1 and 2)

[This is a long essay - I apologize.  The subject is important.]

In anticipation of this week's hearing on the pending House CPSIA Amendment, I wanted to share my thoughts on the present draft.

But first, a little perspective:

The debate over the CPSIA amendment has propitious timing.  Fate has provided us with a new vantage point on lead mania.  In a sad parody of the junk science underlying the CPSIA, the EPA this week assured Americans that it's safe to feed mildly radioactive milk laced with bits of nuclear meltdown to infants.  What?!  In a March 30 press release (available on the EPA website), the EPA instructs us to keep it all in perspective:

"Results from a screening sample taken March 25 from Spokane, Wash. detected 0.8 pCi/L of iodine-131, which is more than 5,000 times lower than the Derived Intervention Level set by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. These types of findings are to be expected in the coming days and are far below levels of public health concern, including for infants and children. Iodine-131 has a very short half-life of approximately eight days, and the level detected in milk and milk products is therefore expected to drop relatively quickly.  'Radiation is all around us in our daily lives, and these findings are a minuscule amount compared to what people experience every day. For example, a person would be exposed to low levels of radiation on a round trip cross country flight, watching television, and even from construction materials,' said Patricia Hansen, an FDA senior scientist."  [Emphasis added]

The CPSIA, on the other hand, is built around the idea that there is "no safe level for lead".  The CPSC has uniformly rejected exemption requests on the grounds that there is no proof that the products won't emit ANY lead - meaning one atom.  The CPSC staff has already acknowledged that there are no materials on Earth that can be relied upon to not emit a single atom of lead.  I would call that "limited" options.  Then again, perhaps space exploration will save us from this law . . . .

So the EPA blesses feeding milk infused with Japanese nuclear material to babies, but even a single atom of lead is intolerable to Congress and the CPSC.

Call me crazy, but they BOTH can't be right.  And it's obvious who knows what they're doing in this case - it's the EPA. 

It's time to drop the rhetoric and rebuild the CPSIA to provide appropriate protection WHERE IT'S ACTUALLY NEEDED and strip everything else away.  Period.  The Emperor has no clothes.


Section 1  Definition of Children's Product:  This open-ended section attempts to lay the groundwork for trimming the coverage of the CPSIA.  Notice that the age limits are blank.  This probably reflects internal divisions among the Republicans on how to set age limits or how to position this law for passage in the Senate and then into law.

Notably, an age limit of seven years of age passed the Senate back in 2008.  That seems to be the default age that may get penciled in, simply because some people believe it may be easier to get that age limit through the Senate.  I believe this is an untested hypothesis, unfortunately.  The consumer groups are going to scream no matter what - they hate most of this amendment, and will make it tough on the lefties in the House and particularly in the Senate to support any rational trimming of these limits.  Even seven years of age may find more than token resistance in the Senate.  Of course, that does not mean we shouldn't push for the right age limits.

Were it up to me alone, I would probably pick a range defined as products SUITABLE FOR children five years of age or younger.  Five years of age pretty much defines the outside limit of age inappropriate behavioral risks for normal children.  Injury statistics and human factors analysis do not identify substantial risks above this age.  [It provides a safe "margin of error", if one is actually needed.]  I think the definition must eliminate the concept of manufacturer's "intent" because the state of mind of the maker has nothing to do with safety.  The intrinsic attributes of the product are what defines risk.  In addition, the fact that we must GUESS as to the state of mind of the manufacturer makes it an unworkable standard.  An objective standard based on traditional notions of human factor analysis would work best.

Even more fundamentally, I question whether it is really the job of Congress to set these age limits.  As we know, Congress has already made a big mess as the self-appointed substitute for the CPSC.  Age limits for safety standards should be based on scientific inquiry, human factors analysis, risk assessment, and so on.  It is presumptuous for anyone to conclude that Congress can do it better than the Ph.D.s at the CPSC.  Of course, in this politicized environment, in which trust in the agency has been bruised beyond recognition, I am somewhat sympathetic to Republicans who feel more secure setting the rules in concrete. If, however, we want to get out of CPSIA hell, we need to restore order in the safety universe.  The CPSC should be given responsibility for making these determinations on a MANDATED RISK ASSESSMENT BASIS.
I hate to go down the path of one sizes fits all age limits, myself.  Is there ANY reason to set age ranges that apply equally to toys, books, t-shirts, dirt bikes and ATVs, CDs and DVDs and educational products?  Of course not.  Who should make this determination?  The agency with the experience and the professional staff trained to make these judgments - the CPSC.

PLEASE NOTE - this is a critical part of this amendment. This section defines who is subject to this awful law and who is not.  Don't misunderstand which provisions are driving this ship - this provisions controls your legal liability, your exposure to regulatory oversight, penalties, enforcement, government intrustion generally.  Testing relief in this amendment MUST BE seen in the context of the limitations here.
With that thought in mind, I would remind my readers of the scarcity of evidence of lead injuries from children's products and of lead-in-substrate victims in general.  I believe the entire basis of this law is a scam (or at a minimum, a hideous misunderstanding of the data) and CHALLENGE the zealots to PROVE a need for the suffocating regulation of lead-in-substrate in these products in these industries.  If lead victims cannot be identified and their lead injuries explained, then there is no demonstrated need for the legislative hammer - no one will benefit (no one will be safer because they weren't in danger in the first place).  The consumer groups and left wingers have had three years to trot out the victims.  There are NONE.  Shame on them for spreading fear.  I say put up . . . or shut up.

Section 2  Application of Lead Limit: 

Subsection (a) is a classic "kick the can down the road" compromise in which the 100 ppm lead standard will be implemented by the CPSC in four years, not three, pushing the prospective date of implementation out to August 2012.  Not good enough, guys!  The structure of this part of the law, requiring that the CPSC implement the new standard or a standard between 100 ppm and 300 ppm based on "technological feasibility" is a direct INSTRUCTION by Congress to the CPSC to reduce the standard.  The CPSC arguably has no choice in the matter.  [Now you know who to blame.]

You can see this issue discussed in gory detail in this snippet from my testimony on the 100 ppm in front of the CPSC Commission on February 16th.  Commissioner Bob Adler asks me if I want him to BREAK THE LAW by not implementing the new standard.  BREAK THE LAW, BOB! 



This is no way to regulate, no way to govern a country!  ALL references to the 100 ppm standard should be DROPPED from the law.  As noted above, and in countless blogposts here, there are no identified lead victims from children's products - so how is lowering the lead standard at enormous cost and economic risk of benefit to ANYONE?  The 112th Congress can do better than repeat the errors of the 110th Congress. 

Should there be a need for a lower standard based on real risk, the agency has sufficient regulatory authority under the CPSA and FHSA to lower standards to protect children in a rulemaking process.  Congress does not need to meddle further in this area.

Subsection (b) introduces a new and uncorrelated "standard" for risk under the CPSA:  "presents an unreasonable risk to children’s health".  This is bad draftsmanship.  There is a standard already in use in the CPSA and the FHSA, namely "substantial product hazard".  The amendment should MANDATE that this term ALONE should be the standard for all action by the agency. 

Subsection (c) makes the application of the lead standards prospective.  [In Section 6, the amendment makes the same change for phthalates.]  This is mainly intended to head off market disruption and distrust over the new 100 ppm standard.  Of course, in my formulation, this is unnecessary if the 100 ppm standard goes away.  I would point out that the entire idea of this kind of downward ratcheting of standards implies that what was safe yesterday is no longer safe today, which is crazy.

Subsection (d) relates to a revised exemption process.  The "any lead" standard would go away, in faver of some limited exceptions.  Ironically, this provision expands the application of the small parts rules to products for older children like youth model ATVs.  This seems like a big error to me (and a bad structure for the law).  If it's foreseeable that a cap on an ATV spark plug could come off and go through a small parts cylinder, it loses its eligibility for the exception.  Hmmm.  This may require some further thought . . . .

There would no longer be an exemption process under the CPSIA.  So if you are in, you are "in" and can't get out no matter what.  The drafters seem to have settled on small parts as the way lead poisoning is "transmitted" or may be transmitted.  I am not sure how this was determined, since there are no victim case histories to examine.  The presumption is that mouthing is how poisoning occurs, but then again, how many poisoning victims (from children's productrs, not from lead-in-paint) can be found?  Zero?  If we have never seen a victim, how can we be so sure there is ANY mechanism for this dreaded outcome?  Is chewing on ATVs, dirt bikes, the ink end of a pen, rocks, and so on, really such a big health risk that we must fight for years over it? 

Hmmm.

The subsection also artciulates a new (presumably relaxed) standard for steel, copper and aluminum alloys.  The new standard is still blank.  I sure hope the definition of "steel, copper, and aluminum alloys" is crystal clear and I likewise hope that this covers the waterfront for metal used in all current products and future materials used in similar circumstances.  I guess we'll find out in time . . . .  It appears to me to be simply a better formulation of the originally defective legislative concept.  But still defective.  Remember, no victims . . . . 

The drafters have introduced doubt about what's in and what's out.  Is a grommet in or out?  Says the new provision:  you lose the exemption if "after any necessary assembly of the product and after the product has been subjected to reasonably foreseeable conditions of use and abuse, the part or any portion of the part becomes detached from the product and such part or portion of the part fits entirely within such cylinder."  How are you supposed to figure this out with confidence?  Your guess is as good as mine.  This kind of rule does NOT work in the real world.  Sorry. . . .

By the way, this provision seems to snag items incorporating metal balls.  While you may or may not like those products, this provision probably will give them no relief whatsoever.

I am even more hostile to their so-called "de minimus" exception.  "De minimus" ingestion of lead is okay under this rule (whatever that is - can't wait for the three year fight over "Congressional intent") BUT only if it does not fit into a small parts cylinder (same as the metals formulation).  This is patently ridiculous and will give no relief to anyone.  Why are the Republicans playing games here?  There is no safe level for over-compromised legislation . . . .

This is the mechanism that the House is providing to "save" rhinestones, btw.  To get rhinestones into the market, you will need a methodology to calculate the amount of lead a rhinestone emits and document it.  You are a "merchant of death", so you must keep records of how much of this "lethal" substance you subject children to.  Excessive regulation, perhaps???  As I have said, compromise is not always the way to build good legislation. The Republicans need to steel themselves to fix this law once and for all. 

The concept of the "de minimus" exception may be off-base.  It is worth noting that blood lead levels are CONCENTRATIONS (mass divided by volume).  In other words, different levels of lead ingestion will be required for a baby and a big child to develop the same blood lead levels.  The persistence of high blood lead levels also has a big impact on the likelihood of injury, so wouldn't daily lead ingestion rates be a better measure of the likelihood injury?  The "de minimus" standard seems to miss the point entirely.  I get the impression that this amendment was drafted entirely in the context of the (defective) CPSIA and thus carries froward some of its basic flaws and misconceptions.  Square pegs are not good fits for round holes. It may not be possible to "fix" the CPSIA by layering more and more rules on top of the underlying law.  Some things may be best left unregulated with a reliance on the substantial product hazard standard.

Perhaps John Dingell was onto something with the original conception of the CPSA in 1972.

Needless to say, this hyper-technical "de minimus" provision will not work for small business. None of us know how to make a "de minimus" assessment and besides, the requirement to document our methods is just an invitation for tort lawsuits.  If we will be made to create evidence to be used against us, I would rather be in another business. The crafters, the small toy merchants, the t-shirt vendors, the book printers, will also howl over the need to engage in silly and pointless technical evaluations of nonexistent risks by calculating the amount of lead ingested from use of their products.  This is just waste, waste, waste. Again, we should not compromise ourselves to hell in this amendment.  If Congress is going to try fix the damn thing, then fix it right.

As noted above, the substantial product hazard /standard is sufficient to empower the CPSC to do everything it needs to do. The legislative structure is in place and tested over decades.  Why not tell the CPSC to do its job, and stop telling us how to run our businesses? 

Finally, subsection (d)(2) entirely excludes used products from the CPSIA other than children's metal jewelry and products actually known by the sellers to violate the lead standards.  This relief is long overdue - I appreciate that the committee is prepared to do the right thing for this group of CPSIA victims.

Of course, this may beg the question.  If Congress is able to dispense mercy on used products, what about all the other absurd victms like bicycles, rhinestones, ATVs and dirt bikes, books, rhinestones, pens, educational products, CDs and DVDs and so on?  Why stop at used products?  Why even START at used products?  Of course, they deserve help but do they deserve it anymore than the rest of us?  They are senseless victims of this law, of course - but stand in line!  So why not keep the carving knife out and free some more corporate "unintended" victims?  I think the problem here is political, not policy.

Ugh.

Friday, October 16, 2009

CPSIA - My Ruling on Brass Bushings

The Learning Curve request for exemption for brass bushings on their toy cars is still pending at the CPSC. It is supposedly up for a vote this week. As I have noted in two prior blogposts, this decision will set an important precedent for a number of other products. If, as expected, the Commission votes down the LCI request, brass will be essentially banned in all children's products, except for the pretzel logic of the pen decision (previously derided in this space). [The logic in the pen decision has never reappeared in another CPSC decision, and therefore should not be used as precedent for ANY other situation under the CPSIA until it actually reappears as part of CPSC common law. The pen decision was simply a gift to the writing implement industry, such as a convoluted and fantastic legal decision can be a gift.]

Among the anticipated victims of the LCI decision (to recap):
  • Toys
  • Connectors of all kinds
  • Brass zippers, grommets and other apparel and footwear components and accessories
  • Brass instruments (rentals to schools, certainly), musical bells and certain strings used in string instruments
  • Children's jewelry

It is worth noting, amateur scientists in Congress, that brass has germicidal properties which is one reason why brass is used in doorknobs (icky germs!). Might actually be useful in some children's products for this reason . . . .

The presence of brass in daily life is an immutable fact. If the CPSC bans brass in children's products because of the idiotic CPSIA, NOTHING will eliminate the following uses of brass in the daily life of children:

  • House keys (good for sucking)
  • Doorknobs and locks (touching and licking?)
  • Plumbing fixtures and drinking fountains (touching and sucking)
  • Pipes to convey potable water (assuming those pipes aren't made of pure lead)
  • Components in cell phones (definitely good for licking)
  • Clocks, antiques, artwork (touching)
  • Railings (licking)
  • Jewelry (sucking)
  • Guns and ammunition (no comment)
  • Tools (you can poke out an eye with a tool!)
  • Etc. etc. etc.

This does not even address the widespread presence of lead in, among other things, our food system, our potable water and our air. There are federal safety standards for allowable lead content in each category. Children are known to consume food, water and air throughout their daily lives without interruption. The obliviousness of the CPSIA in setting such stiff standards for bio-unavailable lead-in-substrate in children's products in the context of these other lead instances is shameful - and the source of the current issues with brass.

The CPSC Staff has determined that the CPSIA does not allow an exemption for brass bushings. In the understatement of the year, the staff concluded "that the estimated exposure to lead from children's contact with the [LCI] die-cast toys would have little impact on the blood lead level." Staff states clearly that they consider brass bushings safe and that the lead transmission from brass bushings is inconsequential and certainly not rising to the level of a hazardous substance. Unfortunately, the Commission has thus far shown no interest in taking bold stands and rejecting the legitimate legal (but nonsensical) conclusions of the CPSC Staff under the CPSIA. Common sense be damned.

In a perfect world (what a joke), the Commission's decision in this case would hold that although LCI brass bushings are caught up in the limits of the CPSIA, they present NO substantial hazard to children, and therefore using their seldom-used discretion, the Commission grants an exemption for brass bushings in children's products conditionally. The decision would explicitly state that this decision should be taken as precedent for brass in all children's products (to cut down on repetitive exemption requests). The decision would be dependent on TWO CONDITIONS, namely that: (a) the particular use of brass in children's products is not known or held by CPSC Staff to present a substantial hazard to children under the FHSA, and (b) the exemption will be lifted when Congress acts to ban brass from everyday life and takes concrete steps to retrofit America for a brass-free future, replacing all brass doorknobs, artwork, cell phones, keys and locks, plumbing fixtures and water pipes (including, what the heck, lead pipes, too) and so on. For so long as brass remains part of children's daily life in their home and school environments, the CPSC will not act to restrict brass in children's products.

The Commission, using common sense not previously known in the CPSIA era, would note that banning brass bushings would be utterly ineffective to change the net exposure of children to lead in their lives but would wreak terrible losses upon the marketplace. Senseless economic destruction is un-American and lacks a social conscience since the losses will be spread ratably throughout society among suppliers, sellers and consumers of all things brass. Finally, the Commission would note that unless and until its decisions to restrict children's products materially impact safety, the Commission will not keep safe products or components off the market for technical violations of the CPSIA. Brass bushings, in my fantasy, would be granted an exemption to the awful CPSIA.

This idle fantasy can come true if the Commission summons up the courage to act sensibly and to stop being complicit in the shoddy legislative work of Congress. As an independent agency of the U.S. government, NOT a subsidiary of the legislative branch or an organ of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, the CPSC has the authority to make up its own mind and to set rational policy. It's time that the Commission draw a line for one and all to see. Especially Mr. Waxman.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

CPSIA - Nancy Cowles Attacks Me in Roll Call!

What a nice compliment, I have been publicly attacked by name by a consumer advocate! In the wake of my my June 1 Op-Ed in Roll Call in which I documented the limited scale of lead-in-paint recalls in 2007/8 and dared to make the self-evident claim that our company does not make "toxic toys", Nancy Cowles, Executive Director of Kids in Danger, responded by tearing me apart in Roll Call on June 8. Talk about "don't kill the messenger"!

While I resent the personal nature of Ms. Cowles' article and its misrepresentations about me as a person and as a businessperson, I am not surprised. The fear mongering attack dogs amongst the consumer advocates have been out and about for some time. In this space, we have faced "Joe Consumer" from ThePopTort.com, pointed out errors and misrepresentations in the Consumers Union blog, dealt with twisted facts by Jan Schakowsky and the like. The really aggravating part about this is that these folks can seemingly say whatever they want and not be held accountable. [That goes double for politicians - consider the galling fact that Rep. Jan Schakowsky has actually given a public address in which she personally attacked me by name and questioned whether I had kids! That's the kind of political "leadership" we are enjoying these days.] Who can challenge the saintly consumer advocate after all? With their purity of spirit and unquestioned good intentions, how can we doubt them? Thus, when they speak, they get the last word. By definition, they claim the higher ground and gaze down upon the rest of us.

Ms. Cowles' essay provides us with an opportunity to examine who, exactly, has the higher ground. For that, we must be thankful. Please consider the following:

a. Ms. Cowles states: "Rick Woldenberg objects to the need to test children’s products for chemicals and other hazardous materials banned under the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act. . . ." I have NEVER said that testing is objectionable. Our company has tested its products aggressively for two decades. As I have stated publicly, we have had ONE recall in 25 years for 130 pieces (out of an estimated 1,000,000,000 units sold) and recovered ALL of them. I assert that this excellent safety record could not be accidental, but instead is the by-product of a concerted and organized effort to behave responsibly. The issue with the new law is NOT that testing is required but instead that a LOT of wasteful and purposeless testing is required. We cannot afford to waste our limited resources on useless testing. Testing for lead-in-substrate is an absolute waste of money. Insoluble lead-in-substrate has not been demonstrated to cause injury. See for example my analysis of ATVs and pens. The health issue is in lead-in-paint and leaded jewelry - in other words, soluble lead. That's it for lead health issues in children's products. I have consistently taken this position. Testing for lead-in-paint is an old standard and an appropriate precaution for any responsible manufacturer. We have always done it and never objected to it. I have long conceded that this kind of testing is a good idea, and further, is a good response to the outbreak of recalls in 2007/8.

Likewise, the cost of testing for phthalates far exceeds its value. I am not going to touch the issues relating to the ban on phthalates in this essay. I have written about it several times and am generally skeptical about its true value to consumers. To spend a fortune on testing for phthalates is ridiculous on two levels. First of all, phthalates are simply NOT a hazard unless you are chewing on the product for a longgggg time. [Remember, lead and phthalates are not radioactive - you have to ingest them to be affected, not just touch them or be near them.] This scratches most products off the list. Second, elimination of phthalates from products does not demand testing each individual item - effective elimination of phthalates depends on good supply chain control. I STRONGLY object to testing every item for phthalates but taking reasonable steps to assure that your supply chain is free of phthalates is not a problem. We can do that for little money. The premise of the CPSIA is that consumers will only feel safe if surrounded by stacks of testing reports reaching the sky - yet the experiences of 2007/8 in which large companies with well-known heavy investments in testing failed to keep defective products off the market (e.g., RC2, Mattel and RoseArt/Mega Blocks) suggests otherwise.

Ms. Cowles, you have misrepresented my position.

b. Ms. Cowles states: "Mr. Woldenberg states, “I don’t make ‘toxic toys,’” and we fervently hope that he is right." Is this fair? The implication of this remark is that she, and YOU, have good reason to doubt me and our company. In other words, our integrity is at issue here - which is shocking, frankly. What good is achieving our long record for safety if consumer attack dogs can freely take this kind of groundless pot shot? Ms. Cowles' commercial denigration is quite damaging to our reputation - and may be actionable. I wonder if Ms. Cowles is familiar with libel laws.

Ms. Cowles goes on to incorrectly state that testing was never required. In practical effect, that statement is simply naive and incorrect. The market has imposed testing requirements for a long time - this is not just our experience, either. First, major domestic customers in many industries have required a broad suite of safety tests for many years. We provide these test reports as a courtesy (and as a by-product of our internal safety practices). [N.b., this is one reason why the challenge to our integrity is so grating - our industry is not comprised of ogres but instead people just like you, concerned about kids and safety and being a responsible corporate citizen. It is convenient for people like Ms. Cowles to tar everyone in the children's product industry with the same brush - this furthers their objectives and allows them to skirt the facts.] Second, as a company selling into Europe (we sell into more than 80 countries worldwide), we have long tested for compliance with EN71, the EU's toy safety regulation. We also test against standards in many other countries. Thus, everything in our line is routinely tested for many things, lead and other heavy metals included, and has been for a long time. The integration of the U.S. economy with the world economy makes this testing practice common in the children's product industry. Sorry, Ms. Cowles, you are WRONG.

c. Ms. Cowles states: "He implies that 'consumer groups' have some nefarious goal of putting innocent toy companies out of business." Wrong. I have never made the absurd claim that any consumer advocate wants to put anyone out of business. Instead, I have claimed that consumer groups don't understand business issues and that their rigid position on safety WILL put many companies out of business. She confuses intent (cause) with effect. The effect is that businesses will die and products will be withdrawn from the market. It is her intention to have this ridiculous law enforced. She and her consumer advocate cohorts are responsible, whether they intended this effect or not.

d. Apparently, Ms. Cowles does not understand the law she so fervently supports. She likewise does not understand the prior law. Her ignorance on this topic is not unique. Ms. Cowles states: "In support of his claims, Mr. Woldenberg references the numbers of recalls for lead paint and points out that there were no recalls for phthalates. In fact, the CPSC did not have the authority to recall a product for phthalates, no matter how dangerous it was to our children’s health."

This is rich. Ms. Cowles is wrong - and in a funny way, she is also technically right. Let's look at the law. The prior law CLEARLY permitted recalls for phthalates. Under the Federal Hazardous Substances Act, the term "hazardous substance" includes "Any substance or mixture of substances which (i) is toxic" [Sec. 2(f)(1)(A)]. Under Section 2(g), "toxic" is defined as "any substance (other than a radioactive substance) which has the capacity to produce personal injury or illness to man through ingestion, inhalation, or absorption through any body surface." The FHSA defines a "banned hazardous substance" as "any toy, or other article intended for use by children, which is a hazardous substance, or which bears or contains a hazardous substance in such manner as to be susceptible of access by a child to whom such toy or other article is entrusted" [Section 2(q)(1)(A)] Under Section 4(a), the FHSA bans the sale of banned hazardous substances: "The following acts and the causing thereof are hereby prohibited: (a) The introduction or delivery for introduction into interstate commerce of any misbranded hazardous substance or banned hazardous substance." Thus, the prior law gave the CPSC the authority to recall anything that is considered toxic. Her statement is wrong.

And her statement is somehow RIGHT, too. How so? Well, as has been previously documented, the CPSC investigated phthalates and concluded that they were not hazardous in toys. Having reached the conclusion that phthalates weren't toxic, the agency actually lacked the authority to recall products containing phthalates. They also can't recall other products that are not toxic, like Wonder Bread or tap water or library books. In this way, Ms. Cowles is technically correct. Congratulations for hitting the target accidentally!

e. Ms. Cowles follows up her legal analysis of phthalates with an equally incorrect reading of the exemption process: "And for those products that may contain lead in a form that would not harm children, the CPSC has been given the authority to exempt products from the lead-limit rules — but only after manufacturers show that the products will not negatively impact children." Of course, this is flat out wrong. This subject has been beaten to death - it is in virtually every statement by the Commissioners after they refuse exemptions for innocent and safe products like pens, ATVs and bikes. If you don't recall this point, please reread Section 101(b)(1) in the CPSIA. The only exceptions allowed are for products that will not pass even one atom of lead into the body. The Commission has seemingly stopped issuing stays without a "competing safety consideration", so I would not hold out much hope for relief under this provision unless an unusual situation arises like ATVs. With advocates like Ms. Cowles promoting the false notion that the law provides common sense flexibility, false comfort is possible. More likely, the CPSC will be forced to continue to violate the Constitution and compensate for the stubborn refusal of Congress to repair this amazing flaw in the law.

f. Ms. Cowles takes one last swipe at me and other vocal members of the children's product industry: "Mr. Woldenberg and his allies in the industry should stop hindering progress and let the CPSC do its job." I don't know whether to laugh or cry over this one. I fail to grasp the basis for this accusation. We are hindering the CPSC by doing what? Expressing our views? Explaining the impact of the law? Explaining the flaws in the law? Demanding that the CPSC follow the law (including the Constitution), not just the convenient parts? Defending our integrity and the safety of our products? Defending the future of our markets? Defending the right of children to learn in schools? Daring to disagree with Kids In Danger and other consumer advocate luminaries?

The incivility of the attacks of Nancy Cowles should stand as a beacon for everyone contesting this awful law. Ms. Cowles thoughtfully drafted a document exposing her ignorance of the law, the products she irrationally fears and the market itself. The demagoguery is obvious.

Readers, please don't forget whose country this is. It does not belong to Nancy Cowles alone. If the message of her essay does not represent your vision of America, it's time to stand up. Don't let fear mongering set the tone for our country. We are capable of marginalizing ourselves and our country's ability to compete - or rising above the nonsense. Take back your country before it's too late!