Friday, August 7, 2009

CPSIA - Walmart's Own Tracking Label Guidance

Not surprisingly, in view of the chaotic and rushed introduction of Section 103 tracking labels guidance by the CPSC, major retailers have been forced to implement their own versions of tracking labels in the hope that their work will suffice. And you thought only weather forecasters made a living by guessing!

I have attached Walmart's tracking labels guidance for your review (1, 2 and 3). It doesn't match the CPSC guidance, which is no surprise in large part because Walmart was able to publish theirs in May, while the CPSC could only squeeze out some guidance in late July. The Walmart guidance tries to be friendly and unthreatening, noting that these guidelines only apply if you haven't developed your own approach. That said, their guidance is very specific and provides conclusions that do not correlate to the CPSC outcomes. In Walmart's defense, they are not well-known to be CPSC mind readers, so some variance from the later guidance could be anticipated. If you are selling to Walmart, who's guidance will you follow? And if you happen to have other customers who also have their own plans of action? Can you picture a fair bit of completely wasted and pointless activity by manufacturers trying to align every customers' requirements?

I thought the Walmart decision trees were particularly amusing. They each look like a beginning decision tree for how to build the Space Shuttle. I see a decision tree like that and I try to find something else to do. . . . Walmart also provides some interesting photo illustrations of tracking label cases, with the "right" decisions indicated. I am not so sure I agree with all their calls. No matter, it's all clear as a bell now with the CPSC's guidance, right?

CPSIA - Riffing on Rocks

Now that rocks must be tested (by us humans, not by their manufacturer, the Almighty) for compliance with lead standards, it's also necessary to make sure they comply with ASTM F963. In another magnificent gift to mankind, Congress elected to convert ASTM F963, a perfectly good and workable voluntary safety standard into law as part of the CPSIA. This wasn't necessary. As Chairman Tenenbaum noted in her recent APEC speech: "The U.S. experience with safety standards has been that you get a great deal of product safety by relying on voluntary consensus standards coupled with regulatory authority to intervene quickly. In fact, my agency's statutes set a preference for voluntary standards over mandatory regulations. This places a lot of responsibility on industry." Imagine, another sign of excess in Congress' handiwork . . . .

Congress' grand gesture also wasn't helpful. Violations of the formerly voluntary standard now require an urgent report to be filed within 24 hours under Section 15(b). Let's be clear, ANY violation of ANY provision of just about ANY product safety law requires the emergency filing of a report to the CPSC as though the world is coming to an end. There is no materiality standard. In my next lifetime, please do not assign me to the department responsible for processing Section 15(b) filings at the CPSC.

Rocks, you may realize, are included in school science kits and also in toys. Once upon a time, we used rocks to learn about the environment and nature. Rocks happen to be present in our environment, no fault of ours but perhaps the Almighty had some purpose in mind. I imagine He thought rocks would inspire some kind of really cool law. And it did! In this case, if foolish educational companies want to sell rocks to schools or for inclusion in educational kits sold in toy stores, they must now test the rocks not only for lead but also for sharp points. Yes, rocks with sharp points need to be restricted under ASTM F963 for children aged eight years old or younger. The CPSC has yet to issue guidance to millions of curious Americans on how to manage this exposure when walking to the park or playing catch with the dog in the backyard.

Think of rocks you have seen. There are skipping rocks, those don't have sharp points. Those are kosher, presumably, if they pass the lead test. Other rocks, like shale, mica, magnetite, etc., are a bit more ragged in appearance, not to mention being dicey legally. They will probably fail the "sharp points" test under F963. Not only does that make them illegal, but it also could potentially trigger a Section 15(b) report and thereby a recall of the rocks. If you sell rocks for a living or as part of an educational business, how do you react to this kind of rule? Some options: (a) retool your kit around smooth stones (forget the educational value), (b) hand pick "good" rocks for each kit or sand the rocks down, (c) sell posters or picture cards of rocks, or (d) I have no idea what.

Rock suppliers cannot guarantee that rocks won't have sharp edges. They are rocks, after all. Suppliers will also swallow hard before testing rocks in a laboratory. It will be hard for them to deal with snickering employees of testing labs quoting on the latest load of rock tests, not to mention paying the bill. Many will just skip the tests and possibly the entire market. Posters will be our means of teaching Earth Science. I am sure the Chinese, Japanese and Germans are having a good laugh about the self-destruction we are merrily implementing to their benefit.

And if you have a problem, what are you supposed to do with all the deadly rocks? It would certainly not be very public-spirited to put such dangerous items in the city dump. Perhaps we should send them to Congress?

Is there a testing standard for rocks in the head? Is the concern lead, sharp points or that irritating rattling noise? I certainly hope there are vigorous use and abuse tests for rocks in the head - perhaps all the shaking might make somebody wake up.

CPSIA - Resale Shop Handbook Reissued

The CPSC revised its Resale Shop Handbook this week. The dancing and weaving continues as the CPSC tries to keep Resale Shops and Consignment Stores in the kid business while trying to scare them out of selling recalled products. This micro-problem has been made a TOP priority and obsession of the agency by our dear friends in Congress and the consumer groups, resulting in the devastation of the market.

Here's a great example of the CPSC's efforts to "reassure" these small businesses: "You are not required to test your products for safety. However, resellers (including those who sell on auction Web sites) cannot knowingly sell products that do not meet the requirements of the law. You can protect yourself by screening for violative products. Ignorance of the law is not an excuse." How comforting!

More stern warnings to get the "point" across: "If you should happen to sell or offer for sale a product in violation of the CPSIA or other law, CPSC’s response will vary depending upon the circumstances, including the nature of the product defect, the number of products, the severity of the risk of injury associated with the product and the type of violation. The Commission’s response would also take into account the fact that you may be a small business." Clearly, they are going to be friendly . . . unless they decide not to. The CPSC's friendly Enforcement officers will decide later, thank you.

The unrealistic, almost delusional advice goes on: "Under the new law, it is now illegal to sell ANY recalled product (for adults as well as children). If you are in the business of reselling products, you are expected to know the laws, rules and regulations that apply to your business, including whether or not a product you are selling has been recalled for a safety issue. Before taking a product into inventory or selling it, check the CPSC Web site for dangerous recalled products, including cribs, play yards, strollers, high chairs, toys with magnets, toys that are choking hazards, and other products. You can search by product type, company name, product description, hazard, country of manufacture and by the month and year in which the recall took place."

Or, here's a labor-saving shortcut: stop selling children's products! The CPSC continues: "Resellers, in particular, need to make sound business decisions about the products they sell. As a practical matter, you can: (a) Test the product (though not required); (b) Not accept the product; (c) Use your best judgment based on your knowledge of the product; or (d) Contact the manufacturer about questionable products." At least you have options.

The new handbook includes a nice list of what to sell and not sell. Bikes are okay to sell for two years, that's it. Jewelry, resale shops are supposed to stay away from. Old books (pre-1985) are ONLY okay to sell if they are collector's items. Otherwise, toss 'em! [Perhaps a lovely bonfire is called for. Some people LOVED book burning in the '30's.] "Clothes with rhinestones, metal or vinyl/plastic snaps, zippers, grommets, closures or appliqués" are also on the "don't sell" list. Of course, anything can be sold if the resale shop tests it (won't ever happen even IF it were affordable - safety testing is destructive).

As to phthalates, dreaded phthalates, what's a person to do? "How can I tell if a product contains a prohibited phthalate? As with lead, you are not required to test your products for phthalates or to certify that they do not contain prohibited phthalates. There is, however, no easy way to tell whether a product contains a phthalate or what kind of phthalate it contains. Unlike lead, where there is a reliable screening tool (the X-ray Fluorescence machine), there is not a screening device to detect the presence of phthalates." Now that just builds retailer confidence! I can foresee a very healthy market for . . . for . . . my vision just got blurry, sorry.

I recently learned that Washington, D.C. and Bethesda, MD are both located on Mars, so perhaps the folks behind this document are unaware of the nature of resale and consignment shops. Resale shops are not perhaps the most profitable businesses on Earth and tend to have low-paid staff. I have heard of chains of stores with managers receiving minimum wage. If you run an entity operating on thin margins staffed by poorly paid workers, what is the likelihood that ANY of the foregoing can be handled adequately? Nil. In addition, many owners of these stores don't have time for the absurd recommendations in this handbook. As a group, they are quite worried about liability. The stories about resale shops closing their children's departments are true (see this article, too). The advice in this handbook will not reverse or halt the terrible shrinkage in this market. Should we care? Yes, quite a bit. Many families depend on thrift stores for their basic needs (including clothing). The wreckage of this market will keep kids shivering during the cold winter ahead. We should all feel ashamed.

The CPSC is doing its job, but it's a terrible assignment. It's supposed to implement the laws written by Congress, stupid or not, and that's what it is doing. Nonetheless, its leadership needs to work harder to force Congress to rewrite the CPSIA. The havoc wrought by this law is creating carnage everywhere you look. Being a good soldier in Mr. Waxman's army just won't cut it. We all need to stand up and get our country back again, even the paid employees and managers of the CPSC.