Showing posts with label Apparel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Apparel. Show all posts

Sunday, July 24, 2011

CPSIA - Participate in the AAFA Email Campaign to AMEND THE CPSIA!

The American Apparel and Footwear Association sent out the following request to the thousands of affected companies and individuals concerned about Congress' inaction on the CPSIA.  Please show your support by sending in an email in support of ECADA (the pending CPSIA Amendment in the House Energy and Commerce Committee).

Thank you!


"Hi.  At some point over the past few years, you have contacted Congress to urge relief from the crushing burdens of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA) using the legislative action center that we host on the AAFA website. Your advocacy has proved critical in raising Congressional awareness of the many problems that have characterized the CPSIA so far.

But we still need your help. Urgently!

A key House committee is currently considering amendments to the CPSIA that would provide relief in a number of areas, including testing, inaccessibility for phthalates, very small business, used products, ATVs and bikes, and retroactive application of the lead rules.

This amendment (H.R. 1939) will make our product safety system operate smarter while making sure that small businesses and other product safety stakeholders don’t get smothered in stifling regulations, extraordinary testing costs, and burdensome paperwork. We can’t let serious product safety risks be ignored while we endlessly test safe products and drive companies out of the children’s product business.

This amendment will not be considered unless Members of Congress hear from their constituents – you and your neighbors – demanding immediate action.

Help us bring commonsense back to our product safety rules.

Time for action is now. Your voice matters.

Please take a moment and send an email to your elected House and Senate members urging them to swiftly pass an amendment to the CPSIA. Please urge your family and friends to contact Congress.

Click here to make your voice heard and help get action on this important issue.

Thanks.

Steve Lamar
Executive Vice President
American Apparel and Footwear Association


Please see below some important resources:

- Copy of NAM ad that appeared in the Hill Newspaper urging action

- Op-Ed by Product Safety Expert Eric Stone describing the CPSIA Amendment

- Editorial from The Wall Street Journal

- Read ECADA"

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

CPSIA - Write the Senate to Stop the Database!

The AAFA has created an easy way to send emails to your Senators to encourage them to support the House's effort to de-fund the CPSIA database until it is fixed. Please click on this link and let your voice be heard in Washington!

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

CPSIA - Tell the CPSC to Extend Testing Stay!

The AAFA has created a link where you can easily send a message to the five CPSC Commissioners to extend the Testing and Certification Stay, due to expire on February 10th. The expiration of this stay will greatly harm the business community but will contribute NOTHING to consumer safety.

The AAFA letter draws from the NAM letter posted in this space yesterday.

PLEASE send this email and ask all your friends, associates, suppliers and customers to add their voice to this important plea.

Thank you!

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

CPSIA - Comment Letter on the "15 Month Rule"

August 3, 2010

Todd A. Stevenson
Director, Office of the Secretary
Room 820
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission
4330 East West Highway
Bethesda, Maryland 20814

Agency: Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC)

Re: Docket No. CPSC–2010-0038 Testing and Labeling Pertaining to Product Certification.

Dear Mr. Stevenson:

I am hereby submitting comments in response to the Solicitation of Comments on Testing and Labeling Pertaining to Product Certification (Docket No. CPSC–2010–0038) published in the Federal Register on May 20, 2010 (the “Proposed Rule”).

The End of (Business) Life As We Know It:

As I sit down to record my comments on this rule, I take comfort in knowing that the CPSC admits what it is doing here. In a section entitled “Caveats and Possible Market Reactions to Third Party Testing Requirements”, the agency acknowledges the severe impact of its new rule on manufacturers:

a. Significantly increased costs,
b. Incentive to redesign (presumably successful) products,
c. Incentive to reduce features on products,
d. Incentive to eliminate (presumably useful) components in finished goods,
e. Incentive to reduce product lines,
f. Exit the market altogether,
g. Go out of business,
h. Create barriers to entry for future business expansion, especially in specialty markets (non-mass market),
i. Devastate niche markets (noting particularly the “special needs” educational market – sorry, blind kids!), and
j. Incentive to delay or forgo product or manufacturing process improvements (to avoid testing costs).

Quite a stimulus program! Of course, the CPSC knows we can’t meet this challenge alone. In “The Potential Effects of the Proposed Rule”, the agency advises us to hire a few helpers:

a. Lawyers to review CPSC regulations,
b. Engineers and chemists to develop product specifications, conduct tests and design a program for production testing,
c. Statisticians or consultants to determine the frequency, sample size and collection method for production testing, and
d. Technicians, “perhaps working under the supervision of an engineer, chemist or similar professional”, to perform production tests.

This certainly is a Brave New World for us. Luckily we have the CPSC to tell us what to do. Unfortunately, we can’t afford an in-house legal department or teams of engineers, chemists or statisticians. We don’t even have technicians. Incredibly, somehow we bumble on in our blissful, almost charming ignorance, having had only one recall of 130 pieces (we recovered every unit) out of perhaps 1,000,000,000 units sold in the last 26 years. No doubt all the pain the CPSC is promising us will be worth it . . . gotta keep everyone so safe.

Seriously, Is Anyone Listening?

On page 28338 of the Federal Register, the Proposed Rule reproduces the “reasonable testing program” as it stood before the December 10-11, 2009 workshop at the CPSC. The workshop (which we attended with three people who were each asked to appear as a panelist) was ostensibly for the purpose of giving “stakeholder feedback” on the so-called “15 Month Rule” (the Proposed Rule) and the component testing rule (also up for comment today, posted under separate cover). We gave detailed feedback on these rules – none positive – yet the Proposed Rule seems to have preserved the original, deeply-flawed concepts intact.

It is difficult not to conclude that the process of providing feedback to this CPSC is a sham. While Chairman Tenenbaum has long touted her “policy” of seeking feedback from all stakeholders including industry, judging from this rule, the commitment to seeking feedback does not involve maintaining an open mind. It appears that the most likely feedback to be well-received is feedback that ratifies what the agency already plans to do. Other feedback is “wrong”, I guess. I doubt you will find this letter useful.

As time ebbs on and as the drumbeat of a CPSC bent on our destruction becomes more and more clear, the incentive to waste a few days preparing detailed comments also ebbs. Nevertheless, owing to the importance of this Proposed Rule, I am hereby submitting comments. I have no reason to be optimistic that you will consider my point of view with an open mind. This rule has all the earmarks of a fait accompli.

Deeply Flawed Economic Analysis.

The Proposed Rule devotes pages and pages to a tortured analysis of its purported compliance with the Regulatory Flexibility Act (“RFA”). This section of the Proposed Rule is a virtual admission of how unworkable the rule is (and the CPSIA testing scheme in general). As a starting point, the rule states: “The objective of the rule is to reduce the risk of injury from consumer products, especially from products intended for children aged 12 years and younger.” In my recent study of CPSC recall data posted on its website, I have found exactly ONE DEATH and THREE ASSERTED INJURIES from lead or lead-in-paint from 1999-2010. Please keep this statistic in mind as I review the economics of your “injury reduction” effort.

The flaws in the RFA analysis are clear in its discussion of testing costs for toys. The analysis acknowledges that it only accounts for out-of-pocket testing costs, nothing else. Significant additional (and ignored) costs include samples destroyed or damaged in testing, transportation of samples, administrative costs for managing testing, administration costs for managing the testing data, administrative costs for managing recordkeeping, an allocation of general management time, legal expenses relating to testing and so on. Depending on the scale of the business, I estimate that these costs (and distractions) will add 15%-50% to the out-of-pocket testing costs.

The RFA analysis concludes that testing a typical toy will cost $1,262 per product. As an average, this might be a good number for our business. I would note, however, that the Proposed Rule posits that we will test multiple samples, sending in perhaps four separate samples per item to satisfy the bizarre “required high degree of assurance” standard. [The rule states clearly that testing one sample is never enough. Interestingly, we have never had the experience in the last 20 years that multiple safety tests of the same product reveals anything useful other than rapidly approaching poverty.] The rule’s four-sample regime takes the testing cost per toy up to $4,848 (by the calculation in the document) plus another $2,500 for mechanical tests (because the rule posits that we will submit FIFTY samples for mechanical tests). That brings us up to $7,348 per item, plus 54 destroyed samples. This implies a rough “all-in” cost of $10,000 per item. We have 1,500 catalog items in our product line. Without a “reasonable testing program” in place (see below), we will have to test each item annually. This is a cost of $15 million for our company EVERY YEAR. [We also sell custom items, a business that would presumably be terminated by this testing rule. That’s several jobs down the drain.]

Does it surprise you to know that $15 million in testing costs exceeds our annual profit? By far?

The RFA analysis is deeply flawed in other ways, too. The rule duly reports that “[a]ccording to a representative of a trade association, there are an estimated 50,000 to 60,000 individual toys on the market.” Oh, really? Perhaps the CPSC shouldn’t have consulted the International Hubcap Manufacturers Association for this information. A quick visit to the Amazon.com website reveals listings of 808,465 toys and games on August 3rd (http://amzn.to/djtTVX). Amazon is a customer of ours – I estimate that they list about one-third of all toys and games sold in the consumer market. Call it 2.5 million toys and games available to consumers in the U.S. But that’s not all – the category also includes specialty items not present on consumer sites. For instance, our industry, the education industry, is largely invisible on consumer sites. I estimate that about one million SKUs are available to purchase at the annual convention of the International Reading Association. Millions of other SKUs are displayed at the national math show, the national science show and the national early childhood show. Add in special needs and other sub-markets – and you get well in excess of 4-5 million toys and games. So the RFA analysis might be off by 100x in its assessment of the toy market ALONE. That’s not close. . . .

The RFA analysis goes on to conclude that the ENTIRE MARKET of products affected by the rule is 100,000–150,000 products. This includes “wearing apparel, accessories, jewelry, juvenile products, children’s furniture, etc.”, plus non-children’s products and other children’s products like ATVs, bikes, bunk beds and so on. It is hard to dignify this ridiculous data with a retort, except to note that it is absurd on its face. The apparel industry ALONE offers as many as 8,000,000 different children’s SKUs for sale. The RFA analysis is fatally flawed.

At $10,000 per SKU, the projected children’s product testing costs will easily exceed $50 billion per year. Remember the 11-year CPSC statistic on lead deaths and injuries – one death and three ASSERTED injuries? [There are no recorded injuries from phthalates or cadmium, by the way.] The 11-year compliance cost will exceed $550 billion (in 2010 dollars), expended by U.S. companies to “reduce” this risk of injury. It would cost a lot less to wrap every American child in bubble wrap.

Small Businesses CANNOT SURVIVE THIS RULE.

Assuming we are supposed to take this rule seriously, the Proposed Rule is perhaps the best friend of the mass market yet invented by an agency seemingly bent on the destruction of the small business community. This letter documents again and again the unrealistic expectations and assumptions made by the authors of this rule with respect to businesses in general and small businesses in particular. Thousands of small businesses of every stripe and color will be affected by this rule. Are you seriously thinking that they will all hire statisticians, chemists and engineers to prepare the reams of data, plans and reports the CPSC expects? Once this massive, herculean effort is completed, who will be safer anyhow? I can think of someone – mass market companies who have been handed a game-ending cost advantage on a silver platter by the CPSC. This, combined with mass market companies’ ability to create certified firewalled in-house labs, favors the big guy dramatically. No wonder the rule states again and again how prejudicial this rule is to small business. The CPSC knows what it’s doing.

Small businesses will strain to even understand what is expected of them. The rule is obtuse, long-winded and full of arcania. Small business people may not have the time or skills to master this complex rule. When the CPSC turns to its attention to enforcement (as promised for 2011) and selects a few small businesses to whip into shape, the market will take note of the pain and a mass exit will result. I realize, however, that Cassandra-like predictions haven’t influenced the CPSC in recent times. One of the Commissioners has even been quoted as saying that “anecdotes aren’t evidence”. It feels like we have to die to prove we were right. A few small businesses might just do that, if the agency waits long enough.

The Commission has asked for feedback on how to address these issues. The complexity of the CPSIA safety rules proves that they are unworkable. To repair this damage, the Commission must ask Congress to restore its ability to assess risk. I am assuming that the Commission would exercise this discretion with more common sense than is embodied in this rule. CPSC rules should be trimmed back to things that MATTER, only. Second, the agency should build its rules and its enforcement activity around DATA. Injury statistics tell the agency what is important. If a particular hazard generates ONE DEATH AND THREE ASSERTED INJURIES OVER 11 YEARS, you can safely relax your rules quite a bit (there are worse problems out there). Education might make a difference, however.

Finally, the Commission should NOT take ANY step if there is EVEN A SHRED OF DOUBT about the impact on small business. Small business is the major jobs creator in America. When you promulgate rules that choke the life out of small business or sharply reduce their incentive to invest, you are killing our economy. You have a heavy responsibility to keep this place running, even if it’s an imperfect world. While it’s sad that a child ever dies, the pain and suffering imposed on countless families from lost jobs, lost capital, lost access to needed products, and so on likely far exceeds it.

Reasonable Testing Program – Busy Work to Keep Us From Running Our Businesses.

The “Reasonable Testing Program” (“RTP”) represents a choice presented to manufacturers of children’s products under this rule. If we endure the expense and disruption of a RTP, we can cut our testing frequency (read, testing costs) in half. A very tempting prospect but the cost of a RTP seems too high, leaving us with a Hobson’s Choice. We can’t afford annual testing and we cannot afford a RTP. What should we do? What will anyone do?

Owing to the burden and complexity of RTPs, I predict EVERY REGULATED COMPANY will violate these rules. Since Ms. Tenenbaum has promised to turn to enforcement in 2011, the CPSC regulators should have a pretty easy time finding juicy targets. Every company will provide wonderful enforcement opportunities.

Although our testing program has been highly-effective over the last 26 years, our program would never meet these standards. We do not maintain the volume of paperwork that the new CPSC rule now requires. We know what we’re doing, but we have not organized our files into a how-to manual. Perhaps the agency thinks every company in the country is an ISO 9001 company. They’re not, and this kind of documentation is rare and breathtakingly expensive to prepare.

Having endured the CPSIA spectacle for two years now, I do not trust the seemingly flexible definition of necessary documentation. The pattern is that these seemingly open-ended terms (which may or may not describe our current recordkeeping) will mature into something rigid down the line. Even if they don’t, we still face the risk that we will not measure up to the expectations of the CPSC enforcement officer at the time of reckoning. The feeling that we are being set up is inescapable. As noted above, given our record of performance, the agency should have NO concerns about how we go about our business. Nonetheless, I feel certain that these rules will bite me in the future.

Sample selection under the rule should not be based on any statistical formula (per the baffling presentation of Dr. Michael Greene at the December 2009 workshop). If the overall safety results of the company are strong, the choice of samples by the company or factories should be presumed compliant without further inquiry. Random selection (taking one off the shelf . . . without the assistance of a statistician) works just fine in our experience, and there is no evidence that testing multiple samples will accomplish anything but will certainly raise costs. Better sampling won’t lower injury rates that already approach zero.

We currently do not use production testing and have zero production testing plans in place. With one recall in 26 years, I would assert this kind of testing is superfluous in our business and basically useless from a safety standpoint. It will significantly raise costs, however. The tedious exercise of preparing a pallet load of production testing plans to meet the new requirements is just plain busy work. One must ask what the CPSC was thinking when it penned this description of a production testing plan: “A production testing plan may include recurring testing or the use of process management techniques such as control charts, statistical process control programs, or failure modes and effects analysis (FMEAs) designed to control potential variations in product manufacturing that could affect the product’s ability to comply with the applicable rules, bans, standards or regulations.” Fancy words but . . . what planet are they from?

The requirement to list all the tests applicable to our items, again and again, to satisfy the RTP requirements is typical of mindless busy work asked of us. Does the CPSC think this will make ANY difference? Most businesses confirm safety tests with their testing lab partners anyhow. More bureaucracy, taken to new heights.

We don’t have any remedial plans in place either. We are quite familiar with how to appropriately resolve compliance and quality issues, and have never had a problem with regulators in the exercise of our business judgment. The requirement to prepare a detailed written plan, just in case we have another recall in the next 26 years, is pure officiousness. This is yet another waste of our time, our money, our resources and our intellect.

The recordkeeping requirements of a RTP is well beyond our ability or interest to preserve for 1500 products produced in thousands of lots over the course of a year. Taking a “Dear Diary” approach to how we source, test, move, remediate, repair, investigate and otherwise manage children’s products is completely unreasonable. This is especially ridiculous given our track record.

The Commission has asked what a RTP might cost us. I have a hard time estimating it because all the fun in our business would be gone. If we had to endure the bureaucratic nightmare this rule envisions, if anyone actually expects us to do all this to make simple plastic toys for schools, I would have to seriously consider our alternatives. So it might cost us our entire company. That’s the whole enchilada, guys.

Remember, we don’t have to make children’s products, nor do we have to stick around for the next act of this tragedy. If the CPSC persists in ruining what was once a rather safe industry with a strong track record, the cost will be the entire market for children’s products.

Is that a high enough price to give you pause? I know, I know, more anecdotes . . . .

The Requirement to Document Procedures against Undue Influence is Unreasonable.

The “Undue Influence Procedures” requirement (“UIP”) is essentially a requirement to document efforts to avoid fraud. If you’re not inclined to commit fraud, there’s little reason to set out your plan to not commit fraud. Here’s our current policy – “Don’t break the law or commit fraud”. This has worked well for us, as we have never exerted undue influence in the last 26 years and have no plans to start now.

I am really sorry that there are bad people in the world, some small number of which may have at one time attempted to exert undue influence over one or more test labs. Perhaps the CPSC should concern themselves with the bad guys and leave the rest of us alone.

Material Change Rules Place Too Much Risk on Manufacturers.

The CPSC’s rule on when to test after a “material change” is sufficiently open-ended to render the judgment on when to test fairly obvious – ALWAYS TEST. Deep within the Proposed Rule, Section 1107.10(b)(2)(ii) instructs “A material change is any change in the product’s design, manufacturing process, or sourcing of component parts that a manufacturer exercising due care knows, or should know, could affect the product’s ability to comply with the rules . . . .” “Due care” is defined as “the degree of care that a prudent and competent person engaged in the same line of business or endeavor would exercise under similar circumstances.”

In other words, the agency’s 20-20 hindsight can construct a case for testing for a material change for just about anything that “might” or “could” affect results or that a hypothetical “prudent person” might think of investigating. Of course, this issue only comes up in the context of an injury or a recall, so what are the odds that any judgment to NOT test would withstand inquiry by an angry CPSC? Zilch. So either you always test or you take a big risk. This is completely unfair and unreasonable.

Testing Frequency Must Be Left to the Manufacturer and to the Market.

A rule requiring manufacturers to test according to these standards every year is going to kill us and many other businesses. No one can afford the testing scheme outlined above, we least of all. If we must test according to these standards, we will be out of business quickly. It is equally unrealistic to imagine that testing cost savings from maintaining a RTP will hold much appeal since that project is so wasteful and gargantuan. Of course, a firewalled in-house lab would be nice for all of us small businesses, but that’s unrealistic, too (not to mention undesirable). We have no realistic way to moderate these costs. Please see my other August 3 comment letter for an explanation of why I believe component and composite testing will likewise provide no relief.

Testing is supposed to assure product quality and compliance. If we have a good, long term record of safety, why can’t we just carry on as we have, and deal with issues as they arise? That worked for 26 years. The new way is just unaffordable.

The “High Degree of Assurance” Standard is Unreasonable and Not Derived from the CPSIA.

The rule seems to conclude that a “high degree of assurance” is a necessary element of any “reasonable testing program”. The importance of the “reasonable testing program” which was incorporated into the CPSIA as an alternative to third party testing for non-children’s products, has been imputed to the children’s product area as a way to reduce testing frequency, and with it, the “high degree of assurance” standard (“HDA”) was likewise imputed. Thus, sliding down this slippery slope, the HDA standard has become part and parcel of the “15 Month Rule”. Abracadabra.

The Commission has requested feedback on the meaning of the definition of HDA in Section 1107.2. Happily, the agency has rejected a strict statistical interpretation requiring “95% probability” of compliance. What should the definition be interpreted to mean? The “high degree of assurance” should be based on an overall assessment of the safety record of the company. It should NOT be based on the results of an individual product, even if recalled or deemed dangerous. In our case, we have done business for 26 years, had one recall of 130 pieces of out of about 1,000,000,000 pieces sold. All of these units were recovered. Thus, we believe there is zero probability that a recalled product is in the market. Our historical recall rate is approximately 130/1,000,000,000 or 0.00001% over a 26-year period.

With this record over so many years, our company should be deemed to have satisfied this HDA requirement and be endorsed as having a reasonable testing program without further inquiry. And if we DON’T deserve the HDA designation, then the CPSC should articulate what level of safety achievement would earn the designation.

Notably, the entire children’s product industry also meets this requirement. Of the 899 recalls of children’s products from 1999-2010, only one death and three asserted injuries from lead were recorded by the CPSC. Thus, the probability of being injured from lead by a children’s product is nearly zero, given that literally billions of children’s products are sold every year. [The apparel and footwear industry claims annual sales of about 4 billion units ALONE.] Industry recall rates are likewise well under 1% per annum. With injury statistics and recall rates in hand, the CPSC should GREATLY loosen the strictures of the “high degree of assurance” standard to focus its resources on activities that might actually injure someone.

One-to-One Product Testing Will Punish the Smallest Companies.

The prophylactic approach to testing adopted by the CPSC will inevitably put many small or micro businesses into bankruptcy, or drive them into unregulated markets to avoid the CPSIA’s wasteful bureaucratic costs. If the law does not permit the agency to adopt sensible rules that allow businesses to manage their compliance risk as best they can (where the standards remain in place, but the government stops trying to tell businesses HOW to comply), then the Commission must finally tell Mr. Waxman what he doesn’t want to hear – that his law is broken and can’t be fixed. [Notably, these mini businesses most at risk have an exemplary record of safety and very low recall rates. NOTHING is gained by rules that crush the little guy.]

We in the small business community have suffered for two solid years while regulators have sought any possible way to avoid delivering this “unpleasant” message. I get the impression that the demise of our businesses would not be too great a cost for the agency to incur to avoid telling Congress what it doesn’t want to hear. If the Commission is genuinely interested in a fix, it must take action with Congress. I do not believe the agency can devise sensible regulations to fix this problem short of a legislative change.

Ban on Retesting Will Unnecessarily Create Crises at Small Businesses.

In our experience, test labs are neither infallible nor definitive in their understanding of U.S. safety laws and regulations. It is not unusual to experience failed test reports for reasons besides safety problems. In addition, children’s products are not so pure and perfect in their composition that every test produces the same result. The CPSC itself instructed manufacturers to audit their test labs in the ironically-dated April 1, 2010 version of the Proposed Rule in response to industry complaints that test results varied from test lab to test lab. By forbidding retesting, the Proposed Rule removes discretion and appropriate problem resolution techniques from a commonplace quality event. You don’t need to manage a very large portfolio of products before the probability of an ordinary course testing problem rises exponentially. This is a matter of mathematics. If retesting is banned, the CPSC is legislating a crisis of the week.

Again, CPSC injury data informs us that the nature of the problem is extremely modest. Historical injury rates are VERY low. This retesting rule is completely unnecessary and penal to all companies except perhaps mass market companies with greater resources. Small businesses won’t have teams of engineers or statisticians around to save the day. Many small businesses will naively call the CPSC for “help”, only to find out that they have created a worse crisis. Some small businesses may miss this point in the Proposed Rule and continue to retest, only to be punished later when the CPSC finds evidence of retesting at the time of a recall. Is this really how you want to regulate?

I would note that the justification for all this is bad acts: “[Retesting] may tempt unscrupulous parties to attempt to ‘test the product into compliance’. . . .” To my knowledge, this behavior has little precedence and even so, it is an abuse that can be dealt with other ways. If honorable and law-abiding companies use retesting to resolve honest problems, no harm is being done. Punishing good guys because you are afraid that otherwise bad guys might benefit is excessive and inappropriately harsh.

The 10,000 Piece Limit for One-Time Testing is Arbitrary and Unfair.

The CPSC has failed to persuade that the 10,000 limit is an appropriate break point for testing. First of all, the limit is cumulative, not related to sales in a period or per annum. Second, the threshold bears no relationship to risk of injury. In other words, it’s completely arbitrary. Why 10,000? Why not? In my view, that’s not enough to justify this rule. Many of the micro businesses that might benefit from this rule have NEVER had a recall. These are the people this rule will restrict. And the logic of this is . . . what, exactly?

Even more remarkable is the rule’s insistence that these low volume items be tested annually after passing the 10,000 piece threshold. Small companies will never have a RTP so annual testing (or more frequently, if for instance the item is hand-assembled) will be mandated. Consider a product selling 2,000 piece per year. Under these rules, the incentive to drop it once it crosses the 10,000 threshold will be powerful. This reminds me of the incentive on small businesses to not hire a 26th employee to avoid an onslaught of Obamacare obligations. A tacit cap on sales will be imposed by this rule. Nice!

The solution to this problem is to require one-time testing before sale, and thereafter according to the business judgment of the manufacturer. Remember, the retailers that buy from the manufacturer will also have something to say about testing frequency, too. Not all solutions are better if imposed by the government.

Alternative Testing Technologies.

The ability to test at low cost with XRF is attractive. For our business, it is tempting to use an XRF gun but for two reasons: (a) cost, and (b) health risk. XRF guns cost $30,000 each and have high annual maintenance costs (several thousand dollars a year). We might need several guns to manage our inventory volumes, a very costly prospect. XRF guns are portable x-ray machines. Notwithstanding the assurance of XRF gun manufacturers, I am quite reluctant to place an x-ray machine in the hands of a warehouse worker in our facility. This is an invitation to disaster. We likewise have no interest in hiring a highly-paid technician to wield the gun, or technicians to wield the guns. In any event, we cannot expose our employees to a possible risk of x-ray genetic damage. I am surprised that the CPSC doesn’t take this risk more seriously. Is lead a worse problem than x-rays?

In any event, I fail to understand what would be accomplished by a XRF solution for small businesses. The process of XRF testing may be inexpensive, but would be disruptive. In any event, I don’t see a connection to safety so I prefer a solution that restores sanity to our safety practices. Burning in a wasteful and disruptive process will only bog down our economy and our competitiveness. Until the CPSC can point to a risk factor relating to the little guys, one cannot rationally conclude that XRF makes this regulation better, just somewhat less worse.

In sum, the Proposed Rule is a dangerous rule with the acknowledged prospect of doing severe market damage. The CPSC knows this, having admitted it in writing in the text of the rule. There is no excuse to push forward with a defective rule on this scale. The Commission must talk honestly with Congress . . . before it’s too late.

Thank you for considering my views on this important subject.

Sincerely,

Richard Woldenberg
Chairman
Learning Resources, Inc.
380 North Fairway Drive
Vernon Hills, IL 60061

Wednesday, July 21, 2010

GUEST BLOG – American Apparel and Footwear Association (AAFA) Urges You To Participate in Survey on Impact of CPSIA-Mandated Testing


The American Apparel and Footwear Association (AAFA) Wants You!

Many have pointed out to the CPSC that the additional testing costs mandated by the CPSIA have been extremely burdensome on companies and have even caused many to either shut down or abandon the children’s product market.

This blog has provided concrete examples with its Casualties of the Week (for example see here, here and here).

Some are still not convinced. CPSC Commissioner Adler made the point at a recent CPSC briefing that "anecdotes are not evidence."

The AAFA has been collecting information ("evidence") from companies to see exactly how the testing rules have impacted their businesses. This information is important to help document to CPSC and Congress the economic impact of CPSIA.

To continue gathering data, AAFA recently published two surveys online to gauge the impact of consumer product testing. One survey is for manufacturers, wholesalers and suppliers and the other is for retailers and licensors.

If you are (or were) in the children's product business, we strongly urge you to fill out this survey online. It only takes a few minutes.

The surveys are especially geared towards assessing the impact on businesses, and business awareness of, two proposed rulemakings that are due August 3, "Conditions and Requirements for Testing Component Parts of Consumer Products" and "Testing and Labeling Pertaining to Product Certification," as well as how the stay of testing and certification requirements impact companies’ testing protocols and costs.

To access the survey for manufacturers, wholesalers and suppliers please visit http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/D6S3D7N

To access the survey for retailers and licensors please visit http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/D668GJT

Thank you for your participation.

Guest Blog Posted by the AAFA

Thursday, June 3, 2010

CPSIA - Fear of Zippers

I have been tossing and turning about zippers ever since the April 29 House hearing. Perhaps you recall Steve Levy's demonstration of why thousands of pairs of pants and jeans were thrown away under the CPSIA to make you so much safer. As you know, you can't place a price tag on safety. Burn, baby, burn.

In response to questions by Ranking Member Whitfield, Steve Levy discussed lead in zippers at about the 47 minute mark in the testimony video. He noted that zippers are made of five to seven components, one of which has been found to have trace lead amounts in excess of current limits. The component in question is not accessible (it's sewn into the crotch of the pant) but since the CPSC can reach the component with a probe, it is considered violative. Fabric is not considered a "barrier" to access under CPSC rules. Bummer, that's thousands of pairs of pants into the garbage.

Self-appointed "Safety Czarina" Rachel Weintraub was quick to object to the horrors of Mr. Levy's jeans: "The problem is, unfortunately, that children mouth zippers all the time. You know I have three young children. My oldest child who is almost six, he mouths zippers as well. . . . The problem is that children interact with clothing in dynamic ways." This Rachel-speak is the version of "common sense" that imbues the CPSIA. Perhaps you recognized the valuable insights.

Whoa! Children are so "dynamic" with their clothes, this little zipper could be zapping IQ points every day. Wow. I am quite a worrier as you know, so I have been fretting about zippers almost non-stop for a month. After all, we clothed our children in pants with zippers since they were born (many years ago). I can't detect any missing IQ points in my kids, but of course, I am not nearly as smart as Rachel Weintraub or the other safety zealots perhaps as a result of my wearing jeans to this very day. Still, I could not ignore Rachel's serious warning but needed to better understand the danger.

So we asked a four-year-old volunteer to suck on his jeans zipper. Here's what happened. Don't worry, no IQ points were killed or harmed in the making of this video.

WARNING: The following video contains dramatic footage of a four-year-old attempting to suck on his jeans zipper. Such graphic footage may not be appropriate for everyone. Please think carefully about watching the video if you are a member of a consumer group.


Friday, October 16, 2009

CPSIA - Recall Insurance Update

One of my eagle-eyed friends noticed an article (or ad masquerading as an article) offering a new recall insurance product in Earnshaws in its most recent issue on page 36. The subject of recall insurance has been on everyone's mind since passage of the CPSIA. The new law considerably increases the risk and expense exposure from recalls in a multiplicity of industries. Earnshaws caters to the apparel industry, but the issues are the same elsewhere in the children's products marketplace. The insurance broker here is HUB International. For those of you in the toy business, you may be familiar with them from messages sent under the auspices of the TIA. HUB International is endorsed insurance broker to the TIA.

The Earnshaws "article" touches on some important points:
  • ". . . with thousands - or in some cases millions - of units with an untold number of components and coatings, it's not unreasonable to imagine that even the most careful company could inadvertently end up shipping goods that don't comply [with the CPSIA]. The consequences of such an error would be costly and possibly catastrophic."
  • "HUB has developed the Children's Apparel Recall Expense (C.A.R.E.) program to cover well-meaning wholesales, importers and distributors of children's apparel and footwear. . . ."
  • One happy customer noted: "We do not want to accept the risks of the threats we cannot control . . . ." [Emphasis added]

I particularly appreciate the tone of doom and regulatory randomness in this "article". Of course we should all mortgage our houses to buy this insurance. As HUB notes, the consequences of an "inadvertent" error is "possibly catastrophic". This point is not lost on their customer either, who notes that the risk cannot be controlled. Even "well-meaning" companies will be subject to this capricious fate. At least they can get insurance . . . . Ouch.

Hmmm, I wonder why the HUB customer thinks that CPSIA risks cannot be controlled. Could it be that Target was whacked with a $600,000 penalty for using reasonable QC procedures and meeting its standard of care, but nonetheless somehow failing to find a lead-in-paint violation in time. [Of course, they had passing test reports and turned themselves in as soon as they found the problem, but they're very nice in Minnesota. Nice, but $600K lighter now.] Could it be that Mattel paid for a massive recall, settled with California, settled with Arizona and 38 other states, paid a $2.3 million fine to the CPSC . . . AND still had to process and pay an extortionate class action settlement with plaintiffs attorneys to the tune of tens of millions of dollars - all for a violation that resulted in NO deaths and NO injuries? Nah, must be something else. . . .

So the ways to waste money on the awful CPSIA expands now to include Recall Insurance. Yet another reason for businesses to hang it up. And then, consumer advocates rejoice!, there will be fewer and fewer children's product recalls to worry about - because there will be fewer and fewer children's products available for purchase. What-a-country!

Thursday, September 17, 2009

CPSIA - What on EARTH is She Talking About?

In a statement approving of a penalty imposed on a company for a drawstring choking hazard violation, Commissioner Nancy Nord made some mysterious remarks. Dense as I am, I just don't get it. If you understand these remarks, I hope you can explain them to me sometime.

a. "On a broader level, I commend companies already following the drawstring voluntary standard. However, I am deeply concerned by the industry's need to increase its efforts to educate its member companies about the problem with drawstrings on children's upper outwear, as well as the Agency's need to increase its efforts to publicize the hazards of these circumstances. Industry and the Agency must make a more aggressive effort, together, to get this warning information out to manufacturers, especially smaller ones who may be less likely to be aware of the seriousness of this problem. In addition, efforts need to be increased to have parents be better informed and be more vigilant in making sure their young children do not wear clothing with drawstrings in their upperwear."

Huh? A need for EDUCATION OF MANUFACTURERS, ESPECIALLY SMALL ONES? What?! The CPSC and industry working COOPERATIVELY to REACH OUT to both makers AND TO PARENTS? Heresy! Besides, doesn't Commissioner Nord know that all problems are best solved by governments, and that individual responsibility, not to mention the obligation to supervise children, is an outmoded concept? Please!

b. [This quote is even CRAZIER.] "In situations like this, I am sadly reminded how agency and industry efforts and limited resources have had to be focused on issues that do not present real safety concerns, like bike valves, library books and rhinestones, instead of on real dangers like drawstrings on children's apparel. The Agency, the industry, and the public at large need to remain focused on the seriousness of drawstrings in children's outerwear until every avoidable injury is just that - avoided." [Emphasis added.]

I don't get it. What's she talking about? You would think she's never been the Chairman of the CPSC or something. First of all, why does she regret the expenditure of millions of dollars and thousands of man-hours dickering about dangerous items like rhinestones? Kids lick their bike chains and chow down on rhinestones every day, after all - oooh, that's so unsafe! And what's this about "limited resources"? Can't Obama just print up some more dough? It's raining dollars, let's hire lots of investigators . . . . I am also mystified by the notion that it is possible to figure out that some dangers are "real" and some are not. Didn't Congress do all the thinking for us already? Ms. Nord, get with the times!

I certainly hope this kind of thinking doesn't catch on. What would I do for amusement?

Saturday, August 15, 2009

CPSIA - AAFA Op-Ed in Roll Call on Anniversary of CPSIA

Paper Is the Right Choice for Clothes and Shoes: Marking One Year of the CPSIA

Aug. 14, 2009, 9:52 a.m.
By Kevin Burke
Special to Roll Call

On Friday, we are marking the one-year anniversary of the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, landmark legislation that provided needed resources to the Consumer Product Safety Commission to improve consumer product safety. We are also commemorating the second of three phase-in dates for reductions in lead standards for children’s products.

As tradition holds, the first anniversary gift is paper. For our anniversary gift, Congress should consider giving the producers of children’s clothing and shoes a thoughtful piece of paper: legislation allowing the U.S. apparel and footwear industry the opportunity to continue making safe clothing and shoes.

The CPSIA was an effort to adapt consumer product safety to the changing manufacturing landscape. While well-intentioned, the CPSIA has unduly burdened businesses by shifting focus away from risk toward legal compliance. As a result, companies that manufacture and sell safe products have been forced to shut down.

The legislation went far beyond its intended purpose of keeping unsafe and dangerous toys off store shelves by creating a “guilty until proven innocent” compliance environment — even for products that have always been safe. As a result, manufacturers of children’s products are spending tremendous resources in duplicative testing of their products simply to comply with the legislation. These extra costs are doing little to improve public health or provide safety, and they are adding enormous pressures to companies already scrambling for ways to cope with the economic downturn.

The U.S. apparel and footwear industry has been a victim in this unfortunate debate that pits compliance against safety. We believe we have a strong safety record. While any recall is one too many, the amount of recalls in our industry in 2008 equaled less than 0.0082 percent of total merchandise sold. To give you an idea of that figure: If a football player were to stand at one end of a football field and run 0.0082 percent of the way to the other goal line, he would travel only a small fraction of an inch.

For us, product safety is engineered into clothing and shoes from the start. That is why we need strong and clear product safety rules that can be communicated and understood up and down the supply chain. However, the CPSIA’s rigid parameters have eliminated key “flexibility” and “risk assessment” tools that are needed for the product safety system to work efficiently. And with some rules implemented retroactively or being announced only a few days before they take effect, the system falls apart.

We will always work with the CPSC and consumer interest groups to determine what, if any, product safety problems exist in the industry and how to best rectify them. Congress should encourage this cooperative environment because it alleviates many of the current burdens the CPSIA imposes on industry — burdens that do not improve consumer safety. This transparent process creates a risk-based, common-sense product safety regulatory network that is agreeable to all stakeholders.

The current regulatory framework has made even the most low-hanging fruit nearly unreachable. When the legislation first passed, our industry began the process of seeking out a rule exempting fabric and textiles from the lead standard because the materials are inherently lead-free. Due to strict statutory language, the tedious process involved hearings, comments, thousands of test reports and several meetings. The final rule came out on Aug. 7, almost one year since the law was enacted. In the meantime, the industry has spent millions of dollars to demonstrate what it already knows — your plain white cotton T-shirt does not have lead in it.

Other exemption requests posed by our industry and others have not been so successful. Crystals and rhinestones on children’s clothing, shoes, princess costumes, dance uniforms, cell phones, jewelry, accessories and eyeglasses are now banned hazardous substances despite a CPSC staff determination that this “bling” does not pose a health risk to children. Furthermore, data shows crystals and rhinestones would leach less lead than some jewelry that is compliant with the strictest CPSIA lead standard that goes in effect two years from now. However, as new CPSC Chairwoman Inez Tenenbaum stated, “A decision to grant the exclusion by using compliant metal jewelry as the baseline for assessing the acceptable level of exposure will reintroduce risk analysis back into consideration. ... Such an interpretation of the exclusion section of the CPSIA appears to be in direct conflict with the statutory language, which does not allow for the consideration of risk.”

Last week, the Senate moved quickly in confirming the two remaining nominees to complete the slate of commissioners at the CPSC. For too long our nation’s product safety regulatory system had been underserved because of long-standing vacancies in vital leadership positions. Fortunately, the recent batch of confirmation hearings has renewed the discussion aimed at restoring common sense to our product safety rules and regulations. Through the appropriations process, chronic underfunding issues are swiftly being resolved as well.

Now that we have five commissioners providing leadership at the CPSC, the commissioners should begin following through on commitments made during confirmation hearings to quickly issue comprehensive and unmistakable guidance to fashion designers, manufacturers and retailers to resolve the immense confusion that has held our industry back.

Congress has an important role to play as well. Hearings are urgently needed to provide all stakeholders an opportunity to document the early successes and failures of the CPSIA. More importantly, with the one-year anniversary behind them, key Members of Congress should take a hard look at the legislation to see what fixes can be made — technical or otherwise — that will make this law work better and as intended. In answer to Chairwoman Tenenbaum’s appeal last week, one urgently needed legislative clarification would provide the CPSC with needed tools to grant common-sense exemptions based on risk.

The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act was a historic piece of legislation that should have been lauded but instead has become known as the law of unintended consequences. For our one-year anniversary, Congress should give American consumers and businesses a piece of paper that makes it easier to buy and sell safe and compliant clothes and shoes.

Kevin Burke is president and CEO of the American Apparel & Footwear Association.

CPSIA - AP Story Features April Rally Committee Members

New lead limits big concern for small businesses

By JENNIFER C. KERR

The Associated Press
9:31 p.m. Thursday, August 13, 2009

WASHINGTON — Tighter limits on the amount of lead the government allows in children's products and a requirement for new tracking labels are stirring fear among small business owners, already hurting in a tough economy.

Starting Friday, the new limits and labels are required as part of a consumer product safety law passed by Congress last summer in the wake of dozens of recalls of lead-tainted toys.

Consumer advocates hailed the measures. But some small businesses, like American Educational Products in Fort Collins, Colo. — it sells classroom teaching aids like flash cards, animal models, globes and relief maps — say the testing and labeling costs are crippling to their operations even though their products are safe. They want the law amended to exempt products that present little or no risk to young children.

"The challenge as a small business is that I cannot do it all (the testing) immediately," said Michael Warring, president of AMEP. "I would have to spend a full year of revenue to test every product I sell."

Warring recently laid off four of his 70 employees. In his 15 years with AMEP, he has not had one safety recall or complaint about lead.

Even so, Warring says he is required to test samplings of all products he makes and sells for young children, which he said costs about $2,000 per product. The tracking labels will add another cost, he says, since they must be a permanent marking on each product.

The new chairman of the Consumer Product Safety Commission, Inez Tenenbaum, has tried to reassure businesses that the agency will work with them as it enforces the new requirements.

"We're going to take into account situations where businesses are making the right efforts to manufacture products safer," said her chief spokesman, Scott Wolfson. "We are going to continue to put out new rules and new guidance to help companies in that effort."

The law, known as CPSIA, sets strict standards for lead and chemicals called phthalates when used in toys and products for children 12 and under. Lead can cause irreversible brain damage,
and some studies have linked phthalates to reproductive problems.

The bill was signed into law one year ago. Since then, CPSC rules have been trickling out — explaining who must comply, and how, as well as announcements about delays in enforcement for certain industries.

But the guidance from the agency has been confusing and belated, says Jolie Fay, a mother who runs a home crafts business — Skipping Hippos — making children's jackets and fleece ponchos out of her basement in Portland, Ore.

"My products are mostly fabric, and they're safe," Fay said. "Mom-home sewers are being pulled into this law to meet the same standards as big companies like Fisher-Price. It's not right."

Fay's orders began drying up in February, when the lead limits first became effective. On Friday, the limits tighten further, with the amount of lead allowed in kids' products decreasing to 300 parts per million and 90 ppm for lead paint.

Fay had all the fabrics and buttons tested on her clothing, and she says there was no lead. Still, she says, boutiques stopped calling in orders, too worried that they might lose inventory if a test later turned up positive for lead.

CPSC has issued guidance that natural fabrics like cotton and silk are exempt from the rules, but zippers, buttons and snaps are not.

Wolfson says the agency is working hard to hear the concerns of small business. But, he added, they have a "responsibility to know their obligations and comply with these new safety requirements starting on Friday."

Thursday, August 6, 2009

CPSIA - Exceptions, Exceptions

The CPSC today docketed their long-awaited decision on CPSIA Section 3 lead standards exceptions for materials known to be "always" compliant. This ornate 94-pager succeeds in making an awful law even more confusing and unworkable. [I have already commented on its shameful impact on library books.] Owing to the decision's length and the bad reputation I enjoy for going on and on, I will try to keep this comment as succinct as possible. Please keep in mind that I am summarizing a 94-page document, however.

Needless to say, the obvious effort here was to narrow the scope of the law to lessen its financial impact on many industries. In that regard, some good was accomplished. There will be some winners, generally makers of simple and untreated goods. Many (not all) "crafters" will be delighted. I hate to break the news . . . but the economy goes a bit further than crafters. What about those of us who make products more complex than an unadorned white cotton t-shirt? There's a word for those people - it's "losers".

The CPSC has the well-known problem of being forbidden to assess risk under the CPSIA. Thus, this queer document simply examines the physical attributes of various materials for compliance with the arbitrary lead standards, all without regard to whether the materials present any known safety risk. This was Congress' fervent desire - that the CPSC not exercise judgment. You can see how items like rhinestones, pens, bikes and Potato Clocks might present particular problems under this construct of law. There is no way to let these items out despite the everyday knowledge that they pose absolutely no risk to consumers from lead content.

The document spends pages and pages in tortured analysis determining which materials can safely and unassailably be construed to be compliant in all known manifestations. If upon reading it, you begin to see a giant wedge of Swiss cheese forming before your eyes, you are not imagining things. Congress' great innovation here was to make everything "illegal" and then carve out exceptions only upon evidentiary consideration after submission of very expensive petitions. If you don't apply for a carve-out, you don't get a carve-out. So holes pockmark the law in seemingly random and unpredictable fashion, all related to whomever ponied up for a (successful) application for exception. The holes cannot be accurately anticipated (they might or might not be there - you must look). Congress' genius legal construct essentially creates a law that resembles organic chemistry - an illogical subject that can only be mastered through pure memorization. I did not like that class. At all. Just as in my dreaded Orgo class, there is a lot to learn to master the CPSIA regulations.

The decision lists many materials that are now excluded from the testing requirement (nothing is excluded from the tracking labels requirement, btw), and many others are explictly NOT excluded. Even if you were able to fit wholly within the safe harbor, the decision is not intended to let you rest easy. It's not really a safe harbor, we are all supposed to remain at risk: "The Commission intends to obtain and test products in the marketplace to assure that products comply with the CPSIA lead limits and will take appropriate enforcement action if it finds a product to have lead levels exceeding those allowed by law . . . . Moreover, even when a particular product or material has been relieved of the testing and certification requirements under section 102 of the CPSIA, manufacturers and importers remain responsible for verifying that the material or product has not been altered or modified, or experienced any change in the processing, facility or supplier conditions that could impart lead into the material or product to ensure that it meets the statutory lead levels at all times." They want you to squirm - even if you are making products entirely from materials explicitly deemed compliant. The law and the CPSC have not identified any behavior or conduct that will cleanse you of liability. The clear message - you make children's products at your own risk. Are we having fun yet?

The details of what's in and what's out are in the linked document. I will highlight a few choice bits without attempting to summarize the complete decision. Please refer to the document for the list of excepted materials.

Glues: I particularly like the exception given to glues. The CPSC doesn't know the composition of most glues (other than "animal glue" - I wonder if that includes "Gorilla" brand specifically) and since risk and safety are utterly irrelevant now, the decision does not give a pass to these materials. However, good news - glues are apparently often "inaccessible" and thus don't need to be tested. Sound good? Now, here's a question - how am I supposed to NOT test the glue that is adhered to the material the CPSC wants tested? And if the glue saturates the material, then what? If the material + glue fails the test but I can prove that the raw material is fine, then what? Who performs this test, a lawyer or a testing lab? Get ready to earn your Ph.D. in testing and safety regulations.

Metals: More good news: the decision exempts "surgical steel". So, if you make toys with surgical steel, like "My First Really Sharp Scalpel Kit" or "Home Brain Surgery for Kids!", you are good to go. Other common metals used in children's products, such as pure gold and silver, titanium (both α-and β-phase - whew!) , platinum, palladium, rhodium, osmium, iridium and ruthenium are also usefully blessed. I know the ATV'rs are thinking of pure platinum models to solve their compliance problems - it's your lucky day, apparently. Even stainless steel is okay (but certainly not 303Pb - you know that one, don't deny it!). Stay away from unusual items like non-steel or non-precious metal components such as solder or base metals in electroplate, clad, or fill applications and aluminum, copper or pewter. Let's not even TALK about brass.

Education: What about rocks, you know the things that were here before Mr. Waxman began to roam the Earth? The CPSC helpfully determined that Congress made them illegal under some circumstances. "As with the precious gemstones and certain semi-precious stones that the Commission determines do not contain lead at levels that exceed the CPSIA lead content limits, other rocks and stones may comply with lead limits provided that they are not based on lead or lead compounds and are not associated in nature with any mineral that is based on lead or lead compounds. In general, we agree that most minerals do not contain lead. However, some minerals are known to contain lead or are associated in nature with minerals than contain lead. We have previously identified minerals that can contain lead, such as aragonite, bayldonite, boleite, cerussite, croroite, linarite, mimetite, phosgenite, vanadinite, and wufenite. We have also identified galena, and will add this mineral to the list of lead containing minerals under section 1500.91(d)(2)." [Italics added.] Clear enough for you? And how does this apply to granite or fossils? You tell me, we do not employ a Ph.D. geologist (yet). This is going to make school supply so EASY! It's "common sense" going full blast.

Apparel: While the decision excises most fabrics and dyes from the need for compliance testing, it also explicitly includes "after-treatment applications, including screen prints, transfers, decals, or other prints." Along with the decision on rhinestones (also noted and affirmed in this document), all accoutrements found on apparel or footwear will be subject to endless testing. The message to apparel makers - if you want to keep life simple, make dull, unadorned clothing, and try to use string as closures (but not TOO much string, Mr. Hoodie). Snaps, zippers and so on expose you to liability risk and cost. "Boring" is the new "exciting" under the CPSIA.

Paper and Ink: Papers have been excluded, even when printed. This is consistent with the decision to exclude books printed on or after 1985. Printing inks used in four-color process are also blessed, however the following inks are NOT excluded: "spot colors, other inks that are not used in the CMYK process, and inks that do not become part of the substrate". Boy, this will be so easy to manage. . . .

The decision continues: "In addition, as discussed in part D.13 of this preamble, we have found that certain after-treatments, including screen printing, may use leaded pigments. Accordingly, inks used in any after-treatments for decals, transfers, and other prints also will be excluded under new § 1500.91(d) (6). Other additional treatments such as . . . laminators or laminations, including plastic sheet or film, or other coatings, would continue to require testing and certification under section 102 of the CPISA if such products are plastic component parts or a paint or similar surface-coating material under 16 CFR part 1303."

Were you feeling good for a minute there? That was unintentional, the CPSC apologizes for any misunderstanding. Hopefully you are now experiencing a good deal of anxiety again.

Fasteners: Staples on books need to be tested IF they are accessible BUT you can get out of it if you use surgical steel for your staples! Bookbinding will be a great new market for medical supply companies. If you use screws as a fastener . . . well, you can guess.

Plastic or Metal Components: Give up the idea that ANYTHING made of plastic or metal will be blessed if not included in the above exceptions: " . . . based on the Commission's past experience with other children's products that have been found to contain lead, the Commission cannot make a determination that any component parts made out of plastic or metal (with the exception of metal determinations made in this rule) falls under the lead content limits." Zippers, grommets, etc. - all are left IN the law. Component testing will be addressed later. I am waiting with baited breath.

While the CPSC tried its best to be sensible, the law does not permit good sense on their part. They are not to be blamed, they didn't write the law and are not permitted to rewrite it. Frustration with the decision is appropriate, but the "bad guy" is clearly Congress and its estimable "leaders". As we get walked down the plank, remember who did it to you. The voting booth beckons . . . .

Monday, July 27, 2009

CPSIA - Steve Levy Op-Ed in Roll Call 7-27-09

The below Op-Ed appeared in today's Roll Call:


CPSC Chairwoman’s Pledge for ‘Common Sense’ Approach to Be Tested

By Steve Levy
Special to Roll Call
July 27, 2009, 12:22 p.m.

At her Senate confirmation hearing last month, new Consumer Product Safety Commission Chairwoman Inez Tenenbaum pledged a “common sense” approach to implementing the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, which has caused so much confusion for consumers and so many problems for businesses. The new law, passed by Congress to improve children’s product safety, has resulted in serious unintended consequences for a number of industries due to its overly broad definition of children’s products, unrealistic implementation timelines, and retroactive bans on the sale of existing inventory.

The first commission vote on a CPSIA-related issue under the new chairwoman took place this week. Unfortunately, it demonstrated just how difficult it can be to apply “common sense” to the implementation of this law, underscoring the need for Congress to address CPSIA’s problems before more unnecessary damage is done to thousands of small businesses throughout the country. In the 2-1 vote, Chairwoman Tenenbaum and the commission denied a petition for excluding crystal and glass beads in children’s jewelry, apparel and other products from the lead law, despite the fact that both CPSC staff and commissioners acknowledge there is no real risk of harmful lead exposure from these products.

Why does product safety law seem to be at odds with common sense? Ever since the new law debuted nearly a year ago, Congress has sought to avoid revisiting the flawed legislation, instead focusing blame on CPSC leadership for its countless implementation problems. Just in April, 28 Senators signed a letter to CPSC Acting Chairwoman Nancy Nord stating, “It is our view that the CPSC is empowered by CPSIA to exercise its authority and enforcement discretion in a manner that ensures enforcement of the act in a comprehensive manner while providing appropriate and common-sense relief to businesses and institutions.” Yet in denying the petition, Chairwoman Tenenbaum focused on the same problem that has hamstrung Republican and Democratic commissioners since the law’s inception: It denies the CPSC the flexibility to consider risk when determining whether or not a product is safe. Tenenbaum’s statement following the vote on crystal and glass beads tells the story: “a decision to grant the exclusion ... will reintroduce risk analysis back into consideration. ... Such an interpretation of the exclusion section of the CPSIA appears to be in direct conflict with the statutory language, which does not allow for the consideration of risk.”

While denied the right to apply risk analysis to the issues, Chairwoman Tenenbaum did state that the CPSC won’t enforce this rule outside of the market for children 6 years of age and under. Unfortunately, her statement does not provide meaningful relief, as the commission’s decision means the crystal and beads violate the law for all children 12 years of age and under, and thus to knowingly import or sell these items is to risk violating the law, something that manufacturers and retailers simply will not risk.

Soon the commission will face another lead-law decision, this time involving a petition to exclude raw, natural or man-made material that is made into finished articles of clothing from the lead laws. This decision should be even more straightforward, as the apparel industry has shown through extensive testing data, expert testimony and overwhelming evidence presented to the CPSC that textiles are inherently lead-free. Yet even though those plain T-shirts and socks in your kids’ drawers don’t have lead in them, the current law compels companies like mine to prove again and again that that is the case. If common sense is followed, we are optimistic that when Chairwoman Tenenbaum and her colleagues consider our request (hopefully soon), the overwhelming evidence we presented to the CPSC seven months ago demonstrating that these materials are inherently lead-free will result in textiles being exempted from this law.

Unfortunately, as Chairwoman Tenenbaum is discovering, Congress created a law that explicitly blocks the government’s own product safety watchdog from practicing common sense risk management in policing product safety.

Businesses need to know what rules and regulations they must follow, especially in an industry like ours that requires long lead times from design of a product to the moment it reaches store shelves. Yet until we have a clearly articulated exemption, companies — particularly small businesses and home crafters who lack the resources to change product plans on a dime — must continue to grapple with the lack of predictability they need to run a business.

What is lost in the debate is that our industries share in the goal of improving product safety and support strong, enforceable safety standards — our entire industry depends on consumers having faith in our products. But arbitrarily denying consumers access to safe products is not the same thing as improving product safety. It’s time for Congress to hold hearings and fix the problems with this flawed law.

Steve Levy is director of operations at Star Ride Kids, a manufacturer of children’s clothing, and president of the Coalition for Safe & Affordable Childrenswear, Inc.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

CPSIA - Thoughts of A Passover Miracle

A friend sent me this and I thought it was funny:

When my ship at N.Y.C. did land,
Let my apparel go!
Lead content at too high a ppm,
Let my apparel go!

Refrain:

Go down, Rick Woldenberg,
Way down to Bethesda Maryland;
Tell old Thomas Moore-oh
To let my children’s products go!

"The crystals on your shirts, they do not comply”,
Let my apparel go!
So they detained my products without blinking an eye
Let my apparel go!

(Refrain)

“There’s no risk to children!” I did decree,
Let my apparel go!
”There’s nothing we can do” said CPSC,
Let my apparel go!

(Refrain)

So to my Congressman I did protest,
Let my apparel go!
And demanded he fix this CPSIA mess!
Let my apparel go!

(Refrain)

He told me to go back to the CPSC,
Let my apparel go!
And see if there’s an exemption that they can grant me,
Let my apparel go!

(Refrain)

With no exemption I’m cooked o woe is me,
Let my apparel go!
From now on I can only manufacture plain white tees,
Let my apparel go!

I will admit to changing one word . . . . Let's hope someone's listening. I am not looking forward to a world without rhinestones.