Showing posts with label Preemption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Preemption. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

CPSIA - What's Missing from the CPSIA Amendment?

I have summarized my comments on the pending CPSIA amendment in my two prior blogposts.  In this post, I explain what's MISSING from the amendment:

a.  Preemption:  The United States needs ONE law on safety for children's products - not 51.  The CPSIA amendment should include strong preemption language to stop rogue state laws and to streamline compliance costs for the entire industry. Industry wastes huge resources dealing with competing and inconsistent regulatory schemes across the country that add little to safety but disrupt commerce.  It goes without saying that small businesses can't keep up with it (which is especially perplexing in California).  Is it fair to burden small business with a hopeless compliance chore?  Is it good public policy?  I think Mattel has enough of an advantage already. . . .

This preemption should also apply to consumer "right to know" laws as they relate to lead and phthalates.  In other words, the Illinois lead labelling law and California's Proposition 65 should be preempted explicitly by federal statute.  These laws were developed to avoid federal preemption.  Lawyers and mercenary consumer groups don't need the handout anymore - the right-to-know "tax" should be lifted from the marketplace.

b.  Testing Frequency.  The amendment addresses part of the mess surrounding the so-called "15 Month Rule" but does not touch the subject of testing frequency.  The CPSC's budding efforts to regulate testing frequency (and sampling for testing) have the potential to wreak new havoc as the government pushes its way into decisions long made by private businesses.  What's the justification for this intrusion?  I guess Congress thinks they can run our businesses better than we can.  Unfortunately, there's no evidence to suggest that they know better than we do, and furthermore, there is no data to suggest that the decisions made by manufacturers on testing frequency have ANYTHING to do with injuries.  The pursuit of a perfect suite of paperwork is not the same as keeping kids safe. 

The amendment should steer the CPSC away from meddling in the internal affairs of manufacturers and instead refocus it on substantial product hazards.  That's why we have a CPSC, the only reason.
c.  Penalties.  When the CPSIA was originally passed, one of the provisions trumpeted by the agency was its fancy new right to impose huge penalties.  And it didn't take long for the agency to try out its new rights.  Unfortunately, as documented in this space, the penalties rarely reflected reason, just emotion.  Penalties tended to vary by the level of anger at the CPSC, not the magnitude of the "crime" or any sense of proportionality.  Chairman Inez Tenenbaum actually bragged publicly about effectively putting Japanese retailer Daiso out of business  in the U.S. in her 2010 ICPHSO keynote speech.   Daiso recalled a few thousand dollars of cheap toys (about one pallet's worth) in five recalls with no injuries reported byt eh CPSC.  Not exactly a crime against humanity, in my view.  Nevertheless, Daiso was hit with penalties in excess of $2 million.  The Daiso fiasco looks very much like vindictiveness or headline-seeking.  

The threat of such disproportionate punishment may look entirely theoretical . . . until it's your turn.

Call me a starry-eyed idealist, but I believe in due process and reasonable recourse to the courts.  If the agency is going to go hog wild with penalties, Congress should impose reasonable restraints on the process.  Unfettered government power is un-American.  Procedural limits providing basic due process rights and restraining the coercive tactics of the agency would be an appropriate addition to the amendment.  This problem is no secret - ICPHSO sponsored a presentation on this problem at the 2011 February meeting by three distinguished CPSC bar practitioners.  If the agency can't control its animal instincts, then the law should be changed to limit its powers.  I also recommend that penalties be limited to egregious conduct, reckless endangerment or conduct resulting in serious injury. 

d.  Restore Risk Assessment.  The basic problem underlying the CPSIA, as is apparent again and again in my comments, is termination of the CPSC's obligation to assess risk.  In fact, they are not allowed to assess risk anymore under the CPSIA, just follow the rules written by staffers in the 110th Congress.  Of course, this renders the standard of substantial risk hazard moot.  Even more problematic, the CPSC shows signs of losing sight of its mission.  Is the mission proper testing . . . or safety?  The recent hearings on pool drains illustrates this problem.  The hearing was all about the definition of proper pool drain testing.  The CPSC wasn't investigating actual injuries, because there weren't any, but instead questioning test results.  That's what passes for safety administration nowadays.

We need a CPSC focused on risks and injuries.  A phobic safety agency adds costs to our economy with little to show for the extra investment.  We need to get our compass working again.  Congress must mandate that the CPSC base all its decisions on the substantial product hazard standard and risk assessment.

e.  Allow resellers to rely on representations of manufacturers,  Fear of liability has caused many layers of the supply chain to repetitively test and retest the same product, all in the pursuit of the perfect suite of test reports.  These costs are harming manufacturers and raising prices to consumers.  Injury statistics do not support the thesis that anyone is safer, however.  The solution is for Congress to set a legal standard that permits retailers to rely on the representations of their suppliers (manufacturers).  This bright line rule should help end the atmosphere of distrust between retailers and their suppliers.  Don't worry, there will still be plenty of testing to make everyone happy (including the always deserving testing labs).

f.  End whistleblower provision.  The whistleblower provision was added in the same fever of vindictiveness that infused the "throw in the kitchen sink" CPSIA in 2008.  The problem is that there is no evidence that there were any "evil" companies at work in the children's market.  Incompetent organizations or failed operators, perhaps, but criminals and bad guys, no.  "Bad guys" are rare in the children's market, frankly.  The whistleblower provision has the potential to be a disruptor, a manipulator mainly useful to pad the income of tort lawyers. 

Additional attention by the CPSC to outreach and education of manufacturers is much more likely to produce results.  Without evidence that true venality is an actual risk in this market, there is no justification for retaining the whistleblower provision.

g.  Remove phthalates ban!  There are no known victims of phthalates.  The CPSC has been operating under this total ban for now almost three years - and has only ONE recall of 40 little inflatable toy baseball bats (our friend Daiso) to show for it.  That's it, my friends.  How much money, how many planeloads of dollar bills have been torched testing and retesting product for the presence of these chemicals in the meantime?  The CPSC hasn't even bothered to finish up testing standards or certify even ONE lab to perform the tests.  They don't appear to think this is a public health emergency.

Ket's end the charade.  When Diane Feinstein isn't looking, drop the phthalates ban!

Tuesday, July 6, 2010

CPSIA - Turns Out that the Government CAN Assert Preemption

And you thought state regulation of children's products was a fait accompli, nothing we can do about it. The proliferation of state safety regulations is a major hindrance to interstate commerce and puts small and medium-sized businesses in a very risky position. Who can possibly master the federal system of safety laws and regulations plus 38 states' own unique versions (plus the EU, plus Canada, plus Japan, plus . . . plus . . . plus)? No one.

The CPSIA addressed this mess by ENCOURAGING IT. The law does not preempt a variety of state laws relating to the safety of children's products. Among the notable laws so exempted, California's Proposition 65 is especially troubling. That said, I cannot recall a single word of a single state children's product safety law that has been preempted by the federal government. It's the Wild West out there.

Worse yet, this subject is among the many that are "off limits". In other words, we are advised to keep our opinions on preemption to ourselves for risk of "offending" the controlling Democratic party. The non-preemption of state laws that conflict with the CPSIA, CPSA and policy and regulations of the CPSC are to be tolerated, I guess. We have no say in this. Like so many things nowadays . . . .

Aha, but when the liberals don't like the action of the states, well then preemption is apparently a viable option. So today the federal government decided to take action against the Arizona immigration law. [I am a minority and am generally fearful of government rules that encroach on protections for minorities. Of course, like most of the media and America at large, I haven't read the Arizona law. So while I am directionally in favor of knocking it out, I freely admit I don't know much about this controversy other than the things I have gleaned from other people's analysis.] So I guess preemption is a viable option . . . if the motivation is there.

The federal complaint makes many compelling assertions about the value and importance of preemption in the case of immigration law . . . and many of these assertions could just as easily be levied against state regulation of children's products. It will never happen, of course, because that might offend the "public interest groups" behind the CPSIA. Besides, who can trust companies anyhow . . . .

Some pertinent quotes (emphasis added):

"In our constitutional system, the federal government has preeminent authority to regulate immigration matters. This authority derives from the United States Constitution and numerous acts of Congress. . . . The Constitution and the federal immigration laws do not permit the development of a patchwork of state and local immigration policies throughout the country."

"The federal government, moreover, welcomes cooperative efforts by states and localities to aid in the enforcement of the nation’s immigration laws. But the United States Constitution forbids Arizona from supplanting the federal government’s immigration regime with its own state-specific immigration policy – a policy that, in purpose and effect, interferes with the numerous interests the federal government must balance when enforcing and administering the immigration laws and disrupts the balance actually established by the federal government."

"In crafting federal immigration law and policy, Congress has necessarily taken into account multiple and often competing national interests. . . . The laws also take into account other uniquely national interests, including facilitating trade and commerce . . . ."

"Because S.B. 1070, in both its singularly stated purpose and necessary operation, conflicts with the federal government’s balance of competing objectives in the enforcement of the federal immigration laws, its passage already has had foreign policy implications for U.S. diplomatic relations with other countries, including Mexico and many others. S.B. 1070 has also had foreign policy implications concerning specific national interests regarding national security, drug enforcement, tourism, trade, and a variety of other issues. . . . Numerous other states are contemplating passing legislation similar to S.B. 1070."

The Feds have noted that the patchwork of local laws would likely prove highly disruptive to efforts to coordinate a national policy on this topic. They are apparently fearful that the Arizona law will lead to many more just like it in other states. Among other reasons to fear the new immigration laws, local laws can have international implications and can hurt trade. I think I know what they are getting at . . . . Consider the market effects of the noxious Proposition 65 and the truly awful and frightening Green Chemistry initiative oozing forth from California in our direction. The case for this preemption lawsuit is eerily similar to the case for preemption of local safety laws. Unfortunately, we will never get this help unless the Feds decide that the system is so out-of-whack that a lawsuit must be filed. With Dems in charge of Congress who are the blood brothers of consumer groups, this will NEVER happen. Too bad for us.

I feel the federal government's pain on the Arizona law. Too bad they don't feel mine.

Friday, January 30, 2009

CPSIA - My "Wish List"

Here is my "wish list" for changes to the CPSIA:

Please note: the reasoning embedded in this list is that it will all be granted, thus some additional points which are important are implied in the list. I assure you that I would never attach my name to any suggested change to the CPSIA if I felt, even for a fleeting second, that any aspect of my suggestions would degrade safety in children's products or lead to any injury. Safety, to me, is only a sidelight to the issues in the CPSIA. The big issues relate to the law's structure, not its intent, and the very negative effects flow from the distortions in incentives and practice caused by its many rules.

In order of priority:

a. A Pause. We need a stay of enforcement or a delay in the implementation dates for the new standards until at least 180 days AFTER the CPSC has published and finalized its implementing rules and regulations. Many people are asking for a six month delay but this overlooks the activities that will take place in the next six months, namely rulemaking. In reality, even this proposed delay may not be enough as the period between final rulemaking and implementation will result in a huge surge of activity that eill likely swamp available resources all throughout the "food chain". Unfortunately, the CPSC has issued very few implementing rules at this point, even defining what "total lead" is or how to test for it. This is causing incredible chaos. The "pause" will allow for more discussion about the details of the law, public hearings and a legislative process that might result in structural repair of the law.

The National Association of Manufacturers has filed a formal request for a Stay of Enforcement signed by 67 assocations, with more associations expected to join the letter shortly.

b . No retroactive effect for the new lead standard. The retroactive effect of the CPSIA's new lead standards is creating massive dislocation. Companies have NO WAY to fix compliance issues with existing inventory which are usually technical in nature but may cost literally hundreds of thousands of dollars per item to fix. Retroactive effect will create a number of terrible problems: (i) huge costs for voluntary recalls of products that pose NO threat of harm to children, (ii) a subsidy to companies who are oblivious to the law, speculate that the law will be repealed or revised later, or who are intent on flagrantly disregarding the law, (iii) may drive many companies to openly disregard of the law, thereby creating a growing trend to disregard safety laws generally, or (iv) widespread business losses, closings and/or job losses. Elimination of the retroactivity effect will considerably reduce the pressure on the thrift store industry, as well as libraries and many other affected enterprises with large inventories of existing product.

c. Age range in the definition of Children’s Products should terminate at six years old. The broad sweep of the definition of Children’s Products under the CPSIA is causing widespread harm, and will dilute the efforts of the CPSC to patrol the marketplace. The risk to children from contact with children’s products sharply diminishes when children stop mouthing toys and other objects. The CPSC has determined that mouthing ends at three years old. There is no support for the notion that children are exposed to dangers from mouthing over three, so a limit of six years of age provides an appropriate margin of error. Elimination of products intended for children seven and over will greatly reduce the scope, and harm, of the CPSIA, as well as significantly narrow the categories of products affected by the law.

d. The Total Lead Standard should be abolished, and pre-sale testing should be limited to Lead-in-Paint. This change is in recognition of the fact that lead is known to be dangerous in some circumstances, but is not known to be dangerous in other circumstances. The way to properly administer the marketplace is to (re)empower the CPSC to identify safety issues as they arise and develop rules for such issues without limitation. The CPSC with its considerable scientific resources and devotion to mission is the right place to make these determinations, not Congressional committees with no such resources. See https://mail.learningresources.com/exchweb/bin/redir.asp?URL=http://www.forbes.com/2009/01/26/toys-lead-cpsia-oped-cx_phr_0127rubin.html. Implementation of this rule would, for instance, let the CPSC tighten up rules on children's jewelry if they felt it was needed. The need for, and the reach of, any “total lead" standard should be assessed by the CPSC on a risk-assessment basis, and should be implemented by the CPSC in its best judgment subject to appropriate public processes. I would note that the 2007 recalls related to Lead-in-Paint, not “total lead”. This is a critical point that Congress has refused, categorically, to acknowledge or consider.

Elimination of pre-sale testing on "total lead" should also explicitly exempt pre-sale testing on phthalates. Whatever standards remain on the books should be the responsibility of manufacturers to comply with, not to prove up before sale.

e. Lot Marking Requirement is Eliminated. This extremely expensive and burdensome requirement is intended to ease future recalls. Yet, future recalls are supposed to be well-contained by the other provisions of the CPSIA. [Have we found a logical problem here, perhaps?!] The lot marking requirements promises to be a crushing burden on non-mass market-oriented companies and will likely result in (i) reduced product diversity, (ii) abandonment of niche markets and specialty markets in favor of the mass market, and (iii) sharp elimination of jobs and economic opportunities for small and medium-sized companies. I believe this one provision has the greatest potential to downshift product innovation among small and medium-sized companies and must be amended urgently.

f. Effective Pre-emption. Effective pre-emption of state law on children’s product safety and the further restraint of State Attorneys General from enforcing (or effectively competing with the CPSC in the enforcement of) the CPSIA is essential to preserve efficient inter-state commerce.

Rick