Last week, the Democrats took action to protect you and your kids from the perils of lead. As we have been relentlessly reminded by non-scientists, there is "no safe level of lead" - just ask Bob Adler and Inez Tenenbaum. Now, in the wake of the conclusion that reducing lead content from 300 ppm (lead-in-substrate) to 100 ppm will produce "minimal" health benefits (read, none), the CPSC Commission voted three Democrats to two Republicans to reduce the lead limit to 100 ppm.
Reducing lead standards from 300 ppm to 100 ppm can be expressed a different way mathematically. This is a reduction from 99.97% lead-free to 99.99% lead-free. [Credit to Anne Northup for the mathematics!] This will cost billions and the economic devastation was ALSO documented by the CPSC Staff in their analysis on the 100 ppm standard. Nevertheless, the non-scientists who rule the roost at the CPSC saw nothing but health upsides in this technologically feasible but economically absurd feat. And, as we know, injuries to children have an infinite value when you are unable to assess risk. The numbers work out - yes, the cost may be in the billions and the reduction in incentives will cost yet more, but the savings are infinite! Even one avoided injury is an infinite savings. Queue the tears . . . . What-a-deal!
Ironically, last week the EPA bowed to political pressure and in an exercise of common sense, eased up on precautions against lead-in-paint in housing stock. Hello? Did you catch that one? Twelve Senators signed a letter in April to protest this proposed rule as excessive and damaging to small business, and bingo, something good finally happened. Olympia Snowe was so delighted that she put out a press release to celebrate it. Please note that the EPA acknowledges that lead-in-paint in housing stock is the principal source of lead poisoning in the United States. [It sure ain't toys.] They have previously acknowledged in writing (lucid writing, actually) that their rules on lead need to be measured and that the economic impact of their rules must also be carefully assessed. The EPA does not attach an infinite value to injuries, even to children. They aren't idiots. Draw your own conclusions.
Hello, Senators, anyone home?
The foundation of the "no safe level of lead" slogan has been laid by the American Academy of Pediatrics, a political organization masquerading as a professional organization. This organization was aggressively and justifiably attacked by Anne Northup during the 100 ppm Commission meeting. It is rare to see anyone attack these people, perhaps besides me (not a fan . . .), but do they ever deserve it. Here is what Dr. Dana Best of the AAP told a House Subcommittee on April 7, 2011:
"Exposure to lead is amply documented to cause the loss of intellectual capacity. On average, children whose blood lead levels (BLLs) rise from 10 to 20 micrograms per deciliter (mcg/dL) lose two to three IQ points. More recent studies have shown an even greater impact on IQ of BLLs under 10 mcg/dL. Key studies reported a loss of 4 to 7 IQ points in children whose lead levels rose from 1 mcg/dL to 10 mcg/dL. These studies suggest that “low” levels of exposure – meaning BLLs less than 10 mcg/dL – cause proportionately greater harm than higher levels. . . . The medical and scientific literature are in substantial agreement that an increase of 1 mcg/dL in blood lead level is capable of causing the loss of approximately one IQ point in children whose blood lead level is under 10 mcg/dL." [Enphasis added]
Dr. Best, well-known for her fear of children licking bicycles, has previously posited "millions" of victims of lead-in-substrate. Despite taking such a dramatic stand, Dr. Best cannot seem to name even ONE victim or lead-in-substrate or provide a single case history demonstrating that such a victim has ever been located . . . anywhere. Not even one. Doesn't matter, apparently. When you're right, you're right.
But is Dr. Best actually RIGHT? Fascinatingly, when Dr. Best plugs the notion that driving lead concentrations below 10 mcg/dl will have some defined (definite) health benefits, she flies in the face of the official AAP Policy Statement on Lead Exposure in Children (recently restated on May 1, 2009). The Policy Statement does NOT support her assertions - and she is on the committee that wrote/approved the statement. You might say she got it wrong, or you might just say she's a liar. Is it really possible to be that incompetent? Here's what the Policy Statement says:
"Canfield et al recently extended the relationship between blood lead concentration and IQ to blood lead concentrations less than 10 g/dL. They observed a decrease in IQ of more than 7 points over the first 10 g/dL of lifetime average blood lead concentration. . . . To confirm the adverse effects of lead on IQ at these concentrations, however, more children whose blood lead concentration has never been more than 10 mcg/dL should be studied. A reanalysis of the primary data from several of the prospective studies is underway to help resolve this issue. At the moment, however, these data have not yet been incorporated into policy, and the CDC16 and AAP24 both currently use 10 mcg/dL (Table 2) as the blood lead concentration of concern." [Emphasis added]
The Canfield study is the study Dr. Best cites in her Congressional testimony above. Canfield predates the restated Policy Statement (obviously, or else it wouldn't be cited), and thus forms part of the basis of the recommendation for further study. The AAP recommends further study to confirm its suspicions - and those studies aren't done. Dr. Best certainly didn't cite them. The AAP Policy Statement goes on to recommend:
"RECOMMENDATIONS FOR GOVERNMENT: Fund studies to confirm or refute the finding that blood lead concentrations of less than 10 mcg/dL are associated with lower IQ. The next important step in lead research is conducting of studies in which confounding by socioeconomic factors is not so strong. Funding of studies in this area needs to be given high priority, as was done in the early 1980s when the question of effects of blood lead concentrations less than 20 mcg/dL was raised." [Emphasis added]
So the AAP acknowledges in its policy statement that the case is not exactly open-and-shut. Dr. Best, a member of the AAP's Committee on Environmental Health, continues to bash away on the hustings with her hyperbolic and conclusory message. Perhaps she feels that no one will likely check her work or contest her blather, so why not?
Senators? Congressmen? Does anyone care about the effects on business when it comes to the out-of-control CPSC?
There are now 25 days until the 100 ppm standard goes into effect retroactively. Starting packing up, guys. Will Congress act? I have no idea - this is not, and never has been, a question of doing the right thing for you or me or for anyone, really. The Dems have an agenda, a political agenda, and your problems are beneath their consideration. I can't say who will be the winners, but the losers are well-known by now.
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
CPSIA - You're Only SAFE if It's 99.99% Lead-Free . . . But Don't Tell the EPA
Labels:
100 ppm Lead Limit,
AAP,
Consumer Groups,
CPSC Leadership,
Retroactivity,
Senators
Thursday, July 14, 2011
CPSIA - Sound Bite Justice
Today the CPSC Commission voted 3-2 to impose the 100 ppm lead standard retroactively as of August 14, 2011, having concluded that there are no materials or products that the CPSC staff could identify for which this level of lead is not "technologically feasible". This vote has been long predicted and anticipated. The entire meeting was conducted in a thoroughly partisan manner, with sharp dividing lines between Dems and Republicans. What-a-shock.
I experienced a range of emotions watching this two-hour hearing. None of them were surprise. I experienced some boredom, as the debate was so predictable and so repetitive of past meetings. Many self-serving remarks by the Dem zealots. I experienced a mild sense of hopelessness, as it is clear that the Dems are unreachable. I experienced rising exasperation over their refusal to listen or consider data - unless it agrees with pre-existing agendas and alliances. It is hard to not feel you are appearing before the Hanging Judge.
I won't attempt to analyze what was really going on today, you already know it. The posturing was sickening among the Dems. That said, you deserve some flavor of the event. Here are a few tidbits for your amusement or annoyance:
She's just the nicest!
Inez Tenenbaum explained that the 100 ppm standard would have gone into effect if the CPSC had not chosen to decide the question of "technological feasibility". As she sees it, "this [decision] is a courtesy to people."
What, Boeing isn't covered by the CPSIA?!
After vigorously stating her case on the cost-benefit analysis of this rule and condemning the possible adoption of this rule as a violation of the recent Executive Order applicable to the CPSC, Ms. Nord restates the obvious. Unfortunately, the power of her logic was lost on at least three of her colleagues by my estimate: "Just because a material is out there for a jet plane, doesn't mean that it's appropriate for a toy plane." No!
Is that a promise, Bob?
Defending caveman logic to his followers, Bob Adler rebuffed the Executive Order argument and the order of the person who appointed him to his post: "This is not a new Executive Order . . . . [They] said could you at least do a plan for economic analysis and I do think that we are planning on doing that and we have done that in the past. It says "to the extent permitted by law" we should do cost-benefit analysis. And I just wanted to say over my dead body would I agree to do the kind of cost-benefit analysis that is contained in Section 9 of the [CPSA]. That is paralysis by analysis. If you look at the data . . . nine [CPSC] standards in 30 years using those procedures. I am not against cost-benefit analysis; I am definitely against the kind of cost-benefit analysis that's contained in our statute. Section 101 does not EXPLICITLY bar a cost-benefit analysis but it effectively does so." [Emphasis added]
I find this rather interesting as he challenged me on February 16 with the question of whether I recommended that he violate the law. It was a tense moment - he was trying to corner me into telling him to spurn his Congressional mandate. Nevertheless, it is appears that Bob can pick and choose which laws bind him and which do not. That shouldn't surprise anyone who went to law school. Law school profs always know the right answer, even if it makes no sense to anyone but themselves.
They care sooooo much, they really feel our pain . . . .
Ms. Tenenbaum set the records straight on the purity of her good intentions: "I so believe that we have been diligent in looking at the marketplace and surveying materials. We have admitted it would be an extra cost to some companies and been out front. But, again, 'technological feasibility' the definition is not 'economic feasibility'. Not that I don't sympathize with small business owners and that is why we have worked on other rules [like the component part rule]. We are trying to be as flexible as possible and work with small businesses and the industry to accomplish what Congress mandated for us to do."
I know it's just a detail but in the last three years, what exactly has this "effort" achieved? Oh yeah, I forgot about Neal Cohen - we can cry on his shoulder! In fact, Ms. T. closed the event with the offer that Cohen has his box of Kleenex ready for you whenever you need him.
Somebody's getting the shaft, let the record reflect.
Nancy Nord noticed something the Dems must have missed: "You know, one of the things that is of concern to me is that the penultimate recommendation from the staff here is that 'complying materials APPEAR to be commercially available for most products.' Listen to the hedge words there in the staff recommendation. They 'appear to be'? Well, let's find out for sure and let's do it on a product category basis. 'Most products'? Well, what about the ones that can't meet it? That's our responsibility as [regulators], colleagues."
Hmmm.
Professor Adler grades the final exam.
Bob Adler was in top form today. The "over my dead body" remark was just an appetizer. He went on to inform us that comment letters which arrive late are not operative, especially if they did not properly read his mind on what he wanted to see:
"I do want to also comment on some of the last minute submissions we got from our friends in industry, and I always appreciate those comments and I do consider a lot of these folks to be good friends both of this agency and of mine. But it's really hard to take it seriously when it comes in at the penultimate or ultimate moment when you've had a lot of time to get that kind of information to us. . . . [Recites all the opportunities to comment prior to this hearing.] All of that, if you want to make a point, would have been very helpful especially we'd had the kind of hard quantitative data that SGS and the Hong Kong-American Chamber of Commerce gave us. And I'm going to just make a brief comment = you're free to do it, it's not helpful to tell us we've read the law incorrectly. I think we've read it correctly. I don't think it's helpful just to tell us that it's going to be difficult and more expensive to get compliant materials. I think we know that, I think the staff told us that. What we needed was more hard data demonstrating the points that you're making because what we really got were a lot of conclusory assertions when what we really needed was some hard quantitative data. And all the hard quantitative data I've seen really points in the opposite direction. So I really appreciate all the last minute comments. Too little, too late as far as I am concerned." [Emphasis added]
This lecture was repeated three times by Mr. Adler unprompted, for reasons best understood by him. Interestingly, Mr. Adler seems to have forgotten that I presented hard quantitative data on this same topic in my timely-filed 100 ppm comment letter and in my Febuary 16 testimony. Of course, it did not agree with the SGS or HKACC submissions. I guess since he found their data useful, mine must have been wrong. According to his remarks today, I didn't even submit it, which is rather surprising since it was discussed extensively in the Staff report: "Learning Resources reported 98.3 percent compliance with the 100 ppm standard for its products, but found this compliance level to be unacceptable because of the difficulty in identifying where the noncomplying components would turn up."
Bob Adler flips his flop.
You would think with three repetitions of his condescending lecture on late submissions, that Professor Adler must mean it. Can't get a good grade in his class with that behavior, right? Well, maybe not for the teacher's pet: "One very quick point, well two. One is that the [AAP] study you shared with us, and again thank you so much Commissioner Northup, is a 2005 study. We got a letter last night from the American Academy of Pediatrics reiterating their support for moving down to these levels. . . . "
Bob Adler wings it. . . .
In the face of a vigorous attack by a well-prepared Anne Northup on the shoddy scientific data presented by the AAP supporting the "no safe level of lead" assertion, Mr. Adler lapses into hyperbole and fantastic assertions incapable of validation:
"It isn't just the [AAP]. A lot of what they've done has been drawn from research done around the world on the effects of lead. I'll bet there must be ten thousand, I know there are thousands and thousands of studies on lead, all of which point to the very severe toxic effects associated with [these products]."
Mother knows best!
In a truly shocking display of personal preference substituting for appropriate policy and regulation, Ms. Tenenbaum decided that we don't need recycled materials in children's products because who would want them anyway?
"The scientific community has shown us over and over again that lead is cumulative and so I think there are safety benefits in reducing the exposure to lead and the accumulation of lead in the body. Also, I don't know that parents are interested in having products that their children use, particularly infants and young children, that are mouthable being made of recycled materials, recycled materials that may contain a higher level of lead. Recycled plastic - do you want your child to have a recycled pacifier? Well, that is why Congress has set these strict limits."
[Full disclosure, we recently won a toy industry award for environmentally-friendly toys made of recycled plastic. No one has objected to them to my knowledge, and believe me, they are wonderfully and thoroughly tested for compliance.]
And the support for Ms. T's bald assertion is . . . what? Did she find something in the legislative record? Is there some verbiage in the law? I have not heard this previously from anyone at the CPSC but notably I have repeatedly noted that the CPSIA will be the death of recycled materials in children's products. Still, Ms. T's logic is irresistible - she is there to figure these things out for us and certainly knows best. After all, she loves children, probably much more than any of us. She cares. What else do you need to know? With her power to impose policy, her preferences will become our marketplace. Brave New World, courtesy of the Nanny Staters.
Tenenbaum says you can ALWAYS file for an exemption!
Ms. T. reminded the audience at least four times that if they wanted to, they could ALWAYS file for an exemption if they can prove their product or material can't be made to the new standard subject to the non-economic technological feasibility test. The door is always open . . . .
This promise seems to be in denial of reality. Let's start with the fact that the CPSC staff studied this question for more than a year and concluded, as summarized in a 59-page tome, that EVERYTHING is technologically feasible. That seems to put us all against the wall when it comes to exemption petitions. And then there's the fact that for three years, nobody has been able to get an exemption for anything, regardless of how obvious the case, unthreatening the use or how well-funded the supplicant.
Notes Ms. Northup: "I just think we should warn the public that it is unlikely that any petition would be accepted and that that is, first of all, for anybody to file it would be far more costly than to just pay for the materials and increase the cost of their products in all likelihood, not to mention the delay they would have in us in actually addressing their petition."
And Nancy Nord speculates that petitions for relief are highly unlikely in any event: "I will just tell you, in my conversations with folks out there, there is a feeling that 'why bother?' There is a comment weariness, there is a sense that it isn't worth the candle, and so I guess if you're not a company that's either been put out of business or not making the product, you don't have the money to hire the lawyer to file the petition. So I think that's just an empty option for most people."
Who do you believe? Hey, as Ms. T says, the door's always open even if it's the door to oblivion.
The outcome of the decision to implement the 100 ppm standard was foretold but let's not forget something important - this is a retroactive rule as implemented today. Unless Congress acts, we are all in the soup. Even worse than before. Call your Congressman and don't stop until they take action. Mr. Obama must sign something by August 14 or all hell breaks out . . . again.
I experienced a range of emotions watching this two-hour hearing. None of them were surprise. I experienced some boredom, as the debate was so predictable and so repetitive of past meetings. Many self-serving remarks by the Dem zealots. I experienced a mild sense of hopelessness, as it is clear that the Dems are unreachable. I experienced rising exasperation over their refusal to listen or consider data - unless it agrees with pre-existing agendas and alliances. It is hard to not feel you are appearing before the Hanging Judge.
I won't attempt to analyze what was really going on today, you already know it. The posturing was sickening among the Dems. That said, you deserve some flavor of the event. Here are a few tidbits for your amusement or annoyance:
She's just the nicest!
Inez Tenenbaum explained that the 100 ppm standard would have gone into effect if the CPSC had not chosen to decide the question of "technological feasibility". As she sees it, "this [decision] is a courtesy to people."
What, Boeing isn't covered by the CPSIA?!
After vigorously stating her case on the cost-benefit analysis of this rule and condemning the possible adoption of this rule as a violation of the recent Executive Order applicable to the CPSC, Ms. Nord restates the obvious. Unfortunately, the power of her logic was lost on at least three of her colleagues by my estimate: "Just because a material is out there for a jet plane, doesn't mean that it's appropriate for a toy plane." No!
Is that a promise, Bob?
Defending caveman logic to his followers, Bob Adler rebuffed the Executive Order argument and the order of the person who appointed him to his post: "This is not a new Executive Order . . . . [They] said could you at least do a plan for economic analysis and I do think that we are planning on doing that and we have done that in the past. It says "to the extent permitted by law" we should do cost-benefit analysis. And I just wanted to say over my dead body would I agree to do the kind of cost-benefit analysis that is contained in Section 9 of the [CPSA]. That is paralysis by analysis. If you look at the data . . . nine [CPSC] standards in 30 years using those procedures. I am not against cost-benefit analysis; I am definitely against the kind of cost-benefit analysis that's contained in our statute. Section 101 does not EXPLICITLY bar a cost-benefit analysis but it effectively does so." [Emphasis added]
I find this rather interesting as he challenged me on February 16 with the question of whether I recommended that he violate the law. It was a tense moment - he was trying to corner me into telling him to spurn his Congressional mandate. Nevertheless, it is appears that Bob can pick and choose which laws bind him and which do not. That shouldn't surprise anyone who went to law school. Law school profs always know the right answer, even if it makes no sense to anyone but themselves.
They care sooooo much, they really feel our pain . . . .
Ms. Tenenbaum set the records straight on the purity of her good intentions: "I so believe that we have been diligent in looking at the marketplace and surveying materials. We have admitted it would be an extra cost to some companies and been out front. But, again, 'technological feasibility' the definition is not 'economic feasibility'. Not that I don't sympathize with small business owners and that is why we have worked on other rules [like the component part rule]. We are trying to be as flexible as possible and work with small businesses and the industry to accomplish what Congress mandated for us to do."
I know it's just a detail but in the last three years, what exactly has this "effort" achieved? Oh yeah, I forgot about Neal Cohen - we can cry on his shoulder! In fact, Ms. T. closed the event with the offer that Cohen has his box of Kleenex ready for you whenever you need him.
Somebody's getting the shaft, let the record reflect.
Nancy Nord noticed something the Dems must have missed: "You know, one of the things that is of concern to me is that the penultimate recommendation from the staff here is that 'complying materials APPEAR to be commercially available for most products.' Listen to the hedge words there in the staff recommendation. They 'appear to be'? Well, let's find out for sure and let's do it on a product category basis. 'Most products'? Well, what about the ones that can't meet it? That's our responsibility as [regulators], colleagues."
Hmmm.
Professor Adler grades the final exam.
Bob Adler was in top form today. The "over my dead body" remark was just an appetizer. He went on to inform us that comment letters which arrive late are not operative, especially if they did not properly read his mind on what he wanted to see:
"I do want to also comment on some of the last minute submissions we got from our friends in industry, and I always appreciate those comments and I do consider a lot of these folks to be good friends both of this agency and of mine. But it's really hard to take it seriously when it comes in at the penultimate or ultimate moment when you've had a lot of time to get that kind of information to us. . . . [Recites all the opportunities to comment prior to this hearing.] All of that, if you want to make a point, would have been very helpful especially we'd had the kind of hard quantitative data that SGS and the Hong Kong-American Chamber of Commerce gave us. And I'm going to just make a brief comment = you're free to do it, it's not helpful to tell us we've read the law incorrectly. I think we've read it correctly. I don't think it's helpful just to tell us that it's going to be difficult and more expensive to get compliant materials. I think we know that, I think the staff told us that. What we needed was more hard data demonstrating the points that you're making because what we really got were a lot of conclusory assertions when what we really needed was some hard quantitative data. And all the hard quantitative data I've seen really points in the opposite direction. So I really appreciate all the last minute comments. Too little, too late as far as I am concerned." [Emphasis added]
This lecture was repeated three times by Mr. Adler unprompted, for reasons best understood by him. Interestingly, Mr. Adler seems to have forgotten that I presented hard quantitative data on this same topic in my timely-filed 100 ppm comment letter and in my Febuary 16 testimony. Of course, it did not agree with the SGS or HKACC submissions. I guess since he found their data useful, mine must have been wrong. According to his remarks today, I didn't even submit it, which is rather surprising since it was discussed extensively in the Staff report: "Learning Resources reported 98.3 percent compliance with the 100 ppm standard for its products, but found this compliance level to be unacceptable because of the difficulty in identifying where the noncomplying components would turn up."
Bob Adler flips his flop.
You would think with three repetitions of his condescending lecture on late submissions, that Professor Adler must mean it. Can't get a good grade in his class with that behavior, right? Well, maybe not for the teacher's pet: "One very quick point, well two. One is that the [AAP] study you shared with us, and again thank you so much Commissioner Northup, is a 2005 study. We got a letter last night from the American Academy of Pediatrics reiterating their support for moving down to these levels. . . . "
Bob Adler wings it. . . .
In the face of a vigorous attack by a well-prepared Anne Northup on the shoddy scientific data presented by the AAP supporting the "no safe level of lead" assertion, Mr. Adler lapses into hyperbole and fantastic assertions incapable of validation:
"It isn't just the [AAP]. A lot of what they've done has been drawn from research done around the world on the effects of lead. I'll bet there must be ten thousand, I know there are thousands and thousands of studies on lead, all of which point to the very severe toxic effects associated with [these products]."
Mother knows best!
In a truly shocking display of personal preference substituting for appropriate policy and regulation, Ms. Tenenbaum decided that we don't need recycled materials in children's products because who would want them anyway?
"The scientific community has shown us over and over again that lead is cumulative and so I think there are safety benefits in reducing the exposure to lead and the accumulation of lead in the body. Also, I don't know that parents are interested in having products that their children use, particularly infants and young children, that are mouthable being made of recycled materials, recycled materials that may contain a higher level of lead. Recycled plastic - do you want your child to have a recycled pacifier? Well, that is why Congress has set these strict limits."
[Full disclosure, we recently won a toy industry award for environmentally-friendly toys made of recycled plastic. No one has objected to them to my knowledge, and believe me, they are wonderfully and thoroughly tested for compliance.]
And the support for Ms. T's bald assertion is . . . what? Did she find something in the legislative record? Is there some verbiage in the law? I have not heard this previously from anyone at the CPSC but notably I have repeatedly noted that the CPSIA will be the death of recycled materials in children's products. Still, Ms. T's logic is irresistible - she is there to figure these things out for us and certainly knows best. After all, she loves children, probably much more than any of us. She cares. What else do you need to know? With her power to impose policy, her preferences will become our marketplace. Brave New World, courtesy of the Nanny Staters.
Tenenbaum says you can ALWAYS file for an exemption!
Ms. T. reminded the audience at least four times that if they wanted to, they could ALWAYS file for an exemption if they can prove their product or material can't be made to the new standard subject to the non-economic technological feasibility test. The door is always open . . . .
This promise seems to be in denial of reality. Let's start with the fact that the CPSC staff studied this question for more than a year and concluded, as summarized in a 59-page tome, that EVERYTHING is technologically feasible. That seems to put us all against the wall when it comes to exemption petitions. And then there's the fact that for three years, nobody has been able to get an exemption for anything, regardless of how obvious the case, unthreatening the use or how well-funded the supplicant.
Notes Ms. Northup: "I just think we should warn the public that it is unlikely that any petition would be accepted and that that is, first of all, for anybody to file it would be far more costly than to just pay for the materials and increase the cost of their products in all likelihood, not to mention the delay they would have in us in actually addressing their petition."
And Nancy Nord speculates that petitions for relief are highly unlikely in any event: "I will just tell you, in my conversations with folks out there, there is a feeling that 'why bother?' There is a comment weariness, there is a sense that it isn't worth the candle, and so I guess if you're not a company that's either been put out of business or not making the product, you don't have the money to hire the lawyer to file the petition. So I think that's just an empty option for most people."
Who do you believe? Hey, as Ms. T says, the door's always open even if it's the door to oblivion.
The outcome of the decision to implement the 100 ppm standard was foretold but let's not forget something important - this is a retroactive rule as implemented today. Unless Congress acts, we are all in the soup. Even worse than before. Call your Congressman and don't stop until they take action. Mr. Obama must sign something by August 14 or all hell breaks out . . . again.
Labels:
100 ppm Lead Limit,
CPSC Leadership,
Lead,
Nanny State,
Testing
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
CPSIA - Alliance for Children's Product Safety Reacts to 100 ppm Decision
The Alliance for Children's Product Safety, a coalition of small business owners, manufacturers, crafters and entrepreneurs who are impacted by the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA), issued the following statement regarding the CPSC's passage of the 100 ppm for lead content rule today by a vote of 3-2.
"Today, just three days after President Obama issued an Executive Order instructing the CPSC and other independent agencies to examine all rules for ineffective and unnecessary burdens and instructed the agency that decisions should be made only after consideration of the costs and benefits of new regulations, the CPSC enacted yet another costly rule that will do nothing to improve product safety but will cause further job losses in the children’s product market. The CPSC has already acknowledged that businesses will not be able to meet the 100 ppm lead standard without cost and disruption, and that consistent compliance with the new standard will be nearly impossible due to material and inter-lab variability and regulatory uncertainty. Most importantly, overwhelming costs imposed by the new standard will disproportionately affect smaller companies. On the other side of the ledger, the CPSC admits the health benefits of the new standard will be 'minimal'.
President Obama's Executive Order states 'Wise regulatory decisions depend on public participation and on careful analysis of the likely consequences of regulation. . . . To the extent permitted by law, such decisions should be made only after consideration of their costs and benefits (both quantitative and qualitative).' The President’s order notes the duty of the CPSC to regulate for public health and safety 'while promoting economic growth, innovation, competitiveness, and job creation.' The new rule fails Mr. Obama’s test.
It is disappointing that the majority of CPSC Commissioners ignored the explicit terms of the President’s order governing regulatory excess. The 100 ppm standard is a prime example of the economic self-destruction caused by the CPSIA: the imposition of costly and burdensome regulations that don’t improve product safety. It is now up to Congress to fix the numerous 'unintended consequences' of the CPSIA before more small businesses are forced to go out of businesses and more jobs are lost."
The Alliance for Children's Product Safety, Chaired by Rick Woldenberg, is a coalition of small business owners, manufacturers, crafters and entrepreneurs who are impacted by the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA). For additional information, please visit www.AmendTheCPSIA.com or contact Caitlin Andrews at 202-828-7637.
"Today, just three days after President Obama issued an Executive Order instructing the CPSC and other independent agencies to examine all rules for ineffective and unnecessary burdens and instructed the agency that decisions should be made only after consideration of the costs and benefits of new regulations, the CPSC enacted yet another costly rule that will do nothing to improve product safety but will cause further job losses in the children’s product market. The CPSC has already acknowledged that businesses will not be able to meet the 100 ppm lead standard without cost and disruption, and that consistent compliance with the new standard will be nearly impossible due to material and inter-lab variability and regulatory uncertainty. Most importantly, overwhelming costs imposed by the new standard will disproportionately affect smaller companies. On the other side of the ledger, the CPSC admits the health benefits of the new standard will be 'minimal'.
President Obama's Executive Order states 'Wise regulatory decisions depend on public participation and on careful analysis of the likely consequences of regulation. . . . To the extent permitted by law, such decisions should be made only after consideration of their costs and benefits (both quantitative and qualitative).' The President’s order notes the duty of the CPSC to regulate for public health and safety 'while promoting economic growth, innovation, competitiveness, and job creation.' The new rule fails Mr. Obama’s test.
It is disappointing that the majority of CPSC Commissioners ignored the explicit terms of the President’s order governing regulatory excess. The 100 ppm standard is a prime example of the economic self-destruction caused by the CPSIA: the imposition of costly and burdensome regulations that don’t improve product safety. It is now up to Congress to fix the numerous 'unintended consequences' of the CPSIA before more small businesses are forced to go out of businesses and more jobs are lost."
The Alliance for Children's Product Safety, Chaired by Rick Woldenberg, is a coalition of small business owners, manufacturers, crafters and entrepreneurs who are impacted by the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA). For additional information, please visit www.AmendTheCPSIA.com or contact Caitlin Andrews at 202-828-7637.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
