Showing posts with label State AGs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label State AGs. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

CPSIA - Phthalates and Lead Limits in Waxman Amendment

Two minor but important points in the new Waxman Amendment relate to the ban on phthalates and the 100 ppm lead standard looming in August 2011.

Phthalates: The phthalates ban has been clarified to exclude "inaccessible" components, thus reducing the cost of testing for victims of this poorly-conceived law. The definition of "inaccessible" is based on foreseeable use and abuse by children. The term "reasonably foreseeable use and abuse" is defined, lest anyone misconstrue what the Waxmanis want it to mean, and hence new concepts have been incorporated: "breaking" as well as "the aging of the product". In the past, "reasonably foreseeable use and abuse" has been interpreted to exclude intentional misuse. The term did not typically include aging since most worn-out products are either handled differently or discarded. The changes wrought by this amendment fundamentally alter the common meaning of "reasonably foreseeable" in quirky ways, making a confusing law all the more difficult to understand or apply.

If "reasonably foreseeable use and abuse" includes breaking the toy, it's hard to know which parts will ever be considered "inaccessible". Reading this language by its plain English meaning, I cannot imagine what might survive this legislative test. Worthless. I sense another rulemaking process for the long-suffering CPSC.

The amendment also clarifies that the CPSC can revoke this exception to protect the public health and safety. Remember, we are talking about a rule affecting mandatory testing of internal components that may or may not contain phthalates. Can anyone tell me what threats to the public health and safety could POSSIBLY result from an internal component made with phthalates? Phthalates have been in use in this country for more than 50 years - wouldn't we know about "leaping phthalates" by now? Oh yeah, I'm sorry, i forgot that reasoning and science don't matter anymore. . . .

Perhaps concerned that the CPSC was running out of things to do, the authors added yet another rulemaking on "inaccessibility" for this new exception. They are free to adopt the definition already set for lead. It's up to them. Study up, guys! Can't wait to give comments . . . .

Can you say . . . mania?

It is worth noting that in taking this route to "resolve" the pain points on phthalates, the Dems have chosen to NOT address a pending issue between the CPSC and California. Attorney General Jerry Brown of California sent a hot letter to the CPSC last year indicating his unwillingness to accept testing of the entire product for phthalates ban purposes. In the wake of his letter, the agency reversed course and rescinded its rule permitting a single test on the entire product. This would have been inexpensive for manufacturers.

It is pure fantasy that the Dems would take on Jerry Brown since our Congressional overlords are largely from CA (Waxman, Pelosi, Boxer, Feinstein) and are busy trying to California-ize the rest of the country. Henry Waxman would certainly never preempt Jerry Brown for the national good. Hence the half-a-loaf approach here.

Lead: The Waxman Amendment makes the pending 100 ppm lead standard prospective. This is a tiny bone thrown in our direction. You may consider it a nod of acknowledgement of your pain from the retroactive application of the lead standards and phthalates ban. Nonetheless, this is all you will get.

Again, this is only half-a-loaf. A more thoughtful and helpful change would have been to draw a FIRM LINE under the 300 ppm standard, eliminating the 100 ppm standard altogether as well as the rule ratcheting down the lead standard in the future (forgot about that one, right?). They could have said that the CPSC would be free to lower the lead standard in the future if necessary to protect public health and safety (taking into account the cost and benefit of any such new rules). But they didn't.

The Waxmanis have no interest in such concessions. Whether out of zealotry or pride of authorship, no amendments will emerge if they reflect any concession of error or misjudgment in the Perfect Legislative Process. Thus, the 100 ppm standard can't be removed because they put it there for a reason. We must live with it . . . so they say.

Rumorville has it that the Waxmanis are about to deliver a message to leaders of the business community to fall in line behind this "wonderful" amendment or else . . . they'll get NOTHING. Don't you love this? And I used to think THEY worked for US. What an idiot I am!

And on that note, I encourage you to read ONE more blogpost about this toxic amendment. I still need to show you how the authors are trying to deceive you and gut the system that regulates safety of safeguards against governmental abuse. That is, abuse of the interests of your businesses. It's really something to see.

Thursday, December 17, 2009

CPSIA - Playing Footsie with Lead Standards

I have complained in this space from time to time about the recent success of Center for Environmental Health in inducing public officials to recall shoes for lead in their soles and insoles. In that case, CA AG Jerry Brown fell right in line and recalled seven items, including a pair of shoes and a pair of sandals for these frightening infractions. The CPSC, as far as I know, was not consulted - this was State AG enforcement of the CPSIA at its best! Did I mention that Jerry Brown is running for governor again . . . .

Of course, a mania over lead in shoe soles and sandal insoles is kooky. You would hope that the CPSC wouldn't fall prey to such nonsense. Of course, the insightfully-written CPSIA makes no such distinction in the wording on its lead content restrictions. This is one reason why the footwear folks are so concerned about the law. Still, the CPSC is not so reactive to recall shoes for this reason . . . are they?

Regular readers of this space know the answer already. Here it is, the CPSC saving the world from "dangerous" leather work boots for kids! This public menace was recalled because the "Classic Scuffproof Boots" have a logo stamped on its insole that exceeds the new lead-in-paint standard. Whoa! The notice warns that "Consumers should stop using recalled products immediately unless otherwise instructed" and later advises that "Consumers should immediately take the recalled boots away from children". The number of scuffproof work boots affected is 21,000 pairs sold for between $50-$70, or between $1-1.5 million in retail value. That's real money, guys. No doubt there'll also be a penalty in, say, three years.

Soooo, what are we looking at here? These are children's leather ankle high work boots with a logo ON THE INSOLE that might violate the lead-in-paint standard. [Personally, I STRONGLY doubt that Timberland uses paint for its insole logos - we believe it's made with an ink, thus not affected by the lead-in-paint standard.] Let me ask you an important question - have you EVER licked the insole of an ankle high boot? If you have, can you please send me a diagram of how you did it? While we're at it, do you believe a child ANYWHERE has EVER licked the insole of their ankle high leather work boot? Chewed off the yummy logo? Just curious . . . .

Man, are we safe now! Is it a huge stretch to contend that most people would not let their kids consume their scuffproof leather work boots, no matter how tasty? It is my distinct impression that many icky chemicals are used to make leather. That's a "watch out", if you ask me.

Furthermore, Timberland is a corporate "good guy". Their website practically oozes with enviro-friendly policies and social responsibility. In fact, they are famous for their personnel practices and activism. Here, for instance, is a portion of their mission statement:
  • Value. Humanity. Humility. Integrity. Excellence. These are the core values that we inject into everything we do, everyday.
  • Purpose. Creating positive change in our company, community and environment. Any way you can.

Clearly, the government needs to keep a close eye on these people.

Unfortunately, now that a lunatic law governs the country and CPSC leadership seeks to please a cartoon character Congress that "wants" products like this off the market, embarrassing and demoralizing recalls like this become commonplace. For business people, these irrational recalls only heighten the fear and amplify the lack of trust that now infect the regulatory environment. After all, if the CPSC would stick it to Timberland for this, what would stop them from wreaking similar havoc on you?

Somehow we have to stop this runaway train. If you don't want your country run like this, you better do something about it.

Thursday, December 10, 2009

CPSIA - Sean Oberle Takes a Pot Shot

How dare I express anger at irresponsible or incompetent consumer groups! I guess I am not a right thinking individual . . . like Sean Oberle, owner of the Product Safety Letter.

Today, Mr. Oberle made an oblique reference to me in his editorial entitled "Zhu Zhus: Who Loses?". In this essay, Mr. Oberle expresses the view that, like negative sales spillover effects from recalls, consumer groups may suffer some reduction in reputation from the actions of the inaptly-named "GoodGuide", famous for attacking Zhu Zhu Pets this week. [Courtesy of the fast action of the CPSC over the weekend in defense of the victimized Cepia LLC, the product was promptly cleared.] After snuffling up a few tears for the consumer groups, nobles one and all, Mr. Oberle carries on with a reference to my recent essay on this sad episode:

"But the current doesn't stop at humor. It runs into hostility. Indeed, one anti-CPSIA advocate this week went so far as to use publicly the irresponsibly offensive (yet laughable) slander, terrorists, to describe consumer groups when reacting to the Zhu Zhu story."

I don't mind being singled out, or even insulted in a condescending manner, for the content or choice of words in my essay on Zhu Zhu Pets. It is hard to interpret the concerted (in fact, coordinated) efforts of many consumer groups to destroy our industry as anything other than terrorism. The annual spectacle of consumer groups frightening the public by spreading fear and misunderstanding about toys is revolting and deserves public shame. Consider the recent successes of CEH in getting shoes and sandals recalled by the CA AG for having too much lead in soles and insoles. Wow, we really are safe now. That's quite a public service, isn't it? [Mattel's fines paid for CEH's sleuthing.] Likewise, Illinois PIRG's failure to find much to complain about in current toys on the shelf didn't stop them from making up a new safety standard (lead in the toys are below the federal standard but above ZERO!). In another case, the "Trouble in Toyland" report this year hauled in a bounty featuring as its big catch a zipper pull. Still, it was a great opportunity to go on TV and make out like the problems were still dire. Hey, it's a living. . . .

And the media is biting down hard, swallowing hook, line and sinker. Consider the WSJ and the Washington Post coverage of the "GoodGuide" episode:
  • WSJ: "The developments underscore the role that consumer groups can play in helping the government regulate children's products, but also the confusion they can bring." [Emphasis added] Helping? By doing what, spreading misleading information and causing a massive emergency by incompetently attacking the year's leading toy? That kind of help I think the CPSC can live without.
  • Washington Post: "A ratings Web site, GoodGuide, reported Saturday that it had found high levels of antimony in the Zhu Zhu Pets' 'Mr. Squiggles' model. Antimony is used as a fire retardant in textiles and plastics, and chronic exposure to it can cause heart and lung problems and other health effects. Federal laws require that toys contain no more antimony than 60 parts per million. GoodGuide reported that it had tested Mr. Squiggles and detected antimony between 93 and 106 parts per million." High levels? What exactly constitutes "high levels" of antimony, anything over the limit? Is that because even one part-per-million of antimony over the federal limit on the product's nose is deadly? I dare say NOT. How many slices of filet-of-nose-of-Zhu-Zhu-Pet must be consumed before you get "heart and lung problems and other health effects"? My opinion: the Washington Post has absolutely NO IDEA. However, what's the story if a paper can't use strong words to describe minor issues?

Don't worry, the Washington Post hasn't lost its edge. It tried again the very next day to help stir the pot some more.

Despite Mr. Oberle's indignation over my choice of words to describe the saintly consumer groups, most Americans are getting sick and tired of the stunts the self-appointed advocates pull annually. A little bit of this is a good thing, a mass terror campaign not so much . . . .

If we are ever to pull ourselves out of this miasma as a society, we're going to have to get away from consumer education through fear mongering. The issue confronting us is safety. Safety . . . not compliance, these are two different things. Perhaps there is something more to the virulence of the campaign than meets the eye. There are those among us who have a political agenda, in addition to an interest in safety. Let's not confuse the two. Revving up in Congress is an effort to recast the Toxic Substances Control Act. This next phase of the CPSIA descent-into-hell aims to make all chemicals suspect until proven safe. Sounds good to you? Well, consider what this approach to regulation has done to all aspects of the children's products industry over only TWO such chemicals (lead and phthalates). The same luminaries who brought you this mess have a mega mess to sell next.

Don't let it happen.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

CPSIA - An Open Letter on the Testing Stay

To all of my loyal readers:

You may not realize it, but we face a serious crisis right now. Last week, the CPSC held a hearing that discussed the possible extension of the testing and certification stay. The Commission is under pressure to ramp up implementation of the awful CPSIA and this therefore puts the testing stay in peril. Chairman Tenenbaum has heard the concerns of regulated businesses that some advance warning is needed, so Rumorville in forecasting a quick consideration of the question - possibly as early as next week. Commissioner Nancy Nord commented on the implications of the stay in her blog last week. At least one Commissioner, Bob Adler, is openly hostile to continuation of the stay. This is a big deal to companies regulated by the CPSIA.

What kind of disaster would the termination of the Stay in February mean to you? Let me count the problems:
  • The "15 Month Rule" was never issued when due on November 14th. The "15 Month Rule" was supposed to address testing frequency, sampling regimes, the need for additional testing, component testing rules, etc. [Component testing rules were cited as critical by Nancy Nord when the original stay was issued on January 30, 2009. How time flies . . . .] There is a workshop to be held on Thursday and Friday this week to solicit feedback from stakeholders. More than 200 people will attend and many more will watch and participate online in the web simulcast. Presumably this feedback needs to be fully digested before the Commission acts on the stay.
  • Comments on the "15 Month Rule" issues are due on January 11. For perspective, the original comments on the penalty factors were due in late December 2008, and a second round of comments were due on October 1. The revised penalty factors have not been released, and we are now within days of a full year since the first comment letters were received. With this as precedent, we are clearly MANY months from a completed "15 Month Rule". Arguably, without a fully articulated "15 Month Rule", an active testing requirement will be incomplete and utterly confusing.
  • The CPSC has not issued its phthalate testing standard.
  • The CPSC has not certified ONE phthalates lab yet.
  • The CPSC admits that it has not certified enough labs to handle a full burden of testing for many product classes or safety tests. They have not provided any quantification of this deficit besides acknowledging that for bikes, based on current accredited labs, it would take a full year to complete testing on all bikes on the U.S. market. That's one round of testing only, btw.
  • The CPSC has not certified labs for ASTM F963 testing yet.
  • The CPSC has not defined "children's product", "toy", "play" or "childcare article" yet, making the application of the rules completely opaque.
  • The CPSC has not leveled the playing field, acknowledging that fixed test costs place a disproportionately high burden on small businesses. This competitive disadvantage has no ready solution under current rules.
  • The CPSC has acknowledged that many companies have not acted to fill market gaps like component testing because the rules are not final (or even drafted in this case).
  • The CPSC is on its third enforcement policy on lead and lead-in-paint. With the enforcement-policy-of-the-week, the agency ensures that companies will have devote considerable resources to relearning the rules that they had previously mastered, leading to confusion and exhaustion. Imposing a further layer of incomplete, vague and unarticulated testing policies and plans will only reinforce chaos as the working standard for the children's product industry.
  • The rules that the CPSC has implemented are so ornate, confusingly worded, scattered among multiple documents, letters, and even video testimony, that only the most obsessive observers can claim an accurate understanding of every nuance. This group would not even include me, even though I have given up sleeping in favor of the CPSIA.

The Commission's sense of urgency to get this irritant off their plate is creating rumors that they intend to act as soon as the next business day after the workshop. As outrageous as this might seem, it's really worse - the workshop is not about the stay. The workshop is about component testing, frequency of testing, sampling schemes, when to require additional testing, etc. The CPSC has not asked for comments about the lifting of the stay but at least one Commissioner has reasoned that if it was a "big deal", the CPSC might have heard from more than the Handmade Toy Alliance. [Apparently, both Bob Adler and Jay Howell believe that the CPSC has had not heard from anyone other than the HTA on the stay, which is certainly not true.] This kind of thinking is worrisome in the extreme.

If the stay is lifted on two months notice with all these rules open, undrafted or in process, utter chaos will break out, not only between CPSC regulators and their regulated companies and industries, but also between (a) consumer groups, regulators and regulated companies, (b) State AGs and regulated companies, and (c) regulated companies and their dealers/retailers. By lifting the stay under these uncertain conditions, the Commission is risking complete market chaos. While this would rain down misery across all regulated companies and industries, there is cold comfort in knowing that the Commission would eat its own cooking, suffering a devastating drop in reputation for taking such an economically insensitive and irresponsible act. It would also create whole new class of crises for the agency to deal with, rendering the agency crippled with overwork, inefficiencies and wear-and-tear. Not exactly a magic pill for good agency morale. If the Commission chooses to take this step, it will be shooting at the agency's feet as well as ours.

We need your help to stop this terrible step. First, it is ESSENTIAL that everyone attending the workshop SCREAM BLOODY MURDER on the issue of the stay. If the stay is lifted, you will be held responsible for complying with unwritten rules by your customers, your local newspaper, your State AG and the like. Your arguments with that cast of characters will get even more intense and distracting (if that's even possible). The upcoming workshop is your unique opportunity to make your voices heard.

Second, you need to let the Commission know directly how you feel. Here are the email addresses of the five Commissioners - send them an email THIS WEEK expressing your deep concern over the possible lifting of the stay. Please feel free to cc. me at rwoldenberg@learningresources.com.

Chairman Inez Tenenbaum itenenbaum@cpsc.gov

Commissioner Bob Adler radler@cpsc.gov

Commissioner Thomas Moore tmoore@cpsc.gov

Commissioner Nancy Nord nnord@cpsc.gov

Commissioner Anne Northup anorthup@cpsc.gov

Make your voices heard - don't let this issue catch you napping. We all have the power to help ourselves. It's time to take action on behalf of your company, your customers, your suppliers, your teammates. Please help us by contributing your voice to this critical issue THIS WEEK.

Sunday, November 22, 2009

CPSIA - Proposition 65 Provides Funding Mechanism for CEH Crusaders

Has the Center for Environmental Health (CEH) gone into the business of finding violations of law for profit? You gotta wonder.

This past week, CEH capped off a six-week investigation of 250 children's items at the request of or in partnership with the CA Attorney General's office, finding seven mildly offending items. As detailed in my blogpost last Wednesday, this rogue's gallery of offenders include a pair of shoes (soles), sandals (insoles), a poncho, a small patch of material on a bicycle accessory and the like. The CA AG issued cease-and-desist orders on his own, cutting the CPSC out of the picture, and a media feeding frenzy ensued. Presumably to the delight of the CEH troublemakers, Oregon followed up with its own action. [To Oregon's credit, they indicate they would inform the CPSC of their concerns, not take a direct recall action like the CA AG.] Perhaps other States plan to follow the CA lead and jump down the retailers' throats for these trivial defects.

How did this come to pass? It turns out that the starting point was a tip by CEH on another lead case, this one involving Mattel. As you know, Mattel was responsible for some major lead-in-paint recalls in 2007/8. These recalls were a result of a violation of longstanding federal law, and the authority for the recall was found in the CPSA (before its amendment by the CPSIA). [In other words, the new law was not required to force Mattel to recall these items.] It turns out that California's Proposition 65, its notorious consumer-right-to-know law, was also violated by those recalls. The insidious Prop. 65 (explicitly exempted from preemption under the CPSIA by the powerful California Congressional delegation including Senators Boxer and Feinstein and Reps. Pelosi and Waxman) requires that products exceeding (in this case) its lead standard be labeled to "inform" the consumer. Prop. 65 lead standards now match the federal standards. By violating the federal standards, Mattel also violated the Prop. 65 label requirements, thus giving California the chance to extend its palm for penalties and other concessions.

In the first of many settlements relating to its recalls, Mattel and other companies settled
a Prop. 65 lawsuit and paid a collective $1.56 million in penalties and fees. [The CA AG extracted similar penalties from Target, TRU and KMart for lead violations earlier this month.] It turns out that this $550,000 penalty case stemmed from a rat out by CEH: "This agreement settles a lawsuit filed by the State of California and the LA City Attorney in November 2007, after receiving notices of violation from the Center for Environmental Health, As you Sow, and the Environmental Law Foundation." Part of the money extracted ($550,000) was applied to a fund "to test toys for lead and improve outreach about future recalls."

So how did Mattel's misery pay off for CEH? The CA AG's press release tells all: "In 2008, Brown's office reached a settlement with several major toy companies over excessive levels of lead in their products. The settlement allocated $548,000 in funding for consumer safety groups to monitor lead levels in consumer goods and to provide outreach about product recalls. The Center for Environmental Health discovered the current violations with a grant from the Public Health Trust, which administers the settlement fund."

So, here's the game - CEH finds violations of the law, and then puts in for grants to find more violations, all funded by the violators. CEH is a not-for-profit - it is not a business, does not make or sell products or services for a profit and its officers and employees have no source of funding other than contributions . . . until now. Proposition 65 is their new funding source. Shaking down corporations under the auspices of Prop. 65 to provide funds for new hires, salaries, raises, perhaps even bonuses. Thus, the unholy alliance of plaintiff lawyers and consumer groups is made even more cozy. Consumer protection as a plaintiff lawyer's dream. Job well done, CEH!

CEH and its ilk want you to believe that they are simply out there to protect your interests, which is the reason presented to explain their "passionate" search for "scofflaws". But does that explanation hold water when the consumer group is essentially working on a commission for pay? Can you really be sure these violations are actually dangerous when it is clear that CEH must find them to pay its rent or keep its officers on the job? And what about the interests of the local politicians in this dynamic? Jerry Brown wants to be California's governor - what are his incentives in this case, being egged on by the pay-by-the-violation consumer group?

Does anyone see the possibility of conflicts of interest here? What is that odor I smell?

Aside from the OUTRAGE of CEH taking money for its escapades, the entire Proposition 65 gambit seems to be a parallel safety law allowing a local politician to upstage and trump federal regulation, all the while shaking down companies with duplicative penalties for the same offense. Mattel, no particular object of sympathy in my book, was hit with Prop. 65 penalties (collectively with others, $1.56 million), a "consumer fraud" settlement with 38 states for $12 million, a CPSC fine of $2.3 million and a class action settlement said to be worth more than $50 million. Since Proposition 65 is exempted from preemption by our wise Congress, this liability bonanza will continue to plague the toy industry for a long time to come (forever?).

What is the consequences of the long term, relentless, pointless (from a social good standpoint) assault on our industry under Proposition 65? A poisoned well. What do you think will happen to small business vendors to retailers who have been hounded and hunted under this law? The ultimate in skittishness. It is just not possible to satisfy their hunger for safety mania. As an example, a large national retailer has been demanding that our company test every product for lead-in-paint . . . regardless of whether it has any paint on it. That can only make sense in a world where the consequences of violations are too horrible to contemplate.

Is a violation of this law really worse than mass murder? I think not. This week's CEH violations are innocent and have not and will not harm anyone. They are minor manufacturing defects and can be corrected easily and inexpensively. By making each such trivial violation into a capital case, the cost of doing business skyrockets, profit incentive crashes and many players exit. We have already seen one offering memorandum for a customer of ours who can't take it anymore. Most of the exits are quieter and harder to detect. See my post about Whimsical Walney. If we allow regulators to run roughshod over our industry this way, there won't be anything left to protect. That would be terrible for all Americans. Sometimes you don't know what you have until you lose it.

This is your country. Think about the corruption of fee-driven consumer groups and marauding State AGs who don't answer to the CPSC. What are you going to do about it???

Wednesday, November 18, 2009

CPSIA - Let's Count the Reasons to be Outraged by CEH

Perhaps like me, you felt a surge of fear and loathing today over the Center for Environmental Health's effort hand-in-hand with CA Attorney General Jerry Brown to find products with "high levels of lead". CEH announced to great fanfare that it had found seven items that violated the law, and Jerry Brown plowed right in behind with a cease and desist order, demanding that these items be removed from shelves immediately. Several of the affected companies denied categorically that there were violations of law. I assume that Proposition 65 lawsuits are being prepared, and suitable penalties will rain down from the heavens in due course (you know, in three years) to properly punish the "scofflaws". Nice work, CEH.

CEH justifies its actions to destroy the children's product industry with misleading facts about lead. Here's how they describe the dreaded danger they are "protecting us" against:

"Lead is a stunningly toxic metal. A long list of problems has been linked to lead exposure: lowered intelligence, behavior problems, cancer, strokes, high blood pressure, kidney problems, anemia, cavities, and delayed puberty. While exposure to lead paint in old houses remains the most significant source of children’s lead exposure, about 30 percent of children with high blood lead levels are exposed to other sources of lead, including toys and other children’s products."

They go on to list a parade of horribles, such as "University of Cincinnati researchers found that arrest rates of young adults (both for violent crimes and all arrests) were linked to the blood lead levels of these adults when they were children. Higher childhood lead exposure was associated with higher arrest rates."

The interesting thing about these assertions about lead is that they are TRUE . . . and they are also IRRELEVANT in this case. There is absolutely no way to prove or even assert in any reasonable fashion that the products cited here could EVER poison children in this way or are responsible for ANY of the cited lead horrors. The CEH is just using plain vanilla scare tactics - did it work on you? Unfortunately, some newspapers bought it, hook line and sinker.

I hardly know where to start. Here are a few reasons to be flippin' mad about this stunt:

I. The Seven Items Present Little or No Risk. Consider this list of "frightening" product defects:

a. Disney Tinkerbell Water Lily necklace - Connector on pixie dust charm contains 22,000 parts per million lead. [I believe this connector is perhaps 3 mm in diameter.]

b. Barbie Bike Flair Accessory Kit - Pink star fabric contains 6196 parts per million lead. [This is an item used on a bicycle.]

c. Dora the Explorer Activity Tote - Orange fabric on back of tote contains 2348 parts per million lead. [I believe his fabric is not detachable and cannot be chewed.]

d. [This one's my favorite] TKS girl’s sandals - Orange insole contains 3957 parts per million lead. [To access this lead, you must lick or chew on the INSOLE of a pair of sandals. Yum!]

e. Kids poncho - Yellow fabric contains 677 parts per million lead. [Gotta chew on your poncho.]

f. [This is a close second] Faded Glory girl’s shoes - Sole contains 1331 parts per million lead. [It's like my old joke about licking the soles of your shoes after walking to school. Happens all the time . . . .]

g. Cherokee boys belt - Surface of belt contains 4270 parts per million lead. [I have no idea what the problem is here. Still, belt chewing is exceptionally rare and not foreseeable in my opinion.]

I hope you haven't begun rioting in the streets over these tragic "violations of law". Let's recap - this rogue's gallery includes a CONNECTOR, the fabric of a decorative star on a bike accessory, backing on a tote, the INSOLE OF A SHOE, the SOLE OF A SHOE, a poncho and a belt.

Let me be blunt - how brain-damaged must someone be to actually believe these things are dangerous?

II. Cassandra Here, Have I Mentioned My Concern about State AGs? Ahem, I believe I have noted my strong concerns about State AG enforcement of the CPSIA in the past (note, especially my April 4 post about Mr. Brown). In fact, I made a big point of this issue in my unread letters sent to the Congressional conferees in July 2008 . . . to no avail. Obviously, I was way off in my thinking. Worrywart . . . .

How outrageous is Mr. Brown's enforcement action? Well, he worked in concert with CEH apparently without talking to the CPSC. CEH practically brags about this ("In collaboration with the California Attorney General the Center for Environmental Health has spent the last six weeks monitoring compliance with the new law. . . . In October and November 2009 we purchased about 250 children’s products from major retailers in the Bay Area and San Diego. . . . We provided information about all of the violations to the California attorney general for enforcement action."). The CPSC seems to be irrelevant to CEH and Mr. Brown.

Ahem, CPSC - what do you think about being rendered irrelevant by a grandstanding State AG and an even more disruptive consumer group? Welcome to my world. Ms. Tenenbaum, in your continuing efforts to cultivate a positive relationship with the State AGs, you may wish to reflect on the behavior of Mr. Brown and his apparent commitment to you and your efforts to calm the markets and implement the new law. Yes, commitment, that's a nice word for it, don't you think?

Here's a word to ponder: "preemption".

III. Publicity-Hungry Consumer Groups Have Proven Their Own Corruption. Stirring up this kind of public shame and panic may be good for raising contributions to CEH, but it is nothing more than a shameful demonstration of anti-social behavior. REAL JOBS and REAL LIVELIHOODS are impacted by CEH grandstanding and NO possible public good was accomplished by the latest losses inflicted by the new toy safety laws. Even CEH concedes things are much better these days (on CBS News, Executive Director Michael Green noted "It is definitely a safer Christmas than it was two years ago."). Thanks, Mike, you have really reassured the American consumer!

CEH's grandstanding over ridiculous assertions of danger is irresponsible and in light of Green's concession of the safety of the marketplace, morally corrupt. Consider that in a six-week effort to find something "bad", the CEH schemers examined 250 products, and all they could find is a connector to a charm, the sole of a shoe and the INSOLE of a shoe. Wow, what a smoking gun! However, with a hepped-up State AG perhaps preparing a gubernatorial bid, even these pathetic findings are the perfect makings for a publicity event.

As if these acts of desperation, self-interest or moral degradation were not enough, both CEH and State AG Brown then attempt to convince the public that these products actually constitute a danger. "'Private testing uncovered a number of products designed for children that contain dangerous and illegal levels of lead,' Brown said in a prepared statement. 'These products must be removed from store shelves at once to protect our kids from toxic lead exposure.'" In the quote above, CEH contends that the presence of lead in products like this can be connected to "lowered intelligence, behavior problems, cancer, strokes, high blood pressure, kidney problems, anemia, cavities, and delayed puberty". Oooh, sounds AWFUL - now prove it! CEH and their merry band of anti-commerce loonies can only assert these harms - NO data exists that can link lead in these manifestations to ANY physical harm. But what's a good consumer group publicity event without unaccountable fear mongering?

Any sane adult or experienced parent knows that all this is baloney. This sad state of affairs confirms that the consumer groups do NOT deserve a leading role in setting the rules of the road in safety. They gave up the moral high ground when they decided to sell fear rather than advocate for safety.

Final Words: I was recently sent a blogpost link written by a consumer group about my testimony at the CPSC on November 10 about the CPSIA public database. Of course, since I am apparently a force from the Heart of Darkness (as you know), the consumer group blogpost scorned my testimony and painted the usual conspiracy theories that the wingnuts tend to favor. What was particularly notable about this post was the following note at the bottom of the page: "Comments are closed."

Get it? The consumer groups like having the last word. They like spreading the news that best suits their interests but don't want to answer to anyone else. [We have seen this before.] The consumer groups depend on the kindness of strangers - they need your contributions to pay their salaries. What better way to do this than sell their souls for some headlines? If you are the ones paying into their coffers with the thinking that they are looking out for you, I think you should carefully ponder the "good work" of Mike Green and his gang this week. Is this good for America? Is anyone safer now or better off? Or . . . are CEH and the other aligned consumer groups a bigger part of the problem than previously recognized?

After this stunt, I certainly hope no one will stick a microphone in Mike Green's face again.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

CPSIA - ICPHSO Toronto Update

I attended this week's ICPHSO meeting in Toronto. The meeting was located in Toronto and focused much attention on the proposed amendment to Canada's 40-year-old Hazardous Products Act (the so-called Bill C-6). The meeting was attended by more than 250 people, largely comprised of Health Canada officials (the analog to the CPSC), CPSC staff, including Chairman Inez Tenenbaum directly from China, a variety of testing companies, mass market companies, Canadian companies, lawyers and other interested parties.

I thought I would share a few tidbits from the meeting:

Chairman Tenenbaum's Keynote Speech: Chairman Tenenbaum addressed the conference on Wednesday morning. Her speech is posted on the CPSC website. The speech included a few hints of movement toward accommodation of businesses under the CPSIA, but unfortunately, it is only provides hints at this point. It is worth noting that sidebars at the conference suggest that there is more sensitivity to business concerns than CPSC public statements might suggest, but then again, we can only rely on real action, not just words. The next development to look for is a change in tone and a change in actions. When we can triangulate from words to actions, and see a real easing of the intense pressure on businesses, then we can take the off-line assurances more seriously.

Some highlights from the speech:
  • The "good": The "15 Month Rule" is due soon. Tenenbaum promised a special two-day workshop on this rulemaking IN ADDITION to normal public outreach. She emphasized that they want to "get it right". [Ed. Note: Rumorville has it that this rulemaking will be delayed, and the two day workshop may precede the issuance of the draft rule. Likewise, there is growing suspicion that the testing stay may therefore have to be stayed. There are multiple reasons why this may have to happen.]
  • She emphasized a need to minimize the burden on small businesses. [Minimize is a relative term, let's not get too giddy yet. Need to see what they have up their sleeves.]
  • The CPSC is reaching out to SAGs to make them partners in the safety process. She wants to minimize competition between the CPSC and the SAGs. I consider this a major advancement in CPSC practice and a nice contribution by Ms. Tenenbaum in the early days of her administration. Arguably, the 2007-8 crush of State legislation and SAG grandstanding evidenced strong State feelings of isolation and legal impoverishment (in addition to a general desire of local politicians to appeal to the populace before elections). A proactive approach by the CPSC to working with the SAGs is the best chance for ANY OF US to neutralize or minimize the disruptive behavior of States and SAGs in the future.
  • Ms. Tenenbaum announced a substantial change to the penalty factors when she said: "In cases where CPSC may impose a financial penalty on a U.S importer for violations, CPSC may to take into account whether the importer has safety or compliance programs in place and whether they conducted pre-market and production testing to minimize safety risks." Gib Mullan also acknowledged that the penalty factors will be changing. This is another faint sign that we are being heard. The penalty factors were very harsh in the first draft. After a bit of an uproar, it appears now that the agency is going to moderate its approach somewhat. If this turns out to be a "real" shift, it is good news indeed.
  • The "bad": The overall tone of the speech remained harsh and somewhat threatening, at least that's how it felt to me. Phrases such as the following were reminders that the CPSC has a big club and intends to use it:

- "Chinese suppliers and U.S. importers are now on notice from both governments that it is a mistake to depend on good intentions and a few final inspections to ensure compliance with safety requirements."

- "We will enforce in a firm but a fair manner the new federal law that puts strict limits on lead and phthalates in children’s products and makes all toy requirements mandatory." [The emphasis was hers in the live speech.]

- "As I have consistently stated, we intend to enforce this law that Congress put in place in a firm but fair manner. CPSC also has a federal rule making underway that puts U.S. importers on notice."

- "Another area that we at CPSC are rethinking is the singular approach used in the past to identify risks and simply recall products when necessary. This is one aspect of enforcement that will not work if pursued alone."

So Ms. Tenenbaum maintained the tough tone but gave hints of a coming thaw. We'll see in due course if I am imagining things. Needless to say, I hope not!

Remarks of Gib Mullan: Gib Mullan, the CPSC chief enforcement officer, gave a short speech summarizing the CPSIA and recent events. I must say I found some of this speech positively chilling. For one thing, Mr. Mullan noted with apparent satisfaction the first recall of a toy for violations of the phthalates ban. I believe this refers to the recall of 40 inflatable toy baseball bats previously highlighted in this space. Aside from the fact that Mr. Mullan confirmed that the enforcement focus of the agency is (supposedly) bath squeeze toys, which certainly does not include inflatable baseball bats, this micro-recall of 40 bats is highly suggestive of a strict liability enforcement policy. If that is so, then what is the purpose of pointing out this recall to the crowd at ICPHSO? I would suggest that it is intended to scare the business community. Mission accomplished?!

Further to that mission, Mr. Mullan announced that the agency is attempting to be more "consistent" and "rigorous" in assessing penalties. Okay kids, think of Target's $600,000 penalty - if the CPSC is going to be "consistent", what does that precedent mean for the rest of us? If Target gets hit with a massive penalty after it performed preshipment testing, had no actual knowledge, was increasing its safety surveillance and turned itself in voluntarily after catching its own errors, what should we expect from a "consistent" penalty practice at the agency now? Mr. Mullan continued by noting (again, with a bit too much relish) the rising tide of penalties assessed by the agency in 2009, and further noted that they haven't even cracked the 2007 lead-in-paint violations yet. He said larger penalties should be expected now, given the new powers allowed the agency under the CPSIA.

What is the purpose of this announcement? What else could it be, besides an intent to scare you and me? And, hats off to the chef, it succeeded. Among the many outrages of this new practice is the focus on retribution for old recalls with new penalties. Why is this a problem in my view? Well, for one thing, no one can do anything about the 2007 recalls at this point. Is the CPSC under the impression that the toy industry hasn't "learned its lesson" yet? If that isn't their view, then why lay on mega-penalties for matters that were apparently closed with significant expense now almost three years ago?

At what point is our penance complete? I can only supply a couple suggestions to explain this new penalty practice - (a) vindictiveness (as in CPSC meting out "justice", rather than simply ensuring a safe marketplace), and (b) terrorizing the corporate community into "compliance". Both rationales are wrongheaded and destructive. I continue to return to my original comment (December 17) on the penalty factors - CPSC penalties can only be consistent, rigorous, purposeful and (importantly) predictable if they are restricted to egregious conduct. Until the CPSC disciplines itself to a fairer penalty system, ALL OF US will assume we are next in line to get whacked like Target. After all, the CPSC has said publicly that they intend to be consistent and rigorous on penalties - in other words, they are telling us that we can and should learn from Target's experience. That message unleashes a parade of horribles. The CPSC needs to take this on board.

One last observation about Mr. Mullan's speech - he noted that recalls from China fell by 40% in 2009, the first fall in years. This is of course good news for everyone, most of all the children's product industry. As we know, success has many fathers but failure is an orphan. Many pundits point to the CPSIA as the reason that recalls have fallen. Mr. Mullan added another factor, the deep recession of 2009. Both of these factors contributed, but I think the real "father" of this success is that the notorious publicity of the new law and the new strict enforcement of the lead-in-paint rules (under the old law) led various companies and industry organizations to get mobilized to address safety practices. Who among us wasn't shocked and horrified by the suicide of the owner of a Chinese factory that supplied Mattel with lead-in-paint toys? The horrors of the recall frenzy and everything it entailed led to changes in practice. The remaining hubbub of the new law is just a hang-over IMHO, and does not explain the good recent reduction in recalls. For this reason, I believe the focus of the CPSC and its enforcement activities can and should SHIFT toward maintaining these gains through industry outreach, education, targeted and focused enforcement, and development of new and modern systems appropriate to the changing marketplace. It even calls into question the value of the law's kneejerk requirement of prophylactic testing, something I am on record opposing.

Health Canada and Bill C-6: Frankly, I have not had time to dig into the Bill C-6 yet but it got a lot of air-play at ICPHSO. Much of the brass at Health Canada was there, and I attended several talks by these professionals. I must say I left impressed with the Health Canada leadership. They were incredibly approachable and engaged. I was not made to feel like the "enemy". Especially notable was their TONE. They don't even imply that businesses are populated with bad or untrustworthy people. They repeatedly pledged to work cooperatively with businesses and noted that they have done well for 40 years with voluntary recalls and non-confrontational relationships. Hmmm, could it really be true that you catch more flies with honey than with vinegar?

They also stressed their interest in hearing about "lessons learned" and engaging in real dialogue as the new bill is crafted and refined. They noted some real gaps in their enforcement empowerment under the existing law, which they characterize as outmoded, but then again, they also stressed that these powers are intended to be used only if necessary. What a different tone they struck. They convinced me that they are nice people who mean to be partners in safety with industry. A refreshing change.

The contrast with the last year of CPSC hostility was palpable. It gave me reason to reflect on the course of my own relationship with the CPSC. Interestingly, I was a big fan of the agency until about two years ago. For 17 years I trusted them, I consulted with them, I had no reluctance to work with them and thought of them as partners, I advised friends to trust them, I did not see them as the 'enemy". The CPSIA and the feeding frenzy of the last two years sadly eroded that trust. Trust has to be earned, of course. I believe trust in the CPSC can be restored but not without real effort and real action. The Health Canada folks struck the right tone, and we can only hope that the CPSC was listening. Industry and the CPSC do not have to be at loggerheads, and there can be trust (there MUST BE trust). To get there, the "new" CPSC may need to make some concessions, but a path to this worthy karma level does exist. This detente does not need to involve endangering children, either. Health Canada implicitly recognizes that industry has no interest in harming children. Considerable efforts by industry are expended to avoid this terrible outcome. The presence of a few bad or incompetent actors in a massive marketplace of many thousands of companies and millions of different products does not make the rest of the market participants into bad guys, too. This is the notion that must be abandoned.

Final Thoughts: ICPHSO was a great event for networking, off-line conversations and sharing of perspectives. I feel that there is room for more dialogue. We can only hope that some barriers are being broken down, and that we may see some positive surprises (for a change). It is also clear, as Health Canada demonstrated, that a regulator can be effective and non-confrontational at the same time. We know the CPSC has a big stick, perhaps they can stop reminding us with harsh rhetoric and harsh actions (we won't forget about the stick, trust me). Next on the agenda is a rationalizing of the rules to allow businesses to function economically. Unfortunately, I cannot conceive of this development without a change in the law. To do this, the CPSC must summon up its resolve and TELL Congress that changes are needed. I do not see any way to avoid this. Time has a value, too, so the CPSC leadership must weigh the consequences of waiting - costs are mounting rapidly as time goes by.

I hope I'm not dreaming. This can be done. The coming weeks will reveal a lot about the direction and resolution of the pending issues confronting the business community.

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

CPSIA - Crain's Says We're About to Get Sued

In this week's Crain's Chicago Business, the news periodical speculate on which mass tort action could succeed asbestos as the next gravy train for plaintiff's attorneys. And guess who makes a guest appearance???

Asbestos and the legal black hole

By: Steven R. Strahler
September 28, 2009

Asbestos has lived up to its Greek origin — "inextinguishable" — on legal and medical landscapes alike: Mass tort actions involving asbestos have bankrupted more than 60 makers and users of the once-widespread insulating material, starting with Johns-Manville Corp. in 1982 and claiming Chicago's USG Corp. in 2001.

Odds are, corporate defendants won't see another mass tort topic like it: more than 700,000 claims pending against 8,000-plus defendants and estimated costs exceeding $250 billion. Because asbestos-related symptoms can take 30 years or more to manifest, the litigation is expected to last until mid-century.

. . . .

"No, there is no asbestos-like gravy train pulling up in front of the American Bar Assn.," says Robert Hartwig, president of the Insurance Information Institute. Still, he says, "there are great unknowns, like climate change and latent manifestation of occupational disease."

Among the most likely post-asbestos targets for plaintiffs' attorneys:

. . . .

Product liability

The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act of 2008 requires independent testing of children's products, including cribs and metal jewelry, empowers state attorneys general to file federal actions and increases penalties, all of which will boost opportunities for mass-tort suits.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

CPSIA - Fashion Jewelry Loses a BIG One

With morbid anticipation, I just read the statements of the three CPSC Commissioners on the Fashion Jewelry industry petition to exclude crystals and glass beads from the overbearing strictures of the CPSIA. On a day when I was a bit emotionally damaged by Tom Watson's failure to win the British Open, these statements more or less finished me off. Should we laugh or cry over this decision? Cry, because it bodes terribly for all of us.

The jewelry industry made all the usual arguments for excluding these non-controversial items from the law. The items in question have no history of causing injury, they are infrequently abused, the amount of lead possibly ingested is absurdly low, etc. Been there, done that. The staff recommended against the petition, per form, because the law clearly states that nothing can be exempt unless it either is always within the law's lead limits (in other words, it already complies) or else it cannot emit so much as an atom of lead into the body. The CPSC staff has previously opined that it has yet to identify a single Earthly material which meets this "common sense" standard which is why it has recommended denial of each and every stay.

The two Democrat Commissioners voted to deny the request on the grounds that the law does not permit exceptions. They then said they would direct the enforcement activities of the agency toward the class of children they deemed most "at risk" (a relative term, if there ever was one). Republican Nord also voted against the exclusion as required by law, but recommended a stay, mainly to allow Congress to fix the law.

Seems like "same old, same old", right? Not in this author's opinion. Here's what I take away:

a. The Days of Easy Stays are Over. The ATV'rs and bike industry can take some (limited) pleasure in their short stays. The window seems closed. Of course, it also means that when their stays are up, they are likely in big trouble. Chairman Tenenbaum took a strict constructionist view of the law: "[Having concluded that swallowing crystals and beads is foreseeable as required under Section 101(b)(1)(A),] the question turns to whether the ingestion or mouthing of these beads would result in the absorption of any lead by a child. In making a determination, I was mindful that the statute does not use the term "harmful" amount or another term which would allow staff to utilize a risk based approach." [She later explicitly rejects a risk based approach as not permitted under the CPSIA.] In other words, true to her word at her confirmation hearing, Ms. Tenenbaum is committed to enforcing the laws handed down by Congress without judgment. She read the law faithfully and did what it instructed. There was no consideration of consequences of the decision or of the relative risk posed by these materials.

Commissioner Moore chimed in with his own analysis of Congress' instructions on the narrow question of crystals. In quoting from the House Report behind HR 4040 (CPSIA), Moore noted that "Paragraph (4) authorizes the CPSC, in very narrow circumstances, to exclude, by rule, certain materials and products from the total lead weight limits. The lead content of these materials must be in a form that will not result in absorption of any lead whatsoever into the human body. . . ." [Emphasis added.] There you go.

Mr. Moore also notes that this decision of the Commission effectively overrules a Proposition 65 settlement applying to crystals. Not sure how the Commission's decision could be made more disruptive or commercially devastating. Even the over-the-top Proposition 65 is outdone by the CPSIA. The reliance of jewelry companies on this California settlement was seemingly not taken into account by Commissioners Moore or Tenenbaum. I believe the effect of this decision is to render the industry's inventory prepared in compliance with various states laws like California and Minnesota instantly WORTHLESS. To continue to sell these items on Monday is an intentional violation and we all know what misery that might bring. More gratuitous business risk and economic losses from your friends in Congress. . . .

I believe the Commission's stay decision on pens needs to be read very, very narrowly in light of the jewelry decision. It is hard for me to believe that the logic of the pens decision will be utilized again. Until it is, I believe that decision should be regarded as limited to the specific facts and circumstances of pens.

b. Economics Will Not Be Considered in Exclusion Decisions. Commissioner Nord produced a laundry list of immediate economic harm from the decision to reject a stay. It is shocking. Presumably, this data was available to the entire Commission but notably neither Tenenbaum nor Moore mentioned it. This makes sense because the CPSIA does not make financial impact relevant in these decisions. The Commission's decision is driven by the law's definition of the interest of consumers (note, I do NOT mean the ACTUAL interest of consumers), namely that "any lead is too much lead" and thus, financial impact is outside the decision matrix. I do not think this is right, because the law is really just a bundle of economic incentives, and in making this decision, the Commission is changing the rules of the market which will change behavior. Products will be killed, choice reduced and companies will exit. The widespread elimination of children's departments in the resale industry is a pertinent example of this effect. By narrowly defining consumer interests in this way, the CPSC ensures maximum economic damage to everyone.

Here's a glimpse of the future: In two years, the Commission will make a decision on whether the new 100 ppm lead limit is technologically feasible. This term is defined in the CPSIA in Section 101(d) - and nowhere will you find a reference to economics. Thus, my new pet saying can be taken as LAW now: If Rolex CAN do it, Timex MUST do it. Put that in your pipe and smoke it.

[There will be a Congressional election before this determination is made, please note. Some careful consideration of your voting choices could have a significant effect on this law, for those of us still in business by then.]

c. The Commission Seems to Think that Enforcement Discretion Makes Violations Go Away. The statements make clear that the CPSC won't be enforcing this rule outside of the market for children six years of age and under. What they do not address is the fact that they have clearly stated that these materials violate the law for all children 12 years of age and under. Thus, to "knowingly" import or sell these items into their no-enforcement zone is to take the chance that a shift in regulatory wind could mean BIGGGG trouble. The CPSC is unable to restrict the 50 State AGs either, so it leaves everyone WIDE OPEN to nastiness on the State level. Sound good? Who would take this chance?

The gerry rigging of this law in this way does not replicate the law that preceded the CPSIA (if that was the goal). In other words, this construct simply does NOT work to lessen risk or financial harm. By saying that the CPSC will only enforce in certain circumstances does NOTHING to make it easier to do business. We are not allowed to violate the law, whether the CPSC wants to enforce it or not. Read the penalties section and think about how penalties have been handed out so far (with lots of imputed "knowing" conduct). In the olde days, the decision on where to enforce or not was completely effective to demarcate the part of the market that needed to tighten its legal belt because back then, everything wasn't illegal. Now it is. The policy to only enforce in part of the market doesn't relieve any responsibility under the law - it only gives the appearance of shifting risk to that part of the market. Remember your 15(b) obligation to report - it still applies to ANY violation. Remember your whistleblower risk - you can't discuss using violative materials in the no-enforcement zone or risk "problems". Remember that any intentional violation of the law, whether the CPSC intends to enforce or not, could be grounds for a felony charge. Hey, it's not my idea - read the law. Do you want to run your business feloniously, even if the Commission says it's okay (today)?

d. Forget "Common Sense". The Commissioners in avoiding the obvious conclusion that glass beads and crystals can be safely sold and sticking closely to the ridiculous language on exemptions (notwithstanding the encouragement of the CPSC by a "primary sponsor" of the CPSIA to grant exclusions for "materials that can be shown to pose no [risk of a] measurable increase in a child's blood lead level", as noted by Ms. Nord) clearly breaks with the tentative baby steps of the Commission under Nord and Moore to introduce a semblance of common sense into the implementation of the CPSIA. Those days seem to be over. The new attitude appears to be that the law as written is to be enforced and that blunting the edges with "common sense" is inappropriate.

The Tenenbaum Commission's approach to statutory construction makes a lot of sense to me. I have long asked the Commission to enforce the written law and not make it up as they go along. Unwritten laws are even worse than bad written laws. I am glad the Commission is showing it can read. Congress remains in denial. I don't know if the jewelry decision is more of a message for Mr. Waxman or for you and me. If we or anyone wants a different way to administer safety, it will require a change in federal law. This is the reality of our situation, like it or not. This Commission apparently intends to enforce the law as written, and that won't change even if the law is foolish on its face. "Common sense" is no longer part of the calculus in interpreting this law strictly.

e. Don't Hold Your Breath for Relief on Tracking Labels. The narrow reading of the law by the Commission here, where almost nothing (other than money) was at stake, suggests grim tidings in the super-secret tracking labels guidance due to be voted into effectiveness without your comments on July 20. I can only speculate on why the Commission didn't think we should read the guidance before they voted on it. I think we could have handled it. The jewelry decision suggests that it is highly likely that the many problems created by the tracking labels provision will be left in place. As previously noted, the CPSC has not deigned to respond to ANY questions on the noxious tracking labels provision in the last 11-and-a-half months. We have no idea where they stand on anything.

Let me give you a great example - I think the guidance is going to require you to disclose your sources on your packaging and on your product directly. This was forecast by Gib Mullan and Cheryl Falvey at ICPHSO in February (we were told to "get over the mourning process"). This term alone will kill many companies and many products. All high volume customers will now have the option to go direct, courtesy of Congress. While this may seem like a zero sum game at first glance, what it really means is that the incentive to innovate or take financial risk on any item that you cannot protect will end. Private labeling will become much harder or impossible. Trading among competitors will end. The net result will be shrunken markets and withered companies. Serious consequences will follow. Again, the Commission has more or less indicated that economic consequences are not its concern, as Congress in its infinite wisdom has determined this provision is best for all of us. Brace for it.

I have long stated that tracking labels is the absolute worst part of this law. The emergency posed by this law is drawing near. If tracking labels becomes law on August 14 without delay and if this law isn't revised significantly in the very near future, the outlook appears very, very grim for all of us. The posture of this Commission suggests that we might be facing a worst case scenario soon. This is disappointing, to say the least. It is Congress' fault. The CPSC is doing what has been asked of it, ridiculous or not.

If you are still sitting on your hands, you might want to call your lawyer soon.

Monday, July 6, 2009

CPSIA - How to Solve Your Problems!

The CPSIA Answer Man gets questions, we get questions! The CPSIA is much simpler than most people believe. Congress, having wisely given so much discretion to the CPSC and to you, left many options open for virtually any situation. Here's a few common "dilemmas" and their simple solutions:

Q: "My Company is straining to survive in tough times, and someone told me that because our products are modified by downstream dealers, I might be liable to comply with this law. I have never tested my items, which are known to be safe, but now I understand I will have to test and even label each item by lot. I don't want to do that, and can't figure out how I would afford it. Mr. CPSIA Answer Man, what should I do?"

A: This could be a major bummer for you, my sad friend. Under Section 3(a)(2) of the CPSA, your products would be subject to the new strictures on lead and tracking labels if they are "children's products", that is "a consumer product designed or intended primarily for children 12 years of age or younger". Hmmm, that could be just about anything. The CPSC has clarified this to the opacity of mud. Consider the many unanswered questions of the Promotional Products industry on this very topic, where companies sell "blanks" that are later modified and resold, possibly as items suitable for children.

So let me answer your question with a question: are you one of those small-minded individuals who craves certainty and cannot abide by guessing or living in the shadows? I hope not, because if you are, you will find yourself compelled to pretend all aspects of the law apply to you. After all, having read the pen stay decision, it appears to be a judgment call whether an item is designed or intended "primarily" for children. And in the world of CPSIA judgment calls, you are encouraged to make the right decision - as determined by other people after the fact.

If you conclude that the law MIGHT apply to you, and can tolerate the risk of any of 51 organizations (the CPSC and 50 States SAGs) coming after you, you should adopt the now common approach to dealing with the CPSIA - non-compliance! Yes, it's low cost and gets the job done with very little bureaucracy. It's one of life's little ironies that this law, intended to facilitate tougher regulation of safety, actually ENCOURAGES non-compliance. Our dear friends in the Consumer Group community know it, too. I am not exactly sure what Congress thought it was accomplishing with this new scheme, other than economic devastation, but heck, I always knew I wasn't smart enough to be in government.

Q: "You have GOT to be kidding. When my dealers call up to assert that the law applies to me and to force me to absorb new costs and responsibilities, what am I supposed to tell them?"

A: Now THAT'S a good question. Mr. CPSIA Answer Man has tried several approaches, such as claiming to not speak English, wrong number, out to lunch, etc. These strategies don't seem to work very well. Unfortunately, our friends in government have not left you with much to say. You have your fig leaf, and need to bob and weave to convince your customers that your approach would stand up if tested. These debates are usually settled on the basis of economic power. Oops, you lose!

This raises one of the delicious ironies of this new law. If you are hiding behind a tiny fig leaf and are getting pressure to move into a safe harbor, what can you do? Sometimes, the law's designated safe harbors (such as lead substrate levels of 300 ppm as of August 14 or TRU's 100 ppm limit as of January 1) simply means you must exit your market, which may not be an option for any number of reasons. I am going to assume that safety is not a real concern for your products, since it has been made clear that only a tiny percentage of children's products ever get recalled. Since Congress wants the CPSC to act with "common sense", is there a way to make a case for such safe products to get into that safe harbor? The answer is NO. The law does not allow exceptions. The only exemptions possible under the law are for products that ("on the basis of the best-available, objective, peer-reviewed, scientific evidence") cannot possibly introduce so much as ONE atom of lead into the body. Thus, you get exempted if you can prove it never applied to you in the first place. SAFETY IS IRRELEVANT. Ouch!

Mr. CPSIA Answer Man wants to remind everyone that none of the foregoing has anything to do with safety. We all have a responsibility to our customers to behave honorably and with a sense of duty when it comes to safety. You should always do the safety testing necessary to satisfy yourself that it is safe and appropriate to sell your products, and need to take into account everything you know when you make that judgment. Control of your supply chain is a big part of how you will achieve this. No matter what you conclude in your administration of CPSIA survival, you can never lose sight of your safety responsibilities.

Q: "What if one of my dealers takes it upon him/her to test one of my products that I have concluded is OUTSIDE the law's confines? What am I supposed to do if they show me the report? What if they demand that I recall the product based on this unnecessary, irrelevant and possibly erroneous test report?"

A. Don't go there.

Q: "This is turning into a blood pressure incident for me. I don't believe this blather you are spouting. Where are the rules and regulations so I can read them myself?"

A: Mr. CPSIA Answer Man does not wish to frustrate! Here is the CPSC's highly touted CPSIA website, see if you can find the rules and regulations yourself. Of course, don't forget to look at the FAQs, which are treated with the seriousness of regulations (until they aren't). Also, you should check out the letters of the General Counsel, but they don't always hold up and aren't the equivalent of a Commission decision (in other words, the Commission can back away from the GC if it wants to). And if you are really resourceful, you might try to find an unpublished CPSC or GC letter to a company on its products that holds a clue for you, or perhaps pick up a useful voicemail from a CPSC staffer along the way that seems to shed some light. Sadly, nothing is really obvious in this arena, since there is no way for the CPSC (or anyone, frankly) to regulate such a vast array of products and have sensible rules that apply to all of them - so you will need to hire experienced counsel. Gather all the experts around a table and see what conclusions you come to. If you have more questions, Mr. CPSIA Answer Man remains at your service!

Q: "The testing costs are going to kill me. We can't afford all these tests because our items generate too little volume to bear the cost. Interestingly, we also don't see much value in purchasing test reports whose results we know before we pay the money. If I really have to bear these unnecessary costs, I will have to gut my product line - and fire some people. My customers want these products, too! What should I do? Also, I know I don't have to test (yet) but am responsible to be compliant with the lead limits. How do I make sure I comply without testing?"

A: I am so glad you asked this question, as it is on so many minds these days. We already covered the fact that an exemption for you is unlikely. Some people want to allow component testing. This sounds good, and for manufacturers of the simplest items, it may work fine. Unfortunately, no one seems to have thought through how a system based on component testing would work. A few "stumbling blocks" might include: (i) incomprehensible test reports (don't correlate or can't be correlated to the finished goods), (ii) reversion to the old "trust me" safety system but with more bureaucracy and cost, (iii) uncooperative component manufacturers who aren't legally required to provide test reports (think of the low volume fabric that is sold in your neighborhood sewing shop), and (iv) ever-finer gradations of components makes the testing scheme into a laughingstock.

As usual, all roads leading to Rome and all that, the issue of what is safe and what is not becomes relevant again. You will not be allowed to argue for an exception based on the safety of your products (socks and underwear?). The rules are blind to safety or risk assessment. Unless and until the law is trimmed back to something more reasonable and appropriate, a la Canada, you better figure out how to finance your testing burden starting with lots made on or after February 10, 2010. The banks are getting healthier - perhaps you can take down a big fat loan!

As to complying without testing, that's a rather metaphysical requirement of this law. Aren't those folks in Congress sneaky?! Wow, if I only had their cleverness . . . . This is the same thinking that underlies their choice to make 600 ppm lead-in-substrate legal from February 10 - August 14, 2009 and then instantly turn it into illegal, dangerous contraband. I wish I could fathom the "logic" of that one. After all, they specifically set the February 10th limit and authorized it for sale, which suggests that they believed it was safe enough to fob off on the American public. Well, it makes a satisfying sound bite at least. I think the requirement to comply while staying the testing requirement is just another compromise on the way to, well you know where. There is no logic to it. You can use supply chain management, selective testing, comprehensive XRF studies of your product range and business judgment. Even this won't work for all of you. Non-compliance anyone?

Q: "My greatest fear is those darned tracking labels. I can't identify my sources on my products, no matter what the Federal government wants. I might as well turn in the keys for my business. Is there ANYTHING I can do? Is there ANY guidance I can hang on to?"

A: The CPSIA Answer Man shares your concern. Today is July 7 and with the tracking labels requirement due to become active in a mere 39 days, the CPSC has yet to so much as float a single sentence of advice. Well, except for Commissioner Moore, who is looking forward to a delightful "learning process". He seems to think that if guidance is put out sometime before the August 14 deadline (August 13, perhaps?) for the crafting community, all would be well. I take it you are not a crafter. Ouch!

Many comment letters have been filed with the CPSC on tracking labels, including mine, which set out concerns like yours. The issue of confidential sources has been highlighted as a "deal killer" yet the CPSC remains silent. Notably, at the ICPHSO conference in February, the General Counsel specifically addressed this point and told the audience to "get past the mourning process" because Congress wants source information to be publicly available. So I guess you should probably begin to hang crepe, if you are to take this advice seriously.

For what it's worth, the NAM petition to stay the tracking labels provision was recently refiled. Hope springs eternal. Let's hope the Commission acts with "common sense" and pushes the day of reckoning on tracking labels far off into the horizon.

Saturday, April 25, 2009

CPSIA - Kafkaesque

I find myself thinking of the writings of Franz Kafka. Kafka's iconic novels, including The Metamorphosis and The Trial, are disorienting and nightmarish. I have read several of his novels and found them disturbing and provocative. I never felt I truly understood Kafka until it was pointed out to me that he is considered a "Jewish writer". Seen in the context of history, The Metamorphosis (1915) (the story of Gregor Samsa, a traveling salesman who overnight turns into a giant cockroach) and The Trial (published posthumously in 1925) (the story of Joseph K. who is arrested and charged with unspecified crimes to be tried by an unspecified court and judge on an unknown date) can be seen as eerily foretelling the dark events of the 20th Century to follow in the coming years, including the Holocaust and the secret purge trials of Joseph Stalin. Arguably, Kafka was also a legal commentator, anticipating how laws and the rules of society were on a downward trajectory in the 20th Century, imperiling the role of the individual in society. Kafka's three younger sisters died in the Holocaust, but Kafka himself never lived to see it - he died in 1924 of tuberculosis.

The disturbing metaphors of these novels ring in my ears. When you think about what followed Kafka's death, the novels take on a power that is beyond their words. The world he was describing incredibly, shockingly, came to pass years later.

I feel like a cockroach myself these days. Having worked for almost two decades to build our education company, and having done so responsibly, I find that we have been labeled a cockroach by our government for imagined transgressions. Actually, thousands of companies have been labeled cockroaches for the same unjustifiable reasons. Not unlike the experiences of Gregor Samsa, I find that we are being isolated, prevented from earning our living, and are shrinking from our former size. Samsa ended up bug-sized and incommunicado.

It is also true that I feel like we have been charged with unspecified crimes by an unidentified tribunal to be tried on a date unknown to me. I cannot figure out what we have done wrong or how we can repair the damage. Like Joseph K., I am looking for someone to defend us against charges that must be wrong - I have scoured my business life and cannot find the crime. Joseph K. ends up being convicted and is executed at the end of the novel. Joseph K.'s last words: "Like a dog."

The Trial in particular is a stunning metaphor for the dilemmas we face. The laws that underlie Joseph K.'s arrest and the unspecified charges are nowhere to be found. He cannot read them, he cannot rebut them. The "laws" exist only by the assertion of the mysterious people who have charged him with crimes. Using the same authority that enabled them to charge him with unspecified crimes, the unnamed court also convicts and sentences him. Unnamed people execute him. He has no recourse and dies alone.

Unwritten laws are subject to abuse. Kafka described the "legal system" of a totalitarian regime. Joseph Stalin used a similar "legal system" to his advantage in the decade following Kafka's death, engineering quick trials in the 30's to convict his enemies of vaguely described crimes, followed by execution within 24 hours. He was clever - he maintained the appearance of a legal system (there were charges, a court, a judge, lawyers, a "trial", even confessions) to preserve the illusion of individual rights. In fact, the system was designed to be manipulated to whatever ends he determined. He could assert he was motivated by justice and protection of the People.

The CPSC's ATV enforcement stay, justified by the agency's supposed "enforcement discretion", makes a mockery of the Rule of Law in children's product safety. If the "law" is not the one available on the CPSC website, then I must conclude it's a secret law present I know not where. The Commission's actions go far beyond exercise of discretion and far beyond their own precedent and statements on the operation of the law. While we certainly don't live in a totalitarian society, the activity of the CPSC in the ATV stay erodes the operation of law and is on a slippery slope. Tell me where it ends - I do not know.

This is a SERIOUS issue, and I hope both the CPSC and Congress takes it seriously. I do not wish to be subject to the risks Mr. Kafka highlighted, and further believe that the U.S. Constitution protects me from that possibility.

A quick side note: In a world with unwritten laws and secret enforcement stays known only on the whisper circuit, it will be impossible to administer your business. Let's not forget that the CPSC's stays (explicit or implicit) have NO effect without the cooperation of all 50 SAGs. Those SAGs were empowered to enforce the CPSIA as they see fit. Think of 51 secret laws now, not just one at the CPSC. In addition, thanks to the CPSIA, violations of any of a number of (unspecified) laws require 24 hour notice to the CPSC under Section 15 of the CPSA. For instance, this obligation would cover one missing warning label on your website. Yes, 24 hour notice for every violation, regardless of how trivial. AND any "knowing" (actual or imputed) violation of law may constitute the basis of a felony charge. How's that for coercive power for 51 different, independent regulators?

The final "gotcha" is the whistleblower provision. You cannot even THINK OUT LOUD about the most minor violations of the law in your office for fear of being turned in. Yes, cockroaches, the government has filled your office with spies to encourage you to toe the line. If you make a mistake or put something off until after your vacation, you are theoretically exposed to a disgruntled employee going "State's Evidence" against you and sticking around to collect a paycheck. The "relief" being offered in the guise of "enforcement discretion" will provide no relief whatsoever.

The imaginary law, the one in the heads of the CPSC as evidenced by the ATV enforcement stay, won't help us run our businesses. Rub your hands with glee, Congress, we are stuck with your awful bill EVEN IF the CPSC exercises its "enforcement discretion". I know you won't like the comparison, but I think Mr. Stalin would be impressed, guys. Like a dog. . . .

I don't care how desperate the 28 Senators are. Fix the damn law.

Saturday, April 18, 2009

CPSIA - The Significance of the ATV Exemption Decision

As you may know by now, the CPSC as anticipated denied the ATV Exemption request on Friday on the grounds that the law does not permit exemption of ATVs from the noxious CPSIA. On this point, both Commissioners agree. The Commissioners voted 2-0 to extend a retroactive and permanent enforcement ban on ATVs made on or before May 1, 2011, thus permitting the continued manufacture and sale of child-sized ATVs for at least two more years, and directed their staff to prepare an official enforcement ban for publication in the Federal Register. What does this all signify?

1. The Continuing Issuance of Stays is an Acknowledgement of the Flaws in the CPSIA. This is essentially the third stay of the CPSIA, and perhaps not the last. [Look for a stay of the tracking labels requirement as chaos is again building in the marketplace.] Having stayed the testing and certification requirements for a year, and deferred enforcement of the law against certain products and materials previously, the Commissioners have again put the law on hold. Why would "landmark" legislation need to be stayed again and again, and may need to be stayed some more? Let me suggest an obvious reason - the law makes no sense and the CPSC cannot make it make sense. Not only does the CPSC recognize that the law is toxic to commerce, which is not the desired purpose of well-crafted safety legislation, but it is also turning many safe and valued products into endangered species. As the Commissioners note, the law is so restrictive that a stay is the only means they have available to avoid the most terrible consequences of this overreaching law.

PLEASE NOTE the absence of howls of protests from Congressional "leaders" and consumer groups over the gutting of the retroactive feature of the CPSIA for the benefit of the ATV'rs. I thought these luminaries told us the standards were intended by Congress to be retroactive and that (evil) American industry had enough time to get the old product off the shelf. If so, why aren't our Mother Protectors screaming about the terrible CPSC Commission selectively letting the ATV industry off the hook??? That darned Nancy Nord again . . . oh yeah, it was Thomas Moore, too. Perhaps the screamers' principles aren't quite so rock hard, and retroactive effect of the lead and phthalate standards weren't actually essential to preserve our way of life after all. Hmmm. Senators???

What does that say about the law itself?

2. The CPSIA Puts the CPSC in Gridlock (not Nancy Nord). The Commissioners continue to struggle with the straitjacket imposed by Congress. In the case of the ATV Exemption request, the staff indicated that the law compelled them to deny the application despite absurdly low lead intake from ATVs (far below daily lead intake from food, water and breathing, ah but details like this are the hobgoblin of the small mind . . .). Likewise, BOTH Commissioners came to the same conclusion. Nancy Nord: "It is clear that the law does not give the Commission the flexibility to grant an exclusion for the petitioners' products." Thomas Moore: "Given the extremely restrictive language of the law, the only avenue I can see is for the Commission to establish an enforcement plan that follows, to the greatest extent possible, the Act's intention for future production. . . ." The Commissioners are stuck and make no bones about it.

Okay, so no exemptions are possible. [Senators, there's some "common sense" for you.] How about the future? Can manufacturers ever find a way to wriggle out of the ridiculous restrictions or will the entire Children's Products industry be slave to these inflexible restrictions going forward? Ummm, we're slaves. The enforcement stay proposed by the Commissioners after considerable delay to study their legal options states that the standard for relief in the future will be "technical feasibility". This sounds like a logical standard, something that reasonable people exercising "common sense" could administer capably, right? I don't know how to tell you this [Senators] but . . . no, not right.

The term "technological feasibility" is defined in Section 101(d) of the CPSIA specifically to tie the hands of the CPSC. Among other things, no consideration of economics is allowed. Notably, something is considered technologically feasible if "a product that complies with the limit is commercially available in the product category . . . or . . . alternative practices, best practices, or other operational changes would allow the manufacturer to comply with the limit." In other words, if Rolex can do it, Timex MUST do it. Mr. Moore, whose enthusiasm for this law seems to approach the pathological, gloats: "The evidence considered is strictly limited to technological feasibility, not on the higher cost of a viable substitute. The guiding principle of this agency's determinations has to be the safety of the children . . . ." Notwithstanding the non sequitur of Mr. Moore's second sentence, his statement is a clear admission that the CPSC has no way to exercise that famous "common sense" recommended by Senator Pryor and his flock.

3. The Notion that a New Chairman Would Impact Outcomes Has Been Exposed as Nonsense. This is the 24th consecutive CPSIA decision of the two person CPSC Commission which has been decided 2-0. There are NO examples of 1-1 votes on the CPSIA. The two Commissioners read the law EXACTLY the same. My heavens, if the Commissioners under this kind of pressure read the law as similarly as they do, is it POSSIBLE that they read the law correctly and are working in concert, exercising similar sound if constrained judgment and in fact, are doing their jobs responsibly? The new Chairman is supposed to clean this up by instituting a new policy at the CPSC to . . . what? Break the law? The demand for a new Chairman to "resolve" the issues under the CPSIA insults the public's intelligence. The Members of Congress and consumer groups that stand in line to bash Nancy Nord and blame her for these decisions and the direction of the agency shame themselves with their mischaracterization of the facts.

4. Fairness and Equity in Safety Regulation or Application of Rules across Industry Lines is Another Casualty of the CPSIA. I am happy for the ATV'rs that they got a break on the unfair retroactive application of the lead standards to their products and inventory. Our suffering need not be their suffering. It is worth noting, however, that they are not alone in their need for relief from the retroactive impact of the law or its harsh disruption of their marketplace. The rippling impact of this law on many industry groups has been well-documented. At a minimum, I simply cannot understand how the CPSC could justify giving a PERMANENT pass on retroactive effect for ATVs through May 1, 2011, but not do the same for all other industries affected by this law. This is shocking, irresponsible, oblivious, unfair and unkind. Had Congress or the CPSC actually given a two-year pass to everyone on retroactivity (preferably several months ago), the transition time alone would have cured many ills, including the need to sort out how to administer the new rules. Likewise, a big chunk of the problem for resellers of used or donated goods would be resolved or at least tabled for further study. Instead, justice will apparently be meted out slowly and unevenly, and will be governed by economics. You can safely anticipate that there will be justice for the rich only. Only rich industries or companies will be able to afford to mount the multi-million dollar effort to appeal for these exemptions. Crafters, for instance, will be sacrificed unless a Sugar Daddy saves them. Don't count on it.

5. The Future of Safety Regulation is Bureaucracy and Complexity without Benefit. The decision in the ATV case makes it clear that unless the law is changed, regulation of safety in children's products will be by exception only. Having mandated that regulating by risk assessment is no longer permitted, Congress' great new scheme is to make everything illegal unless the Commission decides it isn't illegal. It will be years, if not forever, before a coherent, settled law emerges. In the meantime, we will live in the grey zone.

As I have written in the past, there will be significant costs to a regulatory system based on exceptions. For one thing, it will be exceptionally difficult to clearly understand the rules if you must first find and understand all the exceptions. While this might sound achievable, it is not. Neither the law nor its exceptions are clear or entirely black-and-white. Case law or a body of other regulatory decisions will slowly and expensively clarify the law - provided you can find, understand and utilize those decisions. And. . . the body of decisions may not (likely will not) set out the answers applicable to you. It is typically clear as mud.

What will life under this kind of legal system look like?

  • You will need to hire counsel. You will not feel comfortable making the legal analysis yourself. You will also become accustomed to weighing legal risks in the normal, everyday conduct of your business.
  • Easy things will become hard. There will be a need for vast paperwork that does not contribute to the development of your business or the satisfaction of your customers.
  • Your costs will rise to cover the bureaucracy. This will not make your products more valuable or raise the price you will receive for them in the market.
  • Increasingly, your focus will be on paper, not building your business. Regulatory paper will become the medium of trade and owing to the blizzard of paper will lose its meaning. Your business processes will feel Dickensian. [Ah consumer groups, thank you so much for all you are doing to make America great!]
  • You will learn to fear the CPSC and State regulators in your bones for the randomness and pettiness of their rule administration. Rules, NOT common sense, will dominate in a world of forbidden risk assessment, and random seizure of your profits (through fines and technically-driven recalls) will become commonplace. If this sounds apocalyptic, talk to anyone who has dealt with Customs. Get used to it.

6. Small Business is the CPSIA's Sacrificial Lamb. Who survives in a world defined by the ATV decision? This decision makes clear that a serious and expensive legal campaign is required to get permission to sell known safe products that give off about as much lead as four cups of water from your kitchen tap. [You know, the water you feed to your children and grandchildren, and drink yourself.] This is unaffordable and well-beyond the capabilities of 99% of all regulated companies and is thus a closed door (effectively) for small business. We have seen a recent letter by Senator Durbin's staff practically clucking at the nobility of sacrificing small business to the need for pre-market testing. As an Illinois resident, I find this indescribably infuriating. I understand the importance of small business to the marketplace and to local communities. I work at a small business and fear what will happen to us if this law is not gutted quickly. If we really must accommodate these rules, our business will become unrecognizable. That would be a very sad day for me, for our associates, for our marketplace and for our valued customers.

7. The CPSC Has Been Neutered as a Regulator. Ms. Nord sums it up in her April 17 letter: "I hope the state attorneys general will follow our lead in [the enforcement ban on ATVs.]" I hope so, too. That being said, in an orderly legal system, there is one policymaker, one decision-maker. The U.S. Supreme Court doesn't close all of its decisions by saying "We sure hope the Supreme Courts of California, Arizona and the other 48 States will follow our lead on this one." In our business, we say "Hope is not a strategy." Uh-oh.

The CPSC knows it has been cuckolded by the law since it is now subject to oversight by 50 SAGs. If you get yourself a nice two-year enforcement stay from the CPSC, are you going to take a chance to continue to sell your products when Lisa Madigan (SAG-IL) or Edmund Brown (SAG-CA) or others might choose to read the law differently than the CPSC? Does the Federal stay actually mean ANYTHING? According to my 15-year-old daughter, who has more common sense than at least 28 Senators I can name, the answer is NO. And, yes, these SAGs are not above telling the CPSC that they read the CPSIA wrong (see my recent blogpost on this topic). There is no longer a law of the land.

Final Thoughts. With the ATV decision in the books, we now must wait for the enforcement stay to be written up and published. Don't expect any surprises as the Commissioners have published their expectations already (again, one list from the 2-0 Commission vote). Will other industries raise their voices in protest? Questionable, in my opinion. If the past few months has not been enough to get people over their (irrational and misplaced) animal fears, I don't know how the current situation will add much motivation. There aren't enough motivated and persistent protestors out there, and frankly, it's understandable. The economy's still a wreck so everyone needs sales, not new hobbies. Advantage, lead fear mongers.

Time will tell. I hope some of you will answer the call.

Rick