Does anyone in Congress give a darn about how their laws affect those of us in the real world? Given that it seems clear that they don't read the laws they vote for, and seem to prefer a good sound bite to listening or helping on real problems, I think the answer must be "no".
In the case of the noxious CPSIA, a recurrent theme in this blog and elsewhere is that the marketplace is going wild trying to anticipate the ridiculous strictures of the new law, regardless of how pointless, and that massive losses are resulting from the marketplace dislocations. This has been documented again and again, yet Congress refuses to face up to the damage being done.
A nice example of this effect is in the latest missive from Toys R Us. TRU has been a market leader in enthusiastically exceeding the CPSIA in strictures with no negotiation or seeming concern about impact on the marketplace. Today's announcement reads as follows (in part):
"1. Lead in Substrates
In our previous communications, we informed you that all products shipped to Toys “R”Us must meet our requirement of 300ppm for lead in substrate materials (Please note that lower levels are required for PVC, jewelry and other items). However, according to the CPSIA, that limit will be reduced to 100ppm on August 14, 2011, unless the CPSC determines that this is not technologically feasible.
In anticipation of this change, we will be tightening our requirements to 100ppm maximum lead in substrates, as of January 1, 2010 ."
So at TRU, the judgment has been made - 100 ppm is a done deal, and will now become the rule at TRU as of January 1. At least we have six months' notice so we can prepare for losing them as a customer.
Thanks Congress. Everyone is so safe now! Wow, what a wonderful feeling.
Wednesday, July 1, 2009
CPSIA - Who Will Stop the Insanity?
CPSIA - Lead Labels, Who Cares?
Some laws, like California's Proposition 65 and the infamous Illinois Lead Poisoning Protection Law (see my previous post) include labeling provisions to "inform the public" of the presence of various unwanted substances, even trace amounts. After all, it's the public's "right to know" that motivates these consumer protection laws. Sounds good, right? Well, if you are on the receiving end of this good work, it feels like business death. For instance, in the Illinois law (Section 6(b)), labeling is required if lead-in-paint on a toy exceeds 40 ppm. This is intentionally lower than the federal lead-in-paint standards of 90 ppm (as of August 14, 2009, that is) since Illinois is competing to win in the Race to the Bottom as the national leader in "being safe". The Illinois standard is also equivalent to national average of lead levels in DIRT. Yes, dirt (see the report of the American Academy of Pediatrics). Thus, the Illinois law does not make lead-in-paint levels above trace background lead levels illegal but does require that consumers be informed of these "elevated" lead levels in a helpful product label.
So, if you are the lucky manufacturer who has to label his/her products for lead levels that conform to the excessively precautionary federal standards in order to satisfy Illinois or California laws, will you survive the experience to tell the tale? I have argued in testimony to an Illinois House subcommittee that the answer is "no". Consumers will not ignore these labels and will treat your product as though it were poisonous or radioactive. This would not be good for business - to say the least. I, in fact, told the Attorney General's office in Illinois that this might prompt Illinois companies to relocate across the border into saner States like Wisconsin or Iowa.
My vivid imagination, right? Can you imagine the voices I must hear in my head?? Well, perhaps not. Read about the story of lip gloss at Target in Indiana where a recall of a legal, safe product was incited by a panicked consumer reading a Proposition 65 label in Indiana. You can't say you haven't heard it before. Feeling safer already?
Hey Congress - what if some of my other predictions come true, too? Are you ready to stand up before America and tell them that these terrible problems were your handiwork? Is that the Obama Revolution you want to foment?
So, if you are the lucky manufacturer who has to label his/her products for lead levels that conform to the excessively precautionary federal standards in order to satisfy Illinois or California laws, will you survive the experience to tell the tale? I have argued in testimony to an Illinois House subcommittee that the answer is "no". Consumers will not ignore these labels and will treat your product as though it were poisonous or radioactive. This would not be good for business - to say the least. I, in fact, told the Attorney General's office in Illinois that this might prompt Illinois companies to relocate across the border into saner States like Wisconsin or Iowa.
My vivid imagination, right? Can you imagine the voices I must hear in my head?? Well, perhaps not. Read about the story of lip gloss at Target in Indiana where a recall of a legal, safe product was incited by a panicked consumer reading a Proposition 65 label in Indiana. You can't say you haven't heard it before. Feeling safer already?
Hey Congress - what if some of my other predictions come true, too? Are you ready to stand up before America and tell them that these terrible problems were your handiwork? Is that the Obama Revolution you want to foment?
Labels:
AAP,
California,
Dirt,
Illinois,
Lead,
Proposition 65
CPSIA - Bedtime (Horror) Story
This recent post by Wacky Hermit tells the CPSIA saga told as a bedtime story. She also exposes the excesses of our own Illinois laws relating to lead, including the incredible (untested) rule that home searches have been authorized if your child or two children in your building test at or above CDC lead blood limits. Nice! Thank heavens for a government looking out for our own best interests. Perhaps the next rule will be that we have to leave a key under the welcome mat for helpful government inspectors whenever they feel the urge to check out the safe environment of our homes.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
